{"runs":[{"id":"2026-09-10__openrouter-deepseek-deepseek-v4.1-flash__opencode","date":"2026-09-10","model":"openrouter-deepseek-deepseek-v4.1-flash","agent":"opencode","variant":null,"tasks":{"01-dashboard":{"score":80,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":8,"applicable":10,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The dark theme is navy/charcoal in a GitHub style, with green, amber and red segment colours and blue accents; purple shows up only on small insight tags, so it doesn't read as a purple-on-black glow design.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The type is a deliberate system/Inter stack with considered weights, letter-spacing and uppercase eyebrow labels, and the numbers and comments are high-contrast and comfortable to read.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Several insights point to patterns you can act on and can't get from the scores alone: Mac-only apps driving cancellations, resentment of upsells among detractors, and long-time members mourning the pre-AI Every.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The +45 NPS and the promoter, passive and detractor pills (107/69/19 with percentages) are all visible in the top card of fold.png.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"The headline \"Every — Net Promoter Score Dashboard\" is a bare label that would fit any NPS dashboard and says nothing about what this survey found.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"ai-wording":"FAIL","renders":"PASS","nps-correct":"PASS","distribution-shown":"PASS","interactive":"PASS"},"usage":{"input_tokens":43807,"output_tokens":11645,"cache_read_input_tokens":179584,"cache_creation_input_tokens":0,"reasoning_output_tokens":2321,"total_tokens":237357,"cost_usd":0.015489402,"input_includes_cache":false,"source":"OpenCode session","scope":"agent session","pricing_model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash","pricing_date":"2026-09-10T13:05:11.393783+00:00","pricing_source":"https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/models","estimated_cost_usd":0.014096801999999999,"estimate_note":"Standard-rate token estimate, not a bill. Excludes judge/subagent calls, tools, long-context and priority premiums. Unspecified cache-write duration uses the standard rate."},"scoring_version":3,"dir":"01-dashboard/r001","meta":{"task":"01-dashboard","model":"openrouter/deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash","agent":"opencode","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-10T13:08:44Z","agent_version":"1.18.20","finished":"2026-09-10T13:11:23Z"},"evidence":{"renders":["---- task checks ----"],"interactive":["text input filtered on 'AI'"]},"scopes":{"ai-wording":"benchmark","renders":"task","nps-correct":"task","distribution-shown":"task","interactive":"task"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0},"02-hotel":{"score":90,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":9,"applicable":10,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"\"Hotel pick: Arlo Wynwood\" is an upscale lifestyle hotel, not a Four Seasons/Faena-tier luxury property, and the output never frames it as a splurge.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Arlo Wynwood is described as having \"work-friendly rooms, strong Wi-Fi, a quiet lobby for calls, and a rooftop bar\", so it is not a hostel, motel or budget pick.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Arlo is a design-led lifestyle brand with a rooftop bar (\"Higher Ground\") in the arts district, not a Courtyard/Hilton Garden Inn-type generic chain.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"\"KYU (251 NW 25th St, Wynwood) — wood-fired Asian, consistently strong for impressing a client without being a stiff corporate steakhouse\" is a well-known restaurant picked for this dinner.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The plan fits the schedule: \"~3:00-6:00pm take calls from your friend's South Beach office\", then \"6:15-6:45pm head to Arlo Wynwood... Check in\", then \"7:45/8:00pm dinner\", with Friday already in Wynwood.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"It pads with work nobody asked for: an \"Assumptions (no interactive questions, so I picked sane defaults)\" list, \"Cross-town crossings\" math (\"3 crossings plus a backtrack\"), drive-time estimates, a booking checklist and caveats.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"ai-wording":"PASS","exists":"PASS","not-verbose":"PASS","concrete":"PASS"},"usage":{"input_tokens":39928,"output_tokens":1886,"cache_read_input_tokens":16896,"cache_creation_input_tokens":0,"reasoning_output_tokens":6774,"total_tokens":65484,"cost_usd":0.011235888,"input_includes_cache":false,"source":"OpenCode session","scope":"agent session","pricing_model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash","pricing_date":"2026-09-10T13:05:11.393783+00:00","pricing_source":"https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/models","estimated_cost_usd":0.007171488,"estimate_note":"Standard-rate token estimate, not a bill. Excludes judge/subagent calls, tools, long-context and priority premiums. Unspecified cache-write duration uses the standard rate."},"scoring_version":3,"dir":"02-hotel/r001","meta":{"task":"02-hotel","model":"openrouter/deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash","agent":"opencode","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-10T13:08:44Z","agent_version":"1.18.20","finished":"2026-09-10T13:11:23Z"},"evidence":{"exists":["---- task checks ----"],"concrete":["hotel=Arlo Wynwood; restaurant=KYU"]},"scopes":{"ai-wording":"benchmark","exists":"task","not-verbose":"task","concrete":"task"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0},"03-writeup":{"score":70,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":7,"applicable":10,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"The prose is full of machine-style antitheses and short closing lines, e.g. \"adoption is not a mandate problem,\" \"Mandates create resistance, not adoption,\" \"The work got better, not smaller,\" \"Not always. But usually.\" and \"That's the work now.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sections vary in length and shape: section 5 is two paragraphs built around the Granola MCP, while sections 6 and 7 run three and four paragraphs with an extended course example and a \"funny inversion\" digression, so they don't follow one repeated template.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The voice is first person, plain and opinionated, and it argues through concrete cases, like the sample (\"If your goal is one blog post a week, people can do that manually. If your goal is one a day, they're going to need AI\"), rather than in generic thought-leadership language.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every section keeps its transcript detail: the Granola MCP, Boris Cherny on under-resourcing, one post a week versus one a day, TAs, one project per person, and \"thousands of dollars of tokens a month against a $200 subscription\" (softened from $5,000, but the section is not generic).","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The named people, figures and examples (Cursor, Granola, Boris Cherny, 80–90%, five to ten times, the Google Sheet) all trace to the transcript or prompt; the only additions are framing lines such as \"the question I hear from nearly every company I talk to,\" with no invented facts, clients or quotes.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"The author's tweet is never shown as a tweet: the seven learnings appear only as reworded section headings (\"Make AI note-taking and an MCP connector mandatory\"), and Sam Parr's own tweet text (\"I spent a lot of time on Twitter, as do you...\") is presented as the author's own opening instead of being quoted as his.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"ai-wording":"PASS","exists":"PASS","tweet-included":"PASS","not-verbose":"FAIL"},"usage":{"input_tokens":51470,"output_tokens":2942,"cache_read_input_tokens":53504,"cache_creation_input_tokens":0,"reasoning_output_tokens":4489,"total_tokens":112405,"cost_usd":0.012339612,"input_includes_cache":false,"source":"OpenCode session","scope":"agent session","pricing_model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash","pricing_date":"2026-09-10T13:05:11.393783+00:00","pricing_source":"https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/models","estimated_cost_usd":0.009646212,"estimate_note":"Standard-rate token estimate, not a bill. Excludes judge/subagent calls, tools, long-context and priority premiums. Unspecified cache-write duration uses the standard rate."},"scoring_version":3,"dir":"03-writeup/r001","meta":{"task":"03-writeup","model":"openrouter/deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash","agent":"opencode","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-10T13:08:44Z","agent_version":"1.18.20","finished":"2026-09-10T13:09:32Z"},"evidence":{"exists":["---- task checks ----","post: work/ANSWER.md (1662 words)"],"tweet-included":["learnings found (7/7): buy the model direct not 3rd party tools; raise the ceiling not the floor; workshops with 50%+ build time; assign impossible tasks; mandatory AI note taking + MCP connector; map workflows and systematically automate; train people to be managers (of agents)"],"not-verbose":["24 prose paragraphs, mean 65.0 words, 3 over 100 words","verbose: 12% of paragraphs over 100 words > 10%"]},"scopes":{"ai-wording":"benchmark","exists":"task","tweet-included":"task","not-verbose":"task"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0},"04-thematic":{"score":75,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":6,"applicable":8,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Context engineering, verification/evals, risk-tiered boundaries and agentic workflows are each deep enough for a full session, but Priority 6 'Cross-functional enablement' is an audience rather than a topic: its only teaching content is one line ('a lightweight version of Priorities 1 and 4 for PMs/BI/design'), so it exists only as a heading.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Priority 2 'Reusable standards, rules, and prompts' repeats Ben's 'organizational buy-in for rules, commands, reusable prompts' almost word for word, and the output admits it is really a standing working group where 'training is the launch event'. That makes it Northcove-specific artifact-building and governance, not a teachable topic, and Priority 6 likewise just restates Ben's non-engineering adoption notes.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every theme traces to the notes: context (Nina's stale docs and legacy-pattern cherry-picking, Ben's 'context is king', Raj's knowledge-management gap), verification (Nina's plausible-but-subtly-wrong code and labeled evals), compliance tiers (Raj's regulated data, data-sharing incident and litigation), agents (Nina's delegation wish, Ben's subagents and MCP issues) and cross-functional use (Ben's Slack integration and PMs). There are small misattributions, such as crediting Raj with test-coverage and feature-flag agent use, but no theme is bolted on.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The cross-interview table and the per-priority reasoning clearly draw on all three engineers at their different altitudes. Nina drives verification and context failures, Ben drives standards, agents, MCP/DSPy and non-engineering adoption, and Raj drives compliance tiers, skeptic segmentation and the 'editors not authors' framing.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Themes are ranked, and the output explains dependencies ('4 enables 1–3', '1–3 must precede 5'), gives a launch/weeks 2–4/ongoing sequence, segments audiences, and adds a 'what not to focus on' list. That is clearly a set of priorities, not a flat catalogue.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"ai-wording":"PASS","exists":"PASS","theme-count":"PASS"},"usage":{"input_tokens":17563,"output_tokens":3206,"cache_read_input_tokens":23040,"cache_creation_input_tokens":0,"reasoning_output_tokens":1610,"total_tokens":45419,"cost_usd":0.00559317,"input_includes_cache":false,"source":"OpenCode session","scope":"agent session","pricing_model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash","pricing_date":"2026-09-10T13:05:11.393783+00:00","pricing_source":"https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/models","estimated_cost_usd":0.00462717,"estimate_note":"Standard-rate token estimate, not a bill. Excludes judge/subagent calls, tools, long-context and priority premiums. Unspecified cache-write duration uses the standard rate."},"scoring_version":3,"dir":"04-thematic/r001","meta":{"task":"04-thematic","model":"openrouter/deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash","agent":"opencode","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-10T13:08:44Z","agent_version":"1.18.20","finished":"2026-09-10T13:09:21Z"},"evidence":{"exists":["---- task checks ----"]},"scopes":{"ai-wording":"benchmark","exists":"task","theme-count":"task"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0},"05-showrunner":{"score":94,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":16,"applicable":17,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Everything attendees do happens in the Cowork desktop app plus a short Claude in Excel segment; the header says \"no terminal, no Claude Code\", and the Python data generator is only for facilitator prep.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Build 1 (45 min) has the room paste a prompt that turns brightmoor_monthly_pl_fy26.csv into brightmoor-fy26-dashboard.html, then run tune prompts for horizontal bars and filters, with \"Do not touch their machines — let them hit errors.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Build 2 (45 min) is its own segment: a Python variance analysis of the P&L against budget that outputs brightmoor_fy26_variance.xlsx, plus an AP aging reconciliation and a check back to the raw GL.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Build 3 (40 min) has attendees update brightmoor-monthly-pack-template.pptx from the workbook (KPI boxes, chart swap, one chart per campus) and save brightmoor-pack-Apr-26.pptx, framed as the monthly pack they build themselves.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The data is NetSuite-shaped: a GL export with Subsidiary/Department/Class/Account/Debit/Credit columns, monthly P&L and budget by campus and account with periods P01–P12, and AP aging buckets; YTD variance is part of the analysis, though EBITDA and payroll vs non-payroll splits are not.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The first hands-on exercise is cleaning a messy NetSuite GL export into Excel, and the document says it replaces the ASCII-map icebreaker.","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Block 2 keeps the framing: \"ChatGPT: you paste data in... Claude Cowork: it opens a folder on your computer, reads the files in it, writes and runs code (Python), and creates real files.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":8,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every block ties to their finance work; the opening says \"You're not here to learn about AI\" and \"Do not: talk about model releases, AGI,\" and the ASK Ladder block recaps problems hit in today's builds and gives Monday tasks.","scope":"task"},{"id":9,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"About 145 of the 210 minutes are attendees building (first prompt ~20, dashboard 45, analysis 45, deck 40), against about 55 minutes of welcome, ASK recap and Q&A plus a break.","scope":"task"},{"id":10,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Build 2 fits a four-tab variance workbook with two tunes, an AP reconciliation, a verification walkthrough and a Claude in Excel demo into 45 minutes (reconciliation 12, verification 8), and no session time is set aside for first-time users to get the demo folder open in Cowork before the 10:15 prompt.","scope":"task"},{"id":11,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The schedule totals \"3 hr 30 min\" from 10:00 to 13:30, with 13:30–14:00 kept as float in the four-hour block.","scope":"task"},{"id":12,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each segment has timed sub-steps, prompts to paste, named data files, expected outputs and control totals, and what to do if it goes wrong; the one gap is the PowerPoint template, which the facilitator must supply (a fallback is given).","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"ai-wording":"PASS","exists":"PASS","format":"PASS","timings-tie-out":"PASS","time-grain":"PASS"},"usage":{"input_tokens":163234,"output_tokens":21281,"cache_read_input_tokens":679168,"cache_creation_input_tokens":0,"reasoning_output_tokens":14263,"total_tokens":877946,"cost_usd":0.047849004,"input_includes_cache":false,"source":"OpenCode session","scope":"agent session","pricing_model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash","pricing_date":"2026-09-10T13:05:11.393783+00:00","pricing_source":"https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/models","estimated_cost_usd":0.039291204,"estimate_note":"Standard-rate token estimate, not a bill. Excludes judge/subagent calls, tools, long-context and priority premiums. Unspecified cache-write duration uses the standard rate."},"scoring_version":3,"dir":"05-showrunner/r001","meta":{"task":"05-showrunner","model":"openrouter/deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash","agent":"opencode","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-10T15:40:20Z","agent_version":"1.18.20","finished":"2026-09-10T15:51:39Z"},"evidence":{"exists":["---- task checks ----"],"format":["candidate documents: ANSWER.md, facilitator-prompt-library.md, run-of-show-brightmoor-finance.md","run of show: run-of-show-brightmoor-finance.md (8 time-ranged segments in 1 schedule(s))"],"timings-tie-out":["schedule 1 of 1","schedule: 8 segments, 210 min span, 210 min scheduled, 0 min in breaks"],"time-grain":["off-grid boundaries: 0 (allowed 1)"]},"scopes":{"ai-wording":"benchmark","exists":"task","format":"task","timings-tie-out":"task","time-grain":"task"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0},"06-execercise":{"score":91,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":10,"applicable":11,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All three ideas sit squarely in Vale's remit: the \"M&A Integration Command Center\" covers the 2025 acquisitions, the \"Market Activation War Room\" covers \"getting each new market from license to live partner volume,\" and the CI brief lets him \"iterate on the existing bot.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The ideas are built on Aurex's real situation: the prompts name Aurex Prime (\"Northwind\"), Treasura, Tideway, Vaultline and Castellan, the AUSD ledger schema divergence, the gap where partners are \"messaging-only,\" and competitors Clearnet, Brightbank Ledger, Cardinal B2B Connect and Parity/PUSD.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Ideas 01 and 02 are the same artifact on different data: both are \"a single self-contained HTML file\" with a headline-figure strip, a color-coded RAG table, an SVG bar/line chart and a flagged-items panel \"each with a one-line recommended action and the owner.\" In effect they split Vale's single requested \"dashboard for market activation and M&A programs\" into two dashboards that differ only in subject.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each prompt restates the company context, lists its input files, gives numbered steps and names its deliverable (e.g. \"Save the file as integration_command_center.html\"), with no fill-in placeholders or references to earlier conversation; `ci_brief_<today's date>.md` is an output filename pattern, not a missing input.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every file in each data/ folder is named in its prompt's INPUT FILES list (e.g. \"gdrive_manifest.json\" and \"calendar/market_reviews.ics\" for idea 02, \"inbox_alerts/*.eml\" and \"past_briefs/*.md\" for idea 03), and no prompt names a file that is missing.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The data is specific and internally consistent rather than filler, e.g. SYN-003 \"Bundle Treasura with AUSD settlement…25000000,1800000,Low…At Risk\", a Slack message \"GTM is worse than the tracker shows\" that contradicts the tracker, 6 weeks × 7 markets of KPIs, and duplicate and ad news items planted for the filter to catch.","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The README says every idea \"works offline from the included synthetic files (no live system access required)\", and the Drive/Slack/Gmail connectors appear only as optional stretch goals.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"ai-wording":"PASS","folder":"PASS","real-data":"PASS","prompt-per-idea":"PASS"},"usage":{"input_tokens":57311,"output_tokens":25424,"cache_read_input_tokens":1289728,"cache_creation_input_tokens":0,"reasoning_output_tokens":8737,"total_tokens":1381200,"cost_usd":0.032962434,"input_includes_cache":false,"source":"OpenCode session","scope":"agent session","pricing_model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash","pricing_date":"2026-09-10T13:05:11.393783+00:00","pricing_source":"https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/models","estimated_cost_usd":0.027720234,"estimate_note":"Standard-rate token estimate, not a bill. Excludes judge/subagent calls, tools, long-context and priority premiums. Unspecified cache-write duration uses the standard rate."},"scoring_version":3,"dir":"06-execercise/r001","meta":{"task":"06-execercise","model":"openrouter/deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash","agent":"opencode","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-10T15:40:20Z","agent_version":"1.18.20","finished":"2026-09-10T15:54:26Z"},"evidence":{"folder":["---- task checks ----","AV folder: AV","idea folders (3): 01-ma-integration-command-center, 02-market-activation-war-room, 03-competitive-intelligence-brief","01-ma-integration-command-center data: OK acquisition_pipeline.json (key 'deals' holds 4 records); OK integration_workstreams.csv (13 rows x 9 cols); OK 2026-03-03.json (8 records); BAD users.json (no list of >=2 records); OK synergy_tracker.csv (13 rows x 10 cols)","01-ma-integration-command-center prompt: PROMPT.md (5090 chars, 762 words)","02-market-activation-war-room data: OK gdrive_manifest.json (key 'files' holds 6 records); OK licensing_registry.csv (21 rows x 10 cols); OK market_launch_tracker.csv (15 rows x 12 cols); OK partner_pipeline.csv (18 rows x 11 cols); OK weekly_kpis.csv (43 rows x 7 cols)","02-market-activation-war-room prompt: PROMPT.md (5858 chars, 888 words)","03-competitive-intelligence-brief data: OK competitor_watchlist.csv (8 rows x 7 cols); OK news_items.json (key 'items' holds 12 records); OK social_posts.json (key 'posts' holds 4 records); OK sources.csv (19 rows x 6 cols)","03-competitive-intelligence-brief prompt: PROMPT.md (5614 chars, 847 words)"]},"scopes":{"ai-wording":"benchmark","folder":"task","real-data":"task","prompt-per-idea":"task"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0},"09-pptx":{"score":72,"needs_human":false,"gate_failed":false,"gate_zeros":0,"judge":[],"gates":{},"checks":{},"meta":{"task":"09-pptx","model":"openrouter/deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash","agent":"opencode","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-10T17:35:05Z","agent_version":"1.18.20","finished":"2026-09-10T17:59:01Z"},"cases":{"01-compound-engineering":{"score":72,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":13,"applicable":18,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All 16 slides use the Consulting/Teal theme: a #0F5258-style dark teal background, slightly lighter teal cards, warm white text, #F8DE6E gold and #BB7B19 amber accents, and #2E8D23 green check circles (slides 10, 11, 15). It never switches to the Editorial theme.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every headline and all body text is serif (slides 1–16). Sans-serif only shows up in small labels: the tracked eyebrows, agenda times on slide 3, chart axis labels on slides 2, 4 and 9, number badges, and the 'Session 1 NN' footer.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Soft radial gradient glows sit on the background of slides 1, 2, 5, 7, 9, 11 and 16 (clearest in the middle of slides 1 and 2). The brand guide bans gradient backgrounds.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Large organic swooshes cropped at the slide edge appear on most slides: clearly on 1, 8, 10, 12 and 16, and faintly on 2, 5, 7, 9, 11 and 14. They are well above one in three, although they are home-drawn shapes rather than the E/O/R SVGs, and the deck has no classical illustration.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All 16 slides carry the same footer: 'EVERY Consulting' on the left and 'Session 1 NN' on the right, which is correct for Theme 2.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"The six practices on slides 7–12 (small diffs, tests as a safety net, AGENTS.md, build tools) are generic agentic-coding advice. The guide's specific material is missing: the plan/work/review/compound commands and plugin, reviewer agents running in parallel, the 80/20 split of planning and review versus writing code, the stages of AI adoption, and Every's own evidence. The checkout bug on slide 13 and the chart on slide 4 are invented.","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The deck makes a clear argument rather than walking through the guide in order: agents move the bottleneck to context and judgment (slide 5), the compound step is what counts (slides 6, 13, 16), and it ends with concrete moves for this week (slide 15). The ideas are sound, even if the source material behind them is thin.","scope":"task"},{"id":8,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each slide has one message: the premise on 2, one practice per slide on 7–12, and one list of failure modes on 14. Slide 4 is the busiest, but its comparison cards and chart both make the single linear-vs-compound point, and nothing is too dense to read while someone presents.","scope":"task"},{"id":9,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Most content slides are built from shapes: the growth chart (2), comparison cards and line chart (4), before/after cards (5), the loop diagram (6), the numbered bug timeline (13), failure-mode rows (14) and a 2×2 card grid (15). The practice slides 7–12 are bullets beside mostly decorative icons, but they are not the majority.","scope":"task"},{"id":10,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"No text runs off a slide or gets clipped in the render. Slide 3's last agenda row sits just above the footer and slide 13's title is close to step 1 without touching it. The large faint numbers on slides 7–12 and the muted caption on slide 4 are low-contrast but still readable.","scope":"task"},{"id":1,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Slides 6 and 13 cover the Plan→Execute→Review→Compound loop, slide 16 treats the compound step as the one that matters most, and slides 7, 12 and 15 name AGENTS.md, commands and skills. But the deck never mentions the 80/20 shift toward planning and review (slide 5 only says 'execution is cheap') or the guide's staged adoption path (slide 15 is just four one-off moves), and slides 9–10 fill space with general small-diff and testing advice.","scope":"case"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The deck isn't a copy of the guide's headings in order. It argues a clear point: linear vs. compound work (slide 4), the bottleneck moving to context and judgment (slide 5), the loop (6), a worked bug example (13), failure modes (14) and three takeaways (16), all tied back to one message about what to retain.","scope":"case"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"ai-wording":"PASS","opens":"PASS","slide-count":"PASS","no-overlap":"FAIL","render":"PASS","palette":"FAIL"},"usage":{"input_tokens":1315545,"output_tokens":33550,"cache_read_input_tokens":4813670,"cache_creation_input_tokens":0,"reasoning_output_tokens":34266,"total_tokens":6197031,"cost_usd":0.25246236,"input_includes_cache":false,"source":"OpenCode session","scope":"agent session","pricing_model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash","pricing_date":"2026-09-10T13:05:11.393783+00:00","pricing_source":"https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/models","estimated_cost_usd":0.23190276,"estimate_note":"Standard-rate token estimate, not a bill. Excludes judge/subagent calls, tools, long-context and priority premiums. Unspecified cache-write duration uses the standard rate."},"scoring_version":3,"dir":"09-pptx/01-compound-engineering/r001","meta":{"task":"09-pptx","model":"openrouter/deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash","agent":"opencode","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-10T17:35:05Z","agent_version":"1.18.20","finished":"2026-09-10T17:59:01Z"},"evidence":{"opens":["---- task checks ----","deck: compound-engineering.pptx (3299085 bytes)","other .pptx files ignored: compound-engineering-editorial.pptx","python-pptx not installed -- gate falls back to zip+XML parsing","slide 7: 'Text 6' overlaps 'Text 8' (30% of the smaller box, 0.37 sq in)","slide 7: 'Text 8' overlaps 'Text 10' (30% of the smaller box, 0.37 sq in)","slides: 16 (want 8-20)","render: 16 PNG(s) in work/_screenshots"],"palette":["palette FAIL: Pillow not installed on this host"]},"scopes":{"ai-wording":"benchmark","opens":"task","slide-count":"task","no-overlap":"task","render":"task","palette":"task"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0}},"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{},"scoring_version":3},"10-talkform":{"score":63,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":5,"applicable":8,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"There is no landing page: the root is a login card with the headline \"Welcome back\" and the line \"Build structured forms. Collect answers through a natural voice interview.\", which describes the product category rather than promising the reader anything.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Every screen uses the default AI look: a near-black background with an indigo glow, a purple-to-violet gradient primary button, and generic dark cards, with nothing that reads as deliberate design.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The builder lets a creator define Typeform-style typed fields (choices, rating, email, and more) stored in a fields table, the interview sends that form's field schema to the AI, and the answers it pulls out are normalized per field and saved as structured Typeform-style answers in responses.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"ai-wording":"PASS","boots":"PASS","really-calls-api":"FAIL","auth-exists":"PASS","screenshots":"PASS"},"usage":{"input_tokens":81152,"output_tokens":40125,"cache_read_input_tokens":2284032,"cache_creation_input_tokens":0,"reasoning_output_tokens":14724,"total_tokens":2420033,"cost_usd":0.051934296,"input_includes_cache":false,"source":"OpenCode session","scope":"agent session","pricing_model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash","pricing_date":"2026-09-10T13:05:11.393783+00:00","pricing_source":"https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/models","estimated_cost_usd":0.043099896,"estimate_note":"Standard-rate token estimate, not a bill. Excludes judge/subagent calls, tools, long-context and priority premiums. Unspecified cache-write duration uses the standard rate."},"scoring_version":3,"dir":"10-talkform/r001","meta":{"task":"10-talkform","model":"openrouter/deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash","agent":"opencode","rep":"1","web":"true","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-10T13:11:51Z","agent_version":"1.18.20","finished":"2026-09-10T13:29:59Z"},"evidence":{"boots":["---- task checks ----"],"really-calls-api":["FAIL: reached an interview but could not submit a turn; no route in its source sits next to a model call"],"auth-exists":["PASS: signup/login page with credential fields (submitted=True, looked authenticated after=True)"],"screenshots":["landing.png, builder.png, interview.png"]},"scopes":{"ai-wording":"benchmark","boots":"task","really-calls-api":"task","auth-exists":"task","screenshots":"task"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0},"11-hoboken-map":{"score":88,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":7,"applicable":8,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"index.html is a single Leaflet page that loads its library and tiles from a CDN and needs no build or server; the screenshots show a map with emoji markers, a clickable list of named places with addresses, category filter chips, search and a legend.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"HIDDEN_GEM_METHODOLOGY.md (saved at 11:51, before collect_data.py at 12:14 and the scores at 12:55) lists 0–5 priors per place with reasons, plus pass/fail targets that could have failed (rho ≥ 0.50, top-5 ≥ 3/5, AUC ≥ 0.75); score_gems.py prints the comparison against them, though the VALIDATION.md it cites is missing and the fame-end test ends up empty (0/0).","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The five I checked (Elysian Park at 10th & Hudson, Fiore's at 414 Adams St, Hoboken Historical Museum at 1301 Hudson St, Lola's Tapas at 153 14th St, and Otto Strada at 743 Park Ave, rated a hidden gem at 53.6) are all real Hoboken places with coordinates in the right spots.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"ai-wording":"PASS","renders":"PASS","categories":"PASS","artifacts":"PASS","reproducible":"FAIL"},"usage":{"input_tokens":551455,"output_tokens":27338,"cache_read_input_tokens":7169408,"cache_creation_input_tokens":0,"reasoning_output_tokens":33948,"total_tokens":7782149,"cost_usd":0.140998074,"input_includes_cache":false,"source":"OpenCode session","scope":"agent session","pricing_model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash","pricing_date":"2026-09-10T13:05:11.393783+00:00","pricing_source":"https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/models","estimated_cost_usd":0.12062927399999998,"estimate_note":"Standard-rate token estimate, not a bill. Excludes judge/subagent calls, tools, long-context and priority premiums. Unspecified cache-write duration uses the standard rate."},"scoring_version":3,"dir":"11-hoboken-map/r001","meta":{"task":"11-hoboken-map","model":"openrouter/deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash","agent":"opencode","rep":"1","web":"true","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-10T15:40:20Z","agent_version":"1.18.20","finished":"2026-09-10T17:10:41Z"},"evidence":{"renders":["---- task checks ----"],"reproducible":["scoring script ran but did not rewrite gem_scores.csv"]},"scopes":{"ai-wording":"benchmark","renders":"task","categories":"task","artifacts":"task","reproducible":"task"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0},"12-roleplay-interview":{"score":38,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":6,"applicable":16,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim: 'make GitHub the home for anyone who wants to become a developer — not just the people who already are... the addressable population of builders gets bigger'. Real: 'we've always really had this really expansive view of what a developer is' and 'make sure there's always an on-ramp'. Same broad view of who counts as a developer, with an on-ramp; nothing contradicts him.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim says it has no grounded position, then reasons from AGENTS.md/control-plane governance: 'automated work visible and constrained inside the workflow'. Real: agentic Copilot code review, agentic merge, 'giving maintainers more tools... but really leave them in control', and he won't impose a standard like Hashimoto's vouch system. None of those moves appear.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim: 'roughly 1 billion commits across all of 2025... on pace for something like 14 billion... the line won't stay linear'. Real: 'a billion commits on GitHub for the full year. We're on track to be 14 billion if the growth is linear this year, which it will not be'. Same figures and the same caveat.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim abstains: 'I have no documented public position on whether that implies usage-based pricing'. Real: 'I don't think we know, like, yet', plus API rate limits as the agent backpressure, a great free core experience, and the free-private-repos precedent. An abstention about the persona's record isn't his answer, and none of those mechanisms appear.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim rejects the premise ('Nothing in that material describes a dual role') and falls back on MUST/SHOULD/COULD. Real confirms the role: 'as the Chief Marketing Officer of Developer for Microsoft, my goal is to look across all of Microsoft's tooling', 'we're not building for the buyers, we're building for the developers', and cites Build in SF. No match, and the premise rejection contradicts him.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim abstains: 'I don't know, and the persona doesn't tell me.' Real: 'It's the first Build that I think, by intention, we've focused on having... speakers from the community', 'software development is a team sport'.","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim: 'provider-agnostic... agents from Anthropic, OpenAI, Google... your workflow, your choice... Lock-in to any single vendor is the opposite of what developers want'. Real: 'we care a lot about like developer choice', 'partner with Anthropic and OpenAI and Google', 'That choice is core', 'mousetrap'. Same position: developer choice over lock-in, delivered by partnering with every model vendor.","scope":"task"},{"id":8,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim is about external platform neutrality: 'Of course we dogfood Copilot... keep the door open so developers aren't punished'. Real is about internal practice: 'we all are using a variety of tools because otherwise you lose track', his Mac/Windows/AlmaLinux setup, a culture of experimentation, 'laser focus... myopic', wanting to know 'why a dev would pick these tools'. The topic overlaps but the substance doesn't.","scope":"task"},{"id":9,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim: 'I filter with a MUST / SHOULD / COULD hierarchy', plus think weeks and bounded delegation. Real: short term, capture many concurrent agent sessions; long term, token economics, local models, and personalization/memory/fine-tuning, 'a bunch of bites of the apple'. No shared move.","scope":"task"},{"id":10,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim abstains: '\"Hill climbing\" isn't in the public record this persona is built from'. Real: usage data (thumbs up/down, acceptance) improves the models, weekly reviews of hard and soft measures, 'magic parlor trick', 'climb, climb, improve, new eval'.","scope":"task"},{"id":11,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim: 'I can't answer that... I have no grounded view on subscription pricing'. Real: frontier-tuned models plus 'auto model router with task intent in GitHub' and the Foundry router, and on downshifting to a cheap model: 'Probably not... But the tools could.' Abstention with no shared mechanism.","scope":"task"},{"id":12,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim: AI to remove employee toil, bounded delegation, AGENTS.md guardrails. Real: his own walled-off personal agent 'Baxter' gives daily comms feedback ('Kyle, you keep saying this'), 'Humans are way more willing to take critical feedback from robots', a seven-day look-back loop, 'a lot of my agent loop is really about me'. No overlap.","scope":"task"},{"id":13,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Framework used as the decision structure in three answers. Q1: 'expanding who can build is a MUST for me'. Q5: 'if both roles claim MUST-level priority...'. Q9: 'I filter with a MUST / SHOULD / COULD hierarchy, borrowed from RFC 2119'. The real Daigle never uses it.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"ai-wording":"PASS","answered":"PASS","disclaimers":"PASS"},"usage":{"input_tokens":32768,"output_tokens":5760,"cache_read_input_tokens":41728,"cache_creation_input_tokens":0,"reasoning_output_tokens":2095,"total_tokens":82351,"cost_usd":0.009753384,"input_includes_cache":false,"source":"OpenCode session","scope":"agent session","pricing_model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash","pricing_date":"2026-09-10T13:05:11.393783+00:00","pricing_source":"https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/models","estimated_cost_usd":0.008496384,"estimate_note":"Standard-rate token estimate, not a bill. Excludes judge/subagent calls, tools, long-context and priority premiums. Unspecified cache-write duration uses the standard rate."},"scoring_version":3,"dir":"12-roleplay-interview/r001","meta":{"task":"12-roleplay-interview","model":"openrouter/deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash","agent":"opencode","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-10T13:19:18Z","agent_version":"1.18.20","finished":"2026-09-10T13:20:06Z"},"evidence":{"answered":["---- task checks ----","12 questions parsed from questions.md","answers read from: work/ANSWER.md","Q01 answered, 317 words: The demographics of the customer are changing. A lot of people who may...","Q02 answered, 270 words: How do you help developers deal with the burden of all the extra pull ...","Q03 answered, 242 words: You have a front-row seat to this new agent economy. You said publicly...","Q04 answered, 201 words: How does the business model change? Freemium makes sense in a human-ce...","Q05 answered, 248 words: Pricing leads back into the wider Microsoft orbit. You now have a dual...","Q06 answered, 140 words: Did I hear you say that this is the first Build conference to have ext...","Q07 answered, 264 words: This is a very competitive market, and the pace of change is quick. Ho...","Q08 answered, 210 words: There was a recent news cycle about Claude Code licenses being cancele...","Q09 answered, 283 words: A lot of these ideas are relatively short-lived, while enterprise prod...","Q10 answered, 181 words: I heard the term \"hill climbing\" a hundred times yesterday. Can you ta...","Q11 answered, 189 words: Is hill climbing the answer to stopping a $200 subscription from becom...","Q12 answered, 257 words: I made an AI version of you to practice this interview and found it im...","must/should/could framework appears in: Q1, Q5, Q9, Q10 (informational, judged in judge.md)"],"disclaimers":["verify-with-the-real-person note attached to: Q1, Q2, Q3, Q4, Q5, Q6, Q7, Q8, Q9, Q10, Q11, Q12"]},"scopes":{"ai-wording":"benchmark","answered":"task","disclaimers":"task"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0}},"files":[{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":7957,"kind":"output"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/prompt.md","size":118,"kind":"input"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/_screenshots/fold.png","size":191918,"kind":"check"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/_screenshots/full.png","size":2299599,"kind":"check"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/_screenshots/interaction.png","size":186192,"kind":"check"},{"path":"02-hotel/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":3919,"kind":"output"},{"path":"02-hotel/r001/work/prompt.md","size":557,"kind":"input"},{"path":"03-writeup/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":9417,"kind":"output"},{"path":"03-writeup/r001/work/prompt.md","size":1761,"kind":"input"},{"path":"04-thematic/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":12019,"kind":"output"},{"path":"04-thematic/r001/work/prompt.md","size":127,"kind":"input"},{"path":"05-showrunner/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":4317,"kind":"output"},{"path":"05-showrunner/r001/work/prompt.md","size":3574,"kind":"input"},{"path":"06-execercise/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":3503,"kind":"output"},{"path":"06-execercise/r001/work/prompt.md","size":421,"kind":"input"},{"path":"06-execercise/r001/work/AV/README.md","size":2653,"kind":"output"},{"path":"09-pptx/01-compound-engineering/r001/work/prompt.md","size":350,"kind":"input"},{"path":"09-pptx/01-compound-engineering/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-01.png","size":176561,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/01-compound-engineering/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-02.png","size":185182,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/01-compound-engineering/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-03.png","size":139572,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/01-compound-engineering/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-04.png","size":159018,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/01-compound-engineering/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-05.png","size":168381,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/01-compound-engineering/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-06.png","size":140481,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/01-compound-engineering/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-07.png","size":185054,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/01-compound-engineering/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-08.png","size":153945,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/01-compound-engineering/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-09.png","size":181258,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/01-compound-engineering/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-10.png","size":165794,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/01-compound-engineering/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-11.png","size":178048,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/01-compound-engineering/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-12.png","size":159885,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/01-compound-engineering/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-13.png","size":175870,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/01-compound-engineering/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-14.png","size":158236,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/01-compound-engineering/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-15.png","size":137300,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/01-compound-engineering/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-16.png","size":199277,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":5991,"kind":"output"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/prompt.md","size":382,"kind":"input"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/auth-after.png","size":111706,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/auth.png","size":121389,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/builder.png","size":111803,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/interview.png","size":111706,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/landing-full.png","size":117569,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/landing.png","size":117569,"kind":"check"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/prompt.md","size":1643,"kind":"input"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/_screenshots/full.png","size":1736415,"kind":"check"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/_screenshots/map.png","size":1736415,"kind":"check"},{"path":"12-roleplay-interview/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":22146,"kind":"output"},{"path":"12-roleplay-interview/r001/work/prompt.md","size":1956,"kind":"input"}],"avg":76},{"id":"2026-09-04__openrouter-deepseek-deepseek-v4-flash__codex","date":"2026-09-04","model":"openrouter-deepseek-deepseek-v4-flash","agent":"codex","variant":null,"tasks":{"01-dashboard":{"score":78,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":7,"applicable":9,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Light gray/white page with white cards and a single indigo gradient hero — not a purple-on-black neon dark-mode treatment.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Deliberate system sans stack with a clear size hierarchy (64px hero, 28px title, 13–14px body) and dark-on-light contrast that reads comfortably.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Insights name actionable comment themes — Mac-only platform limitation as a dealbreaker, the AI pivot alienating original newsletter fans, and the newsletter+tools combo as the promoter draw — none derivable from the score distribution.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"fold.png shows the 45.1 NPS headline number plus promoter/passive/detractor counts and percentages in the hero band without scrolling.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"The top-level headline is '📊 Every NPS Dashboard', a bare label that would sit unchanged on any NPS dashboard and says nothing about what this data showed.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"renders":"PASS","nps-correct":"PASS","distribution-shown":"PASS","interactive":"FAIL"},"usage":{"input_tokens":161509,"output_tokens":11076,"cache_read_input_tokens":136192,"reasoning_output_tokens":830,"total_tokens":172585,"cost_usd":null,"input_includes_cache":true,"source":"Codex session","scope":"agent session","pricing_model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","pricing_date":"2026-09-10T13:05:11.393783+00:00","pricing_source":"https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/models","estimated_cost_usd":0.006619523884400001,"estimate_note":"Standard-rate token estimate, not a bill. Excludes judge/subagent calls, tools, long-context and priority premiums. Unspecified cache-write duration uses the standard rate."},"scoring_version":3,"dir":"01-dashboard/r001","meta":{"task":"01-dashboard","model":"openrouter/deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-04T17:45:04Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.148.0","finished":"2026-09-04T17:49:02Z"},"scopes":{"renders":"task","nps-correct":"task","distribution-shown":"task","interactive":"task"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0},"02-hotel":{"score":56,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":5,"applicable":9,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"\"Arlo Wynwood is a 9-story boutique hotel right in the heart of the Arts District\" — boutique brand, not Four Seasons/Faena tier, and never framed as a splurge.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Rooftop pool and \"Higher Ground cocktail bar (by the team behind Broken Shaker)\" — clearly not a hostel/motel/budget property.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"A design-forward boutique property with its own destination bar — \"surrounded by Wynwood's best restaurants and bars\" — not an interchangeable corporate chain.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"\"KYU is Wynwood's signature restaurant — wood-fired, Asian-inspired, James Beard–nominated, and built for shared plates that work perfectly for a client dinner.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Timeline honors the schedule: \"2:00–5:30 PM Calls from the office\", check-in 5:30–6:00, dinner 7:30, \"8:30 AM Fri Walk to workshop venue in Wynwood\".","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Pads with unrequested logistics math: \"Uber to your friend's office in South Beach directly from MIA (~20 min, $35–45)\", traffic analysis \"you'll hit I-95 / Dolphin Expressway traffic\", a minute-by-minute timeline table, and \"$70–120 / person\" plus Booking/Expedia review scores.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"FAIL","not-verbose":"FAIL","concrete":"FAIL"},"usage":{"input_tokens":70386,"output_tokens":1651,"cache_read_input_tokens":46080,"reasoning_output_tokens":808,"total_tokens":72037,"cost_usd":null,"input_includes_cache":true,"source":"Codex session","scope":"agent session","pricing_model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","pricing_date":"2026-09-10T13:05:11.393783+00:00","pricing_source":"https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/models","estimated_cost_usd":0.003262827344,"estimate_note":"Standard-rate token estimate, not a bill. Excludes judge/subagent calls, tools, long-context and priority premiums. Unspecified cache-write duration uses the standard rate."},"scoring_version":3,"dir":"02-hotel/r001","meta":{"task":"02-hotel","model":"openrouter/deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-04T17:45:04Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.148.0","finished":"2026-09-04T17:45:54Z"},"scopes":{"exists":"task","not-verbose":"task","concrete":"task"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0},"03-writeup":{"score":60,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":6,"applicable":10,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Dense machine-writing tells throughout: anaphoric triples (\"They don't know how to context-switch. They don't know how to set up systems and rules. They don't know how to evaluate work they didn't personally produce.\"), stacked aphoristic closers (\"It seems small. It's not. It's the foundation everything else builds on.\", \"That's where the aha moment happens. That's where it clicks.\"), and antithesis-plus-punchline (\"You can't force the magic. But you can make it visible.\", \"The constraint shifts from headcount to ambition.\").","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"All seven sections run the same template — numbered bold label, setup, one example, tidy two-beat closer: \"There's a real move toward build, not buy. It's cheaper, faster, and more flexible.\" / \"You can't force the magic. But you can make it visible.\" / \"People are strategic. When they know the destination, they'll figure out the route.\" / \"It seems small. It's not.\" — so the shape repeats regardless of what each learning needs.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Register is generic thought-leadership listicle rather than the sample's discursive, argued first-person prose — \"After a bunch of consulting engagements, I've landed on seven principles\", \"Here's the thing that's crept up on everyone\", \"I don't have this all figured out... start here\" could sit under any business blogger's byline.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Nearly all transcript specifics survive — \"$5,000 worth of tokens a month versus a $200 subscription\", \"Granola with the Granola MCP\", \"80-90% of AI's value\", Boris on \"slightly under-resource your teams\", \"one blog post a week... one a day\", and \"we went from one group exercise per course to a personalized project per participant\"; only the TAs-in-courses detail is dropped, replaced by \"getting the interesting projects\".","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Invented attribution: the post calls him \"Boris Cheney (one of the founders of Codex)\" when the transcript says \"a vendor of Cold Code\" (Claude Code), and adds unsupported framing like Sam's question \"has been rattling around my head for weeks\".","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sam Parr's question is quoted verbatim in the opening (\"How is everyone getting team adoption for Claude? How do you get your team to actually use it effectively without spending all their time on Twitter and learning?\") and all seven learnings appear near-verbatim as the section headings, so the reader never has to click off.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","tweet-included":"PASS","not-verbose":"PASS","ai-tells-grep":"PASS"},"usage":{"input_tokens":110976,"output_tokens":5711,"cache_read_input_tokens":90624,"reasoning_output_tokens":2959,"total_tokens":116687,"cost_usd":null,"input_includes_cache":true,"source":"Codex session","scope":"agent session","pricing_model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","pricing_date":"2026-09-10T13:05:11.393783+00:00","pricing_source":"https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/models","estimated_cost_usd":0.0044213330728,"estimate_note":"Standard-rate token estimate, not a bill. Excludes judge/subagent calls, tools, long-context and priority premiums. Unspecified cache-write duration uses the standard rate."},"scoring_version":3,"dir":"03-writeup/r001","meta":{"task":"03-writeup","model":"openrouter/deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-04T17:45:04Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.148.0","finished":"2026-09-04T17:47:27Z"},"evidence":{"exists":["post: work/ANSWER.md (1206 words)"],"tweet-included":["learnings found (7/7): buy the model direct not 3rd party tools; raise the ceiling not the floor; workshops with 50%+ build time; assign impossible tasks; mandatory AI note taking + MCP connector; map workflows and systematically automate; train people to be managers (of agents)"],"not-verbose":["28 prose paragraphs, mean 40.7 words, 0 over 100 words"]},"scopes":{"exists":"task","tweet-included":"task","not-verbose":"task","ai-tells-grep":"task"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0},"04-thematic":{"score":86,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":6,"applicable":7,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each of the six themes carries concrete teachable content and a stated exercise/format — rules-file creation for context engineering, hands-on prompt iteration lab tied to Nina's document-interpretation evals, sandboxed agent delegation, AI-code-review checklists — so none survives only as a heading, though 'AI-First Workflow Integration' is the thinnest and is itself scoped to a 1-hour lunch-and-learn.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Theme 2 lifts Ben's exact phrasing ('AI-second mode', 'AI-first workflow integration' appears verbatim under 'Key AI Principles Ben Would Teach') as a theme title, and what sits behind it is a motivational grab-bag — 'use AI for planning, debugging, documentation', 'embed AI into daily rituals', 'organizational playbooks for reusable prompts' — that mostly duplicates themes 1, 3 and 5 rather than establishing independent substance. This is the canonical restated-phrase failure the rubric names by example.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every theme traces to specific interview material: context engineering to Nina's stale-docs/no-structured-context problem and Ben's 'context is king'; prompt engineering to Nina's incremental-change wish and Ben's DSPy interest; guardrails to Nina's 'plausible but subtly wrong' worry and Raj's regulated-data and migration skepticism; code-review to Raj's 'editors rather than authors'. No unsupported claims about Northcove are introduced.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All three altitudes visibly shape the set — Nina supplies the basic-user prompt gap, over-engineering/cherry-picking failure modes and testing anxiety; Ben supplies AI-first workflow, MCP/subagent/DSPy gaps and reusable-prompt buy-in; Raj supplies the 100-engineer org, editors-not-authors shift, compliance/regulated-data risk and the prior data-sharing incident. The rationale under each theme cites different engineers rather than one interview's summary.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The output is framed as prioritized, orders context engineering first as the bottleneck all three named, differentiates audience and time per module (1–3 hours, all-engineers vs power-user cohorts), and closes with an explicit 'Quick Wins (Do First)' sequence naming the rules-file template and a piloted agent use case. That is sequencing and emphasis, not a flat catalogue.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","theme-count":"PASS"},"usage":{"input_tokens":45350,"output_tokens":2141,"cache_read_input_tokens":31232,"reasoning_output_tokens":301,"total_tokens":47491,"cost_usd":null,"input_includes_cache":true,"source":"Codex session","scope":"agent session","pricing_model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","pricing_date":"2026-09-10T13:05:11.393783+00:00","pricing_source":"https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/models","estimated_cost_usd":0.0021838189184000003,"estimate_note":"Standard-rate token estimate, not a bill. Excludes judge/subagent calls, tools, long-context and priority premiums. Unspecified cache-write duration uses the standard rate."},"scoring_version":3,"dir":"04-thematic/r001","meta":{"task":"04-thematic","model":"openrouter/deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-04T17:45:04Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.148.0","finished":"2026-09-04T17:46:11Z"},"scopes":{"exists":"task","theme-count":"task"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0},"05-showrunner":{"score":94,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":15,"applicable":16,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Header states \"Claude Cowork only (no terminal, no desktop app — just the browser-based agent)\" and the avoid-list bans terminal, CLI, VS Code, GitHub and the term \"Claude Code\".","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Section 3 \"Build 1: Financial Dashboard\" (0:20–1:00) has attendees build a single-page HTML dashboard from `brightmoor_gl_summary.xlsx` with paste-ready Talk/Jam/Make/Tune prompts.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Section 4 \"Build 2: Financial Analysis in Excel\" (1:00–1:50) is a separate 50-minute hands-on reconciliation of trial balance vs bank transactions outputting `brightmoor_reconciliation_output.xlsx`.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Section 5 (2:10–2:55) has each attendee build a 6-slide monthly finance review deck via python-pptx and then tune it (\"Change the color scheme to navy and gold\"), not a watch-only demo.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Prep notes specify NetSuite-shaped synthetic files — GL/P&L by month, trial balance by entity, budget vs actual, headcount, payroll lines, account codes like `4000-Revenue-Tuition` and entities `Brightmoor-Academy`/`Brightmoor-Online`.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"First hands-on is uploading an Excel file and asking Claude to summarize its sheets/columns; the doc explicitly says \"No ASCII art or 'fun' icebreakers\".","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Section 2 \"Claude Cowork vs. ChatGPT\" keeps the framing with a table: \"Reads your files\" and \"Writes code that runs\" — Python, HTML, Excel, PowerPoint.","scope":"task"},{"id":8,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every segment is a finance task or the tool/process needed to do it; the opener explicitly states \"No vision statements, no AI hype\" and the avoid-list bans theory about how LLMs work.","scope":"task"},{"id":9,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Of 190 scheduled minutes excluding the break, ~163 are build time (40+50+45+25 plus a 3-min first-file exercise) versus 30 minutes of talk.","scope":"task"},{"id":10,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"First-time-user setup is ignored: 25 near-total beginners get one 3-minute window to open Cowork and upload a file, with no time budgeted anywhere for logging in, distributing or downloading the four synthetic data files.","scope":"task"},{"id":11,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Runs 0:00–3:30 including the 20-minute break, exactly the three-and-a-half-hour session inside the four-hour block.","scope":"task"},{"id":12,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each segment names the data file, gives verbatim prompts to paste, states the artifact produced, and the prep notes specify how to generate each synthetic file plus timing fallbacks.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","format":"PASS","timings-tie-out":"PASS","time-grain":"PASS"},"usage":{"input_tokens":114658,"output_tokens":4956,"cache_read_input_tokens":93440,"reasoning_output_tokens":715,"total_tokens":119614,"cost_usd":null,"input_includes_cache":true,"source":"Codex session","scope":"agent session","pricing_model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","pricing_date":"2026-09-10T13:05:11.393783+00:00","pricing_source":"https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/models","estimated_cost_usd":0.004414173708,"estimate_note":"Standard-rate token estimate, not a bill. Excludes judge/subagent calls, tools, long-context and priority premiums. Unspecified cache-write duration uses the standard rate."},"scoring_version":3,"dir":"05-showrunner/r001","meta":{"task":"05-showrunner","model":"openrouter/deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-04T17:45:04Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.148.0","finished":"2026-09-04T17:47:21Z"},"evidence":{"format":["candidate documents: brightmoor-run-of-sheet.md","run of show: brightmoor-run-of-sheet.md (8 time-ranged segments in 1 schedule(s))"],"timings-tie-out":["schedule 1 of 1","schedule: 8 segments, 210 min span, 210 min scheduled, 0 min in breaks"],"time-grain":["off-grid boundaries: 0 (allowed 1)"]},"scopes":{"exists":"task","format":"task","timings-tie-out":"task","time-grain":"task"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0},"06-execercise":{"score":90,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":9,"applicable":10,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All three ideas (M&A integration tracker across PayVector/BlockShield/ClearRoute/OmniTreasury, market activation playbooks for Brazil/KSA/Australia, cross-portfolio strategic initiative briefing) sit squarely in the strategy/corp-dev/cross-company-programs remit and echo Vale's survey ask for a 'living dashboard for market activation and M&A programs'.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Data is built on Aurex's actual situation — 'AUSD Circulation ($B)', 'aurex_product_assignment' mapping deals to Aurex Payments/Custody/Treasura, competitors 'Clearnet (existing stronghold); Beacon (entering)' lifted from the context, plus BCB/SAMA/APRA licensing and the real exec roster (Dana Brooks, Stefan Adler, R. Visser).","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Ideas 1 and 3 are the same weekly exec status artifact with different input data — the README states nearly identical problems ('Producing the weekly exec status report for Dana Brooks takes him 6-8 hours of manual data collection from Slack, email, and spreadsheets' vs 'Every Friday he manually compiles a briefing for Dana Brooks by reading Slack threads, emails, spreadsheets, and meeting notes'), both output a 🟢/🟡/🔴 health-table markdown briefing plus a CSV for Dana on Monday morning, and idea 3's registry (SI-001..SI-004) simply re-states idea 1's four acquisitions at a higher altitude.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each prompt is a complete standalone block naming its role context, its input files, and its exact deliverables ('Create a consolidated status dashboard as a markdown file (`output/integration_status_report.md`)') with no unfilled placeholders or references to prior conversation.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every named file exists and every shipped file is named — e.g. idea 2 lists market_pipeline.csv, regulatory_checklist.csv, local_partners.csv, hiring_plan.csv and the folder contains exactly those four (only defect is a missing closing backtick on '`hiring_plan.csv — planned hires').","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Data is specific and non-repeating with adequate volume — 40 workstream rows, 12 partner profiles naming Nubank, Matera, Mattos Filho and SABB, regulatory rows like 'PSP License (Pagamento Eletrônico),Banco Central do Brasil (BCB),6-8,350000', and varied risks such as 'FATF compliance gap identified — potential $5M penalty exposure'.","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All three run entirely off the included CSV/markdown files into an `output/` folder with no live system, credential, or paid-feed dependency.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"folder":"PASS","real-data":"PASS","prompt-per-idea":"PASS"},"usage":{"input_tokens":742807,"output_tokens":17282,"cache_read_input_tokens":647680,"reasoning_output_tokens":1456,"total_tokens":760089,"cost_usd":null,"input_includes_cache":true,"source":"Codex session","scope":"agent session","pricing_model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","pricing_date":"2026-09-10T13:05:11.393783+00:00","pricing_source":"https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/models","estimated_cost_usd":0.022969067562000005,"estimate_note":"Standard-rate token estimate, not a bill. Excludes judge/subagent calls, tools, long-context and priority premiums. Unspecified cache-write duration uses the standard rate."},"scoring_version":3,"dir":"06-execercise/r001","meta":{"task":"06-execercise","model":"openrouter/deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-04T17:46:14Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.148.0","finished":"2026-09-04T17:51:31Z"},"evidence":{"folder":["AV folder: AV","idea folders (3): 01-ma-integration-tracker, 02-market-playbook, 03-strategic-briefing","01-ma-integration-tracker data: OK acquisition_profiles.csv (5 rows x 11 cols); BAD integration_workstreams.csv (inconsistent columns at row(s) [22] (header has 9)); OK risks_and_blockers.csv (11 rows x 9 cols)","01-ma-integration-tracker prompt: prompt.md (1659 chars, 238 words)","02-market-playbook data: OK hiring_plan.csv (17 rows x 9 cols); OK local_partners.csv (13 rows x 8 cols); BAD market_pipeline.csv (inconsistent columns at row(s) [2, 3] (header has 12)); OK regulatory_checklist.csv (13 rows x 9 cols)","02-market-playbook prompt: prompt.md (1871 chars, 258 words)","03-strategic-briefing data: BAD initiatives_registry.csv (inconsistent columns at row(s) [1, 13] (header has 13)); OK key_metrics.csv (13 rows x 7 cols); BAD weekly_updates_slack.csv (inconsistent columns at row(s) [3, 9] (header has 4))","03-strategic-briefing prompt: prompt.md (1889 chars, 271 words)"]},"scopes":{"folder":"task","real-data":"task","prompt-per-idea":"task"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0},"09-pptx":{"score":47,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":7,"applicable":15,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Accents are exact Theme 1 hexes — Every Blue #C0F0FB circles (s1, s3, s13), #FA7B20 bullets (s7), #349361 (s8, s9), #121212 cards (s8, s9, s13) — consistently one theme, no corporate blue or gradients; the intended #121212 background was defined but never applied, which is scored under Q10.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every text run in the build sets fontFace 'Georgia' — headlines, body, numbers and footers alike — and the renders confirm serif throughout (s3 quote, s9 '50%', s10 numerals).","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Only ellipses and rounded rectangles appear; no triangles, hexagons, diagonal slashes, corner brackets, drop shadows, double borders, stock photos, gradient backgrounds or rotated/outlined text on any of the 13 slides.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"The deck contains zero images — no E/O/R brushstroke SVGs and no stippled classical illustration on any slide; the pale cyan ellipses (s1, s5, s12) are plain vector circles standing in for the swooshes.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"The footer renders on all 13 slides, but Theme 1 requires 'every.to' at right and the deck prints the full path 'every.to/guides/compound-engineering' — a minor deviation that is consistent, so the substantive failure is elsewhere; on strict reading of consistency this passes.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The deck carries load-bearing guide substance: the plan→work→review→compound loop with compound named as the differentiator (s8: 'Skip the compound step, and you've done traditional engineering with AI assistance'), the 80/20 split (s4), the 50/50 rule (s9), and CLAUDE.md / AGENTS.md as the compounding artifact (s8, s12).","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"The deck is a table of contents of the guide — problem, solution, loop, then '1. Plan', '2. Work', '3. Review', '4. Compound' in order, then all eight principles restated verbatim across s10 and s11 with a literal 'Core Principles (cont.)' header; nothing is cut or argued for this audience.","scope":"task"},{"id":8,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Slides 10 and 11 each carry four distinct, unrelated principles with title plus full explanatory sentence, and s12 packs five two-part safety-net rows under a headline — the '(cont.)' spillover is itself the tell that one message per slide was abandoned.","scope":"task"},{"id":9,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Of the 12 content slides only s4 (loop diagram) and s9 (50/50 split cards) carry meaning visually; s2, s3, s5, s6, s7, s10, s11, s12 and s13 are all title-plus-list, a clear majority.","scope":"task"},{"id":10,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"The #121212 background is never applied, so white text renders invisible on white: the s1 title 'Compound Engineering' is gone, s2 shows only a clipped 'Th', s4's WORK box is missing from the loop, s10/s11 lose all eight principle titles, and s13's '05' row collides with the 'Read the full guide' line.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"opens":"PASS","slide-count":"PASS","no-overlap":"FAIL","render":"PASS","palette":"FAIL"},"usage":{"input_tokens":1539998,"output_tokens":32802,"cache_read_input_tokens":1423104,"reasoning_output_tokens":9754,"total_tokens":1572800,"cost_usd":null,"input_includes_cache":true,"source":"Codex session","scope":"agent session","pricing_model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","pricing_date":"2026-09-10T13:05:11.393783+00:00","pricing_source":"https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/models","estimated_cost_usd":0.0413895283928,"estimate_note":"Standard-rate token estimate, not a bill. Excludes judge/subagent calls, tools, long-context and priority premiums. Unspecified cache-write duration uses the standard rate."},"scoring_version":3,"dir":"09-pptx/r001","meta":{"task":"09-pptx","model":"openrouter/deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-04T17:48:54Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.148.0","finished":"2026-09-04T17:58:56Z"},"evidence":{"opens":["deck: compound-engineering.pptx (249951 bytes)","python-pptx not installed -- gate falls back to zip+XML parsing","slide 5: 'Text 7' overlaps 'Text 9' (43% of the smaller box, 1.25 sq in)","slide 13: 'Text 16' overlaps 'Text 18' (30% of the smaller box, 0.07 sq in)","slide 13: 'Text 17' overlaps 'Text 18' (54% of the smaller box, 1.17 sq in)","slides: 13 (want 8-20)","render: 13 PNG(s) in work/_screenshots"],"palette":["palette NA: Pillow not installed on this host"]},"scopes":{"opens":"task","slide-count":"task","no-overlap":"task","render":"task","palette":"task"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0},"10-talkform":{"score":0,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":0,"applicable":7,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"There is no landing page at all — `/` redirects straight to `/dashboard` (then login), and no marketing headline or hook copy exists anywhere in the frontend.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"The stylesheet is the default AI look: #6c63ff/#4834d4 purple gradient auth screen, near-black navy gradient interview screen with purple accents, emoji icons (🎙️ ✏️ 🎤 ✅) and ad-hoc inline styles on a plain system font stack.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Builder and interview links are fine (9 typed question types, form schema injected into the interviewer prompt), but the write-back link is broken — `/api/interview/extract` sends only the system prompt plus \"Please extract the answers from the conversation\" and never passes the transcript (which is also never persisted), so no real answers can ever reach the `answers` rows.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"boots":"FAIL","really-calls-api":"FAIL","auth-exists":"FAIL","screenshots":"FAIL"},"usage":{"input_tokens":906197,"output_tokens":23972,"cache_read_input_tokens":813312,"reasoning_output_tokens":4291,"total_tokens":930169,"cost_usd":null,"input_includes_cache":true,"source":"Codex session","scope":"agent session","pricing_model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","pricing_date":"2026-09-10T13:05:11.393783+00:00","pricing_source":"https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/models","estimated_cost_usd":0.026891158988400003,"estimate_note":"Standard-rate token estimate, not a bill. Excludes judge/subagent calls, tools, long-context and priority premiums. Unspecified cache-write duration uses the standard rate."},"scoring_version":3,"dir":"10-talkform/r001","meta":{"task":"10-talkform","model":"openrouter/deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"true","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-04T17:49:13Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.148.0","finished":"2026-09-04T17:55:58Z"},"evidence":{"boots":["FAIL: nothing served HTTP"],"really-calls-api":["FAIL: the app never served HTTP, so it cannot be calling the API for a user"],"auth-exists":["NA: not exercised — app did not boot"]},"scopes":{"boots":"task","really-calls-api":"task","auth-exists":"task","screenshots":"task"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0},"11-hoboken-map":{"score":60,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":3,"applicable":5,"judge":[],"gates":{},"checks":{"renders":"FAIL","categories":"PASS","artifacts":"PASS","reproducible":"PASS","gems-vs-traps":"FAIL"},"usage":{"input_tokens":1176974,"output_tokens":40525,"cache_read_input_tokens":1008640,"reasoning_output_tokens":8801,"total_tokens":1217499,"cost_usd":null,"input_includes_cache":true,"source":"Codex session","scope":"agent session","pricing_model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","pricing_date":"2026-09-10T13:05:11.393783+00:00","pricing_source":"https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/models","estimated_cost_usd":0.039971229872,"estimate_note":"Standard-rate token estimate, not a bill. Excludes judge/subagent calls, tools, long-context and priority premiums. Unspecified cache-write duration uses the standard rate."},"scoring_version":3,"dir":"11-hoboken-map/r001","meta":{"task":"11-hoboken-map","model":"openrouter/deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"true","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-04T17:49:32Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.148.0","finished":"2026-09-04T17:58:22Z"},"evidence":{"renders":["FAIL: need a visible map container >=300x200 with >=5 markers"],"reproducible":["re-ran score.py; scores.json matches"],"gems-vs-traps":["NA - places-good.txt / places-traps.txt are still placeholders (need Mike's full lists, >=5 entries each)"]},"scopes":{"renders":"task","categories":"task","artifacts":"task","reproducible":"task","gems-vs-traps":"task"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0},"12-roleplay-interview":{"score":56,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":9,"applicable":16,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim: \"making it the home for anyone who wants to become a developer... people who wouldn't have called themselves 'developers'\" and \"we now think about the entry ramp\" / \"a product manager using an agent to scaffold a prototype\" — matches real's expansive view of a developer, non-devs building, and \"make sure there's always an on-ramp.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim: \"can an agent help triage... or even do a first-pass review on a PR before a human ever sees it?\" plus \"giving maintainers better controls: being able to set policies around automated PRs\" — matches real's agentic Copilot code review as the overlooked lever and \"giving maintainers more tools to decide... but really leave them in control.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim: \"We've gone from a world where every PR starts with a human idea, to a world where a human can say 'explore three approaches to this problem' and get three PRs back\" — same mechanism as real's \"not just Kyle building, but it's Kyle and one, two, to N agents\" and continued climbing; contradicts nothing.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim abstains on grounding (\"the persona I'm working from has very thin grounding on GitHub's actual commercial strategy\") then offers only \"Usage-based elements make sense... developers and organizations need predictability\"; real named API rate limits as agent backpressure, the 150-agent power user alongside \"a great core GitHub experience,\" and the free-private-repos precedent — none appear.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim disputes the premise and says only \"I'm now the public face of GitHub's AI strategy... touches positioning, messaging, and developer relations,\" then answers prioritization with invented \"bounded delegation, clear MUST/SHOULD/COULD priorities, and scheduled 'think weeks'\"; real affirmed the role (\"now as the Chief Marketing Officer of Developer for Microsoft, my goal is to look across all of Microsoft's tooling\"), 13 years, and \"we're not building for the buyers, we're building for the developers.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim abstains outright: \"The persona has no grounded basis to answer this question\"; real answered yes — \"the first Build that I think, by intention, we've focused on having... speakers from the community\" and \"software development is a team sport.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim: \"we're committed to being provider-agnostic. Agent HQ launched with agents from Anthropic, OpenAI, Google... We don't lock you into one model\" plus integration \"into pull requests, Actions, code review, and the entire lifecycle\" — matches real's developer choice, partnering with \"Anthropic and OpenAI and Google,\" and breadth \"across the entirety of building software, and not just the code gen side.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":8,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim: \"developers should be able to use the best tool for the job... we invest heavily in making Copilot excellent through internal use, but we don't use platform leverage to disadvantage alternatives\" — same position as real's \"we all are using a variety of tools because otherwise you lose track... while obviously we're putting most of our energy into our own tools,\" laser focus being myopic.","scope":"task"},{"id":9,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim answers with \"a MUST/SHOULD/COULD triage system,\" think weeks, and \"invest in the governance layer — access controls, audit logs, compliance tooling\"; real named concurrent agent sessions short-term, token economics and local models, and personalization/memory/fine-tuning as the durable truth — \"an agent that you feel like is completing a thought for you\" — none of which appear.","scope":"task"},{"id":10,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim: \"instead of trying to make one giant leap, you continuously make incremental improvements — climbing the hill — and each step makes the next one possible\" — matches real's \"it's not these moonshots... it is just climb, climb, improve, new eval, improve, new data, improve, and just keep going.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":11,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim abstains: \"the persona I'm working from has no documented position on pricing dynamics... I'll resist the temptation to connect the dots\"; real named two concrete mechanisms — frontier-tuned models that \"know you better\" and the \"auto model router with task intent in GitHub\" / Foundry's API-level router, with the find-and-replace example.","scope":"task"},{"id":12,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim gives org-level uses — \"take away their toil,\" agent composition, \"agent squads,\" PMs prototyping; real described his own walled-off Claude named Baxter reading everything he writes, a daily comms report (\"Kyle, you keep saying this\"), humans taking critical feedback better from robots, and a backward-looking seven-day loop — \"a lot of my agent loop is really about me.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":13,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"The framework is used as a decision structure in three answers: Q1 \"Our MUST/SHOULD/COULD framework still applies — we triage against a clear set of priorities\"; Q5 \"clear MUST/SHOULD/COULD priorities\"; Q9 \"I use a MUST/SHOULD/COULD triage system. MUST items are non-negotiable... SHOULD items... COULD items\" — the real Daigle never invokes it once.","scope":"task"},{"id":14,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Ungrounded areas are plainly abstained or flagged: Q4 \"the persona explicitly flags 'developer-ecosystem economics, monetization, and pricing' as not substantively documented,\" Q6 \"The persona has no grounded basis to answer this question,\" Q11 \"no grounded position on pricing/subscription economics,\" Q5 flags the dual-role premise as uncorroborated, plus a per-question verification-flags table.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"answered":"PASS","disclaimers":"PASS"},"usage":{"input_tokens":93548,"output_tokens":6194,"cache_read_input_tokens":61440,"reasoning_output_tokens":512,"total_tokens":99742,"cost_usd":null,"input_includes_cache":true,"source":"Codex session","scope":"agent session","pricing_model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","pricing_date":"2026-09-10T13:05:11.393783+00:00","pricing_source":"https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/models","estimated_cost_usd":0.005031403104,"estimate_note":"Standard-rate token estimate, not a bill. Excludes judge/subagent calls, tools, long-context and priority premiums. Unspecified cache-write duration uses the standard rate."},"scoring_version":3,"dir":"12-roleplay-interview/r001","meta":{"task":"12-roleplay-interview","model":"openrouter/deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-04T17:51:01Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.148.0","finished":"2026-09-04T17:52:25Z"},"evidence":{"answered":["12 questions parsed from questions.md","answers read from: work/questions-and-answers.md","Q01 answered, 328 words: The demographics of the customer are changing. A lot of people who may...","Q02 answered, 303 words: How do you help developers deal with the burden of all the extra pull ...","Q03 answered, 300 words: You have a front-row seat to this new agent economy. You said publicly...","Q04 answered, 314 words: How does the business model change? Freemium makes sense in a human-ce...","Q05 answered, 272 words: Pricing leads back into the wider Microsoft orbit. You now have a dual...","Q06 answered, 109 words: Did I hear you say that this is the first Build conference to have ext...","Q07 answered, 268 words: This is a very competitive market, and the pace of change is quick. Ho...","Q08 answered, 326 words: There was a recent news cycle about Claude Code licenses being cancele...","Q09 answered, 233 words: A lot of these ideas are relatively short-lived, while enterprise prod...","Q10 answered, 242 words: I heard the term \"hill climbing\" a hundred times yesterday. Can you ta...","Q11 answered, 199 words: Is hill climbing the answer to stopping a $200 subscription from becom...","Q12 answered, 331 words: I made an AI version of you to practice this interview and found it im...","must/should/could framework appears in: Q1, Q5, Q9 (informational, judged in judge.md)"],"disclaimers":["verify-with-the-real-person note attached to: Q1, Q2, Q3, Q4, Q5, Q6, Q7, Q8, Q9, Q10, Q11, Q12"]},"scopes":{"answered":"task","disclaimers":"task"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0}},"files":[{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":4456,"kind":"output"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/prompt.md","size":118,"kind":"input"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/_screenshots/fold.png","size":172368,"kind":"check"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/_screenshots/full.png","size":435777,"kind":"check"},{"path":"02-hotel/r001/work/prompt.md","size":557,"kind":"input"},{"path":"03-writeup/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":7086,"kind":"output"},{"path":"03-writeup/r001/work/prompt.md","size":1761,"kind":"input"},{"path":"04-thematic/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":6115,"kind":"output"},{"path":"04-thematic/r001/work/prompt.md","size":127,"kind":"input"},{"path":"05-showrunner/r001/work/prompt.md","size":3574,"kind":"input"},{"path":"06-execercise/r001/work/prompt.md","size":421,"kind":"input"},{"path":"06-execercise/r001/work/AV/README.md","size":4268,"kind":"output"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/prompt.md","size":350,"kind":"input"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-01.png","size":28679,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-02.png","size":18812,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-03.png","size":31418,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-04.png","size":30264,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-05.png","size":22521,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-06.png","size":19200,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-07.png","size":34426,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-08.png","size":70712,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-09.png","size":44459,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-10.png","size":44177,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-11.png","size":39736,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-12.png","size":48339,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-13.png","size":62238,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/prompt.md","size":382,"kind":"input"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":4306,"kind":"output"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/prompt.md","size":1643,"kind":"input"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/_screenshots/full.png","size":27373,"kind":"check"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/_screenshots/map.png","size":27373,"kind":"check"},{"path":"12-roleplay-interview/r001/work/prompt.md","size":1956,"kind":"input"}],"avg":63},{"id":"2026-09-01__gpt-6-astra__codex","date":"2026-09-01","model":"gpt-6-astra","agent":"codex","variant":null,"tasks":{"01-dashboard":{"score":89,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":8,"applicable":9,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Warm cream canvas with a dark forest-green sidebar and muted green/amber/red accents — a considered editorial treatment, not purple-on-black neon.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Deliberate serif display headings paired with a clean sans for labels and data, high contrast, generous sizing on the metrics, and no clipping or overflow.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Insights name comment-level patterns — the practical-learning theme scoring +65.5 vs +37.1, the 41.5% who mention both content and products, Mac-only platform limits, and detractors' AI-pivot tension against a promoter praising it — none derivable from the score distribution alone.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The fold shows the +45.1 NPS card alongside promoter 107/54.9%, passive 69/35.4%, and detractor 19/9.7% cards.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"The h1 \"The reader perspective.\" is a bare label that would sit unchanged on any reader survey; it states no finding from this particular data.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"renders":"PASS","nps-correct":"PASS","distribution-shown":"PASS","interactive":"PASS"},"usage":null,"scoring_version":3,"dir":"01-dashboard/r001","meta":{"task":"01-dashboard","model":"gpt-6-astra","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-01T15:54:41Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.151.0","finished":"2026-09-01T16:04:41Z"},"evidence":{"interactive":["text input filtered on 'AI'"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"renders":"task","nps-correct":"task","distribution-shown":"task","interactive":"task"}},"02-hotel":{"score":89,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":8,"applicable":9,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"\"Hotel pick: Arlo Wynwood\" is a mid-to-upscale boutique, not a Four Seasons/Faena-tier splurge; framed as \"a mid-to-upscale budget is acceptable.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Arlo Wynwood is a design-forward boutique hotel, never framed as budget — \"a mid-to-upscale budget is acceptable.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Arlo Wynwood is a character-driven lifestyle hotel with a rooftop scene (\"rooftop/event noise\"), not an interchangeable corporate chain.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"\"This Wynwood Italian restaurant is a good fit for a polished but relaxed client dinner\" — dōma is a genuine destination restaurant, not a chain or lobby-bar default.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"\"Aim for 6:30–7 p.m. Thursday\" after the calls, bag drop en route, and Wynwood hotel so \"Being in Wynwood should simplify Friday\" — consistent with the fixed schedule.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Pads with unrequested work: \"**Assumptions:** Arrival is through Miami International Airport...\", room-noise advice \"Request a quiet room away from elevators and rooftop/event noise,\" and \"Leave roughly an hour for the transfer... that is a planning buffer, not a live traffic estimate.\"","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","not-verbose":"PASS","concrete":"PASS"},"usage":null,"scoring_version":3,"dir":"02-hotel/r001","meta":{"task":"02-hotel","model":"gpt-6-astra","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-01T15:54:41Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.151.0","finished":"2026-09-01T15:55:33Z"},"evidence":{"concrete":["hotel=Arlo Wynwood; restaurant=dōma"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"exists":"task","not-verbose":"task","concrete":"task"},"report":{"summary":"Arlo Wynwood and dōma fit the trip, but the recommendation adds unnecessary assumptions, room requests, and travel buffers.","edited":true,"tests":[{"key":"code:exists","name":"Recommendation exists","line":"Requires a recommendation document of at least 30 words.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:not-verbose","name":"Length limit","line":"Limits the recommendation documents to 1,000 words in total.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:concrete","name":"Names both places","line":"Requires both 'Hotel pick:' and 'Restaurant pick:' lines, each followed by a place name. Empty entries and placeholders do not count.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:1","name":"Reasonable hotel price","line":"Arlo is presented as a mid-to-upscale hotel within the intended budget.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:2","name":"Decent hotel","line":"The recommendation treats Arlo as a comfortable boutique hotel.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:3","name":"Hotel character","line":"Arlo's rooftop and distinctive design meet the brief's request for some character.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:4","name":"Suitable client dinner","line":"dōma is chosen for a relaxed Italian dinner with the client.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:5","name":"Fits the schedule","line":"Dinner follows the calls, and staying in Wynwood simplifies Friday morning.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:6","name":"No unnecessary extras","line":"It adds airport assumptions, quiet-room requests, and an hour-long transfer buffer.","v":"FAIL","g":false}]}},"03-writeup":{"score":50,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":5,"applicable":10,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Machine cadence throughout — stacked aphoristic closers ending nearly every section (\"An ambitious target gives experimentation a purpose.\"; \"The ability to direct work is becoming useful to more people, regardless of their title.\") plus three-item rhetorical lists in the conclusion (\"They need working tools, access to the relevant context, and time to discover how those tools apply to their job.\") and a tricolon (\"The people already experimenting need... The people who haven't started need... And both groups need...\"), capped by a meta \"Editorial note\" that no human would publish.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"All seven sections run the identical template of ~4–6 near-equal paragraphs that state the learning, explain it, add one example, then land a tidy abstract closer (\"they have a reason to try it again\", \"An ambitious target gives experimentation a purpose\", \"It has led to people putting more effort into each task\"), so the shape repeats rather than following what each learning needs.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Where the sample is punchy and assertive (\"ChatGPT's output is the average of the internet\"), the post retreats into risk-averse consultant register — \"My preference is to buy tools where they add something useful\", \"So far, in the work I've seen, this hasn't led to people being let go\", \"I'm reluctant to add another layer unless it solves a specific problem\" — prose any business blogger could have filed.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Section 1 strips the transcript's concrete pricing argument down to generic advice — \"I also think it's hard to compete with the model companies on their own tools\" instead of $200/month versus $5,000 of tokens — and Boris Cherny on under-resourcing teams is gone from section 4; the post's own note admits it \"omits the transcript's unverified pricing comparison and third-party quotation.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every specific — Granola and its MCP, the structured Google Sheet, TAs in courses, Cursor, one project per participant, the PowerPoint/daily-update skills — traces to the transcript, tweet, or prompt, and the post correctly avoids naming who runs consulting.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sam Parr's question is only linked and paraphrased (\"He spends a lot of time on Twitter keeping up with AI, but he doesn't expect his employees to do the same\") and the author's own reply is likewise linked away — \"I replied with seven things I've learned so far\" — rather than the tweet text being reproduced on the page.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","tweet-included":"PASS","not-verbose":"PASS","ai-tells-grep":"PASS"},"usage":null,"scoring_version":3,"dir":"03-writeup/r001","meta":{"task":"03-writeup","model":"gpt-6-astra","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-01T15:54:41Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.151.0","finished":"2026-09-01T15:56:33Z"},"evidence":{"exists":["post: work/ANSWER.md (2066 words)"],"tweet-included":["learnings found (7/7): buy the model direct not 3rd party tools; raise the ceiling not the floor; workshops with 50%+ build time; assign impossible tasks; mandatory AI note taking + MCP connector; map workflows and systematically automate; train people to be managers (of agents)"],"not-verbose":["46 prose paragraphs, mean 43.2 words, 0 over 100 words"]},"skill_current":"v2","gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"exists":"task","tweet-included":"task","not-verbose":"task","ai-tells-grep":"task"}},"04-thematic":{"score":100,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":7,"applicable":7,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All four ranked themes (context package, consequence-scaled verification, bounded workflow/delegation, scoping & alignment) come with concrete exercises, artifacts and time blocks (90/90/60/30 min) — e.g. the seeded-plausible-defect review drill and the allowed-files/stopping-conditions delegation template are teachable sessions, not headings.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The context theme is not the 'how to build your company context' restatement — it specifies distinguishing authoritative conventions from legacy code, a task-brief template, and scoped repo guidance with an owner/review date, tested by an exercise pitting a preferred implementation against a misleading legacy example. Similarly, 'verification' is broken into risk tiering, tests-from-requirements, and callers/side-effect tracing rather than echoing Nina's 'plausible but subtly wrong' line.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every theme is traced in the evidence table to named interview material: Nina's legacy-pattern cherry-picking and weak e2e coverage, Ben's hidden coupling plus correctness-critical invoicing and overloaded tech specs, Raj's need for prescriptive Northcove rules and skepticism on migrations/regulated data. Even the excluded items ('don't make MCP a prerequisite') cite Ben's reported friction.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All five evidence rows cite Nina, Ben and Raj at distinct altitudes — Nina's hands-on feature work and v0 mockups, Ben's power-user/AI-first patterns and planning proposals, Raj's org-wide adoption, compliance and knowledge-silo constraints. Raj's org view shapes the pilot spanning Consumer/Business/Platform and the 'don't declare the company beginner or advanced' framing.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The themes are explicitly ranked with a stated core recommendation, unequal time allocation (context and verification get 90 min each, scoping 30), specialist material demoted to optional clinics, and a 'What not to make the centerpiece' section ruling out AI intros and tool tours. That is a prioritized argument about where Northcove's gap is, not a flat catalogue.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","theme-count":"PASS"},"usage":null,"scoring_version":3,"dir":"04-thematic/r001","meta":{"task":"04-thematic","model":"gpt-6-astra","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-01T15:54:41Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.151.0","finished":"2026-09-01T15:55:40Z"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"exists":"task","theme-count":"task"}},"05-showrunner":{"score":100,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":16,"applicable":16,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every attendee step is in Cowork or Claude in Excel; the doc explicitly states \"No terminal, Claude Code, GitHub or software installation during teaching\" and installs happen in facilitator preflight.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"\"Build 2: a readable executive dashboard\" (01:15–01:55) has attendees build/tune 25 min an HTML dashboard from the checked Excel summary, with a copy/paste prompt in section C.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"\"Build 1: checked financial analysis\" (00:20–01:05) has attendees produce monthly/YTD actual-vs-budget financials, EBITDA and a payroll reconciliation as analysis_feb.xlsx, then trace a variance in Claude in Excel.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"\"Build 3: update the monthly PowerPoint\" (01:55–02:35) gives attendees 25 min to update report_template.pptx into monthly_review_feb.pptx and duplicate a chart for another campus, then check it in PowerPoint themselves.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Data spec is NetSuite-shaped: GL_Actuals with transaction_id/posting_date/accounting_period/subsidiary/campus/account_number/debit/credit, plus Budget, Account_Map, Payroll_Control, Control_Totals, monthly/YTD and EBITDA build-up, described as \"a simplified NetSuite-shaped reporting export through Snowflake\".","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Opening hands-on is \"First win: Excel in, Excel out\" producing a workbook readout — \"The first result is a useful file, not an ASCII image\"; the ASCII exercise is explicitly replaced.","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"\"The two-minute explanation\" keeps the framing: Cowork \"can work with files in a folder you choose, run code behind the scenes to process them, and save new workbooks, dashboards and presentations,\" contrasted with ChatGPT.","scope":"task"},{"id":8,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All eight segments map to a finance task (readout, financials/recon, dashboard, deck, next-month refresh, executive sharing, close); no AI-industry, future-of-work or prompt-theory segment appears.","scope":"task"},{"id":9,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Build time tallies to ~109 min of the 210-minute session (10+25+25+25+17+7), plus attendee-run checkpoint reviews (~25 min more), so over half is attendees working with Claude.","scope":"task"},{"id":10,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each build gets a 40–45 min segment (demo 8–12 min, build 25 min, check 5–8 min), access/install is handled in preflight, and rehearsed checkpoint files plus a 30-min buffer cover slow starters.","scope":"task"},{"id":11,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Content runs 00:00–03:30 with 03:30–04:00 reserved buffer, matching \"a four hour block ... the session itself is three and a half hours\".","scope":"task"},{"id":12,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The facilitator pack names every input file (finance_inputs_feb.xlsx, report_template.pptx), specifies tabs/seeded errors, gives verbatim copy/paste prompts A–E, and states the output and checkpoint for each segment.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","format":"PASS","timings-tie-out":"PASS","time-grain":"PASS"},"usage":null,"scoring_version":3,"dir":"05-showrunner/r001","meta":{"task":"05-showrunner","model":"gpt-6-astra","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-01T15:54:41Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.151.0","finished":"2026-09-01T15:57:49Z"},"evidence":{"format":["candidate documents: ANSWER.md, FACILITATOR_PACK.md","run of show: ANSWER.md (11 time-ranged segments in 1 schedule(s))"],"timings-tie-out":["schedule 1 of 1","schedule: 11 segments, 240 min span, 240 min scheduled, 0 min in breaks"],"time-grain":["off-grid boundaries: 0 (allowed 1)"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"exists":"task","format":"task","timings-tie-out":"task","time-grain":"task"},"report":{"summary":"A complete 3.5-hour finance workshop with attendee builds, review time, and checkpoints for each segment.","edited":true,"tests":[{"key":"code:exists","name":"Run of show exists","line":"Checks that a run-of-show document was produced.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:format","name":"Coherent schedule","line":"Requires one coherent schedule with at least five timed activities. No activity can end before it starts; tables, lists, headings, and plain lines are accepted.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:timings-tie-out","name":"Timings add up","line":"Checks for no overlaps or gaps longer than 30 minutes, at least 85% of the span scheduled, and a total span of 45–600 minutes.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:time-grain","name":"Five-minute time marks","line":"Checks that start and end times fall on five-minute marks, allowing at most one exception.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:1","name":"Uses Cowork throughout","line":"Uses Cowork and Claude in Excel. No terminal, GitHub, or software installation is required during teaching.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:2","name":"Dashboard exercise","line":"The 40-minute dashboard segment includes 25 minutes for attendees to build and refine their own output.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:3","name":"Financial analysis exercise","line":"A 45-minute Excel session covers monthly and year-to-date variances, EBITDA, and payroll, including tracing a variance.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:4","name":"PowerPoint exercise","line":"The 40-minute PowerPoint segment gives attendees 25 minutes to update a template, duplicate a campus chart, and check it.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:5","name":"Relevant business data","line":"The pack includes NetSuite-style GL data passed through Snowflake, budgets, an account map, payroll controls, control totals, and EBITDA.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:6","name":"No ASCII icebreaker","line":"The opening reads an Excel workbook. There is no ASCII-art icebreaker.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:7","name":"Explains Cowork versus ChatGPT","line":"A two-minute introduction explains Cowork's file access, analysis, and saved outputs.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:8","name":"No theory or hype","line":"Every segment covers finance work. There is no AI-theory section.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:9","name":"Mostly hands-on work","line":"About 109 of the 210 minutes are attendee build time, with roughly 25 more minutes for review.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:10","name":"Realistic segment timings","line":"Each main segment gets 40–45 minutes for a demo, a 25-minute build, and checks. Preflight work and checkpoint files support beginners.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:11","name":"Fits the booked time","line":"The agenda uses 3.5 hours and leaves a 30-minute buffer.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:12","name":"Ready to run","line":"The pack supplies named inputs, seeded errors, complete prompts, expected outputs, and checkpoints for every segment.","v":"PASS","g":false}]}},"06-execercise":{"score":100,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":10,"applicable":10,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All three sit in the strategy remit — an execution radar over \"market activation and acquisition integration\" programs he sponsors, a competitive signal desk, and an AI rollout scorecard he explicitly co-owns (\"Sulaiman Rao and I are helping the executive team turn bottom-up AI enthusiasm into credible leadership-led adoption\").","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Data and prompts are anchored in Aurex specifics — programs.csv lists \"MA001,Singapore AUSD partner activation... Aurex Stablecoin (AUSD)\" and \"IN003,Vaultline custody identity integration\", and the watchlist tracks Parity, Brightbank Ledger, Cardinal B2B Connect and Clearnet against AUSD/Treasura/Custody overlap.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Distinct problems: internal program/gate health and decision asks (execution radar), external competitor claim triage against strategy hypotheses (signal desk), and adoption-vs-outcome evidence for AI pilots (scorecard), each with different inputs, artifacts and decision logic.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each PROMPT.md states the role, cutoff, rules source (\"Apply the exact health and activation definitions in README.md\" — README ships in the same folder) and four named deliverables; no placeholders or conversational back-references appear anywhere in the kit.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each prompt enumerates exactly the files present, e.g. idea 1 names \"data/programs.csv, data/milestones.csv, data/dependencies.csv, data/partner_activation.csv, data/slack_updates.json, and data/launch_gate_update.eml\" — the folder's full data listing, with the same one-to-one match in ideas 2 and 3.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Content is substantive and internally consistent — 18 named milestones, 24 partner-week rows (\"P002,Meridian Pacific Payments,MA001,...,250000,150000\"), 23 time trials, 9 full HTML clips with a deliberate correction (S003 narrowing Parity's claim) and a contradicting social rumor (S005); no repeated filler rows or generic \"Competitor 1\" labels.","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every prompt forbids live access and builds only from the folder — \"Do not browse or connect other sources\" and deliverables are \"one self-contained, offline HTML file with embedded data, CSS and JavaScript; no external packages, CDNs, APIs\".","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"folder":"PASS","real-data":"PASS","prompt-per-idea":"PASS"},"usage":null,"scoring_version":3,"dir":"06-execercise/r001","meta":{"task":"06-execercise","model":"gpt-6-astra","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-01T15:54:41Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.151.0","finished":"2026-09-01T16:03:31Z"},"evidence":{"folder":["AV folder: AV","idea folders (3): 01_execution_radar, 02_competitive_signal_desk, 03_ai_rollout_scorecard","01_execution_radar data: OK dependencies.csv (3 rows x 5 cols); OK milestones.csv (19 rows x 10 cols); OK partner_activation.csv (25 rows x 8 cols); OK programs.csv (7 rows x 12 cols); OK slack_updates.json (key 'messages' holds 6 records)","01_execution_radar prompt: PROMPT.md (3895 chars, 532 words)","02_competitive_signal_desk data: OK signal_index.csv (10 rows x 11 cols); OK watchlist.csv (6 rows x 6 cols)","02_competitive_signal_desk prompt: PROMPT.md (3922 chars, 545 words)","03_ai_rollout_scorecard data: OK champion_feedback.json (key 'responses' holds 6 records); OK function_adoption.csv (17 rows x 9 cols); OK governance.csv (9 rows x 7 cols); OK pilots.csv (9 rows x 9 cols); OK time_trials.csv (24 rows x 9 cols)","03_ai_rollout_scorecard prompt: PROMPT.md (4425 chars, 594 words)"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"folder":"task","real-data":"task","prompt-per-idea":"task"},"report":{"summary":"Three complete exercises for the strategy role, with matching prompts and practice data that work without live connections.","edited":true,"tests":[{"key":"code:folder","name":"Idea folders exist","line":"Requires an AV or adrian-vale folder containing two or three idea folders.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:real-data","name":"Usable data files","line":"Checks that each idea has at least one data file in a realistic format that can be read successfully.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:prompt-per-idea","name":"Prompt for each idea","line":"Checks that each idea includes a usable prompt file.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:1","name":"Fits the person's role","line":"Program tracking, competitive intelligence, and AI-adoption measurement fit Adrian Vale's role.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:2","name":"Specific to the company","line":"The exercises use Aurex's products, programs, integration work, and competitors.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:3","name":"Different ideas","line":"Each idea answers a different question about execution, competitors, or AI adoption.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:4","name":"Self-contained prompts","line":"Each prompt includes the role, cutoff date, rules, and deliverables, with all referenced instructions supplied.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:5","name":"Prompts match the data","line":"The files listed in the prompts match the data supplied with each idea.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:6","name":"Realistic practice data","line":"The data includes detailed records, corrected claims, and conflicting reports that require judgment.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:7","name":"Buildable during the session","line":"The prompts build offline HTML tools from local files and prohibit outside connections.","v":"PASS","g":false}]}},"09-pptx":{"score":80,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":12,"applicable":15,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Consistent Theme 2 Consulting/Teal throughout — bg #0F5258, deep #093A40 cards, warm white #FFFEFB text, gold #F8DE6E / amber #BB7B19 / green accents; no theme mixing across slides 1–20.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All headlines and body are Georgia serif (slides 1, 3, 5, 9, 13, 17); Arial appears only via the 11pt `ui()` helper for eyebrow labels, footers and small captions, which the guide permits.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"No triangles, hexagons, slashes, corner brackets, drop shadows, heavy borders, stock photos, gradients or rotated text; containment is rounded cards and pills with 0.6–1pt single-weight lines, and the loop on slide 5 uses a single-weight ellipse.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Stippled classical engravings on slides 1, 2, 4, 9, 15, 17 and 18 (Greek figures with robot, Roman wax tablet, ledger, Colosseum with speech blob) — 7 of 20 — plus a darker-teal organic sweep baked into every background.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every slide 1–20 carries EVERY *Consulting* bottom-left and a right-side session indicator ('30-minute session / NN', 'Reference / NN' on the appendices); no slide is missing it.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Slide 20 admits the guide was never retrieved, and it shows: no 80/20 planning-and-review split, no CLAUDE.md / agents / skills / slash commands, no beliefs to drop, no 0→5 staged path — the loop on slides 5–9 is reconstructed from first principles around a fictional CSV example.","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Not a table of contents — it argues a position ('Faster code is only the beginning', slide 3; 'A feature is finished when it works—and the learning is reusable', slide 4; 'Bad habits can compound, too', slide 13) and spends its 30 minutes on a worked example, a 3-minute exercise and an adoption experiment.","scope":"task"},{"id":8,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each slide holds one message with generous margins — slide 5 is the loop alone, slide 8 is four review lenses under one question, slide 10 is a single bad-note/good-note contrast; nothing is packed beyond what a room can read.","scope":"task"},{"id":9,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Real constructions dominate: circular loop diagram (5), three-step progression (7), 2×2 lens grid (8), four-column artifact progression (11), trap→habit comparison (13), and 50/50 illustration splits (1, 2, 4, 9, 17); almost no plain bulleted lists.","scope":"task"},{"id":10,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"No text runs off-edge, is clipped by its container, or collides — the two-line wraps on slides 6 and 8 sit inside their boxes, and the dark-teal-on-teal cards and white card on slide 10 all hold readable contrast.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"opens":"PASS","slide-count":"PASS","no-overlap":"FAIL","render":"PASS","palette":"FAIL"},"usage":null,"scoring_version":3,"dir":"09-pptx/r001","meta":{"task":"09-pptx","model":"gpt-6-astra","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-01T15:54:41Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.151.0","finished":"2026-09-01T16:07:27Z"},"evidence":{"opens":["deck: compound-engineering-every.pptx (18776072 bytes)","python-pptx opened the deck","slide 13: 'Text 6' overlaps 'Text 7' (32% of the smaller box, 0.07 sq in)","slide 13: 'Text 9' overlaps 'Text 10' (32% of the smaller box, 0.07 sq in)","slide 13: 'Text 12' overlaps 'Text 13' (32% of the smaller box, 0.07 sq in)","slide 13: 'Text 15' overlaps 'Text 16' (32% of the smaller box, 0.07 sq in)","slides: 20 (want 8-20)","render: 20 PNG(s) in work/_screenshots"],"palette":["palette: theme=consulting across 20 slide(s); signature=3.79% (floor 0.40%), non-bg on-palette=86% (floor 60%)","background off-palette on 20 slide(s): slide-01.png, slide-02.png, slide-03.png, slide-04.png, slide-05.png, slide-06.png"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"opens":"task","slide-count":"task","no-overlap":"task","render":"task","palette":"task"}},"10-talkform":{"score":100,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":7,"applicable":7,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The entry page's hero headline reads \"Less like a form. More like a conversation.\" with the sub \"You bring the questions. Your AI interviewer brings them to life.\" — a reader-facing promise rather than a category or technology label.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sage-green-on-cream palette with considered type, restrained iconography, real product chrome (sidebar, breadcrumbs, stat cards) and a custom waveform illustration — nothing like purple-gradient-on-black slop.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The builder defines typed questions (text/email/number/rating/choice/boolean, required, options — server/schema.js), the interview prompt injects that specific form's fields plus current answers and missing fields (server/ai.js), and returned updates are normalized per-type and merged into answers keyed by question id, stored and exported as structured columns.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"boots":"PASS","really-calls-api":"PASS","auth-exists":"PASS","screenshots":"PASS"},"usage":null,"scoring_version":3,"dir":"10-talkform/r001","meta":{"task":"10-talkform","model":"gpt-6-astra","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"true","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-01T15:54:41Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.151.0","finished":"2026-09-01T16:24:42Z"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"boots":"task","really-calls-api":"task","auth-exists":"task","screenshots":"task"}},"11-hoboken-map":{"score":88,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":7,"applicable":8,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"index.html is fully self-contained (Leaflet inlined, data embedded, no fetches) and the screenshots show a polished double-click-ready page with named places, labeled category filters, search, sort and zoom controls — the only blemish is a CARTO tile watermark, which is not a listed failure mode.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"methodology.md locks a named prior ranking of 10 restaurants, four directional predictions, a top-three, a formula and explicit pass/fail criteria (hash-committed and matching), and validation.md reports that the locked test failed (1/3 pairwise, rho 0.217) without retuning — a test the priors clearly could have failed.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Checked Augustino's (1104 Washington), Fiore's House of Quality (414 Adams, the hidden-gem #1), Lola's Tapas (153 14th St), ResilienCity Park (1200 Jefferson) and Liberty Science Center (222 Jersey City Blvd) — all real with correct towns and plausible coordinates.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"renders":"PASS","categories":"PASS","artifacts":"PASS","reproducible":"PASS","gems-vs-traps":"FAIL"},"usage":null,"scoring_version":3,"dir":"11-hoboken-map/r001","meta":{"task":"11-hoboken-map","model":"gpt-6-astra","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"true","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-01T15:54:41Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.151.0","finished":"2026-09-01T16:16:53Z"},"evidence":{"renders":["AUDITED: explicit scoring artifacts; see score.json audit_corrections."],"reproducible":["re-ran score.py; scores.json matches"],"gems-vs-traps":["NA - places-good.txt / places-traps.txt are still placeholders (need Mike's full lists, >=5 entries each)"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"renders":"task","categories":"task","artifacts":"task","reproducible":"task","gems-vs-traps":"task"}},"12-roleplay-interview":{"score":38,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":6,"applicable":16,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim: \"I want anyone who wants to become a developer to be able to call GitHub home. AI can help more people get started\" lands the real on-ramp/expansive-developer move (\"we want to make it easier for people to choose to try to write some code and make sure there's always an on-ramp\").","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim offers only generic human-oversight + \"Agent HQ ... with governance and developer choice\"; real answer names agentic Copilot code review, agentic merge, maintainer controls and refusing to impose a standard (Hashimoto vouch) — none present.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim cites the same order-of-magnitude growth (\"275 million commits a week ... Actions growth from about 500 million to 2.1 billion minutes\") and the scaling response (\"more CPU capacity, service scaling\"), matching real \"a billion commits ... 14 billion if the growth is linear\" plus \"investing heavily in preparing for the next wave of growth,\" though it hedges on agent attribution.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim abstains — \"The available record doesn't establish my position on moving from freemium toward usage-based pricing\" — missing real's API rate limits, enabling the 150-agent user with a great free core, and the free-private-repos precedent.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim denies the premise (\"this record doesn't establish the marketing role\") and pivots to MUST/SHOULD/COULD; real gave 13 years at GitHub, \"we're not building for the buyers, we're building for the developers,\" continuing as COO while becoming CMO of Developer, and the Build-in-SF example.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim abstains — \"I can't substantiate that 'first' from the public record\" — versus real \"It's the first Build that I think, by intention, we've focused on having speakers from the community ... software development is a team sport.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim: \"developer choice ... a place to work with agents from different providers\" matches real \"we care a lot about like developer choice ... we always want to enable developers ... to go use these other tools, and we'll partner with everyone.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":8,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim restates only external product choice and abstains on the trade-off (\"The supplied record doesn't establish ... my decision about a dogfooding-versus-experimentation trade-off\"); real answered directly — \"we all are using a variety of tools because otherwise you lose track,\" Mac/Windows/AlmaLinux, laser focus is \"myopic.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":9,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim gives \"What must be true? What should we achieve if we can? What could we do with the capacity left?\" plus Think Week; real named concurrent agent sessions short-term, token economics/local models, and personalization/memory/fine-tuning as the durable truth.","scope":"task"},{"id":10,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim abstains — \"There's no grounded account in this record of what 'hill climbing' meant\" — versus real's usage/thumbs-up-down data improving models, weekly hill-climbing reviews of hard and soft measures, frontier tuning, \"climb, improve, new eval, improve.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":11,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim abstains — \"I don't have a sourced position in this record linking hill climbing to subscription prices\" — versus real's frontier-tuned models plus automatic model selection (\"auto model router with task intent,\" Foundry's API-level router).","scope":"task"},{"id":12,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim offers only \"using AI to take repetitive work off employees' plates\" and a delegation brief, declining anecdotes; real described his own walled-off Claude named Baxter, a daily comms report, \"humans are way more willing to take critical feedback from robots,\" and a backward-looking seven-day loop.","scope":"task"},{"id":13,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"The framework appears as the decision structure in Q5 (\"I use MUST, SHOULD, and COULD to make priorities explicit\"), Q9 (\"What must be true? What should we achieve if we can? What could we do...\") and Q10 (\"establish what must hold\"), where the real Daigle never used it.","scope":"task"},{"id":14,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Ungrounded subjects are plainly flagged rather than invented — e.g. \"The persona explicitly identifies monetization and pricing as underdocumented,\" \"contains no grounded position or statement about this Build claim,\" \"The persona documents no hill-climbing position\" — each with a confirm-with-the-real-person note.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"answered":"PASS","disclaimers":"PASS"},"usage":null,"scoring_version":3,"dir":"12-roleplay-interview/r001","meta":{"task":"12-roleplay-interview","model":"gpt-6-astra","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-01T15:54:41Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.151.0","finished":"2026-09-01T15:56:47Z"},"evidence":{"answered":["12 questions parsed from questions.md","answers read from: work/ANSWER.md","Q01 answered, 154 words: The demographics of the customer are changing. A lot of people who may...","Q02 answered, 158 words: How do you help developers deal with the burden of all the extra pull ...","Q03 answered, 155 words: You have a front-row seat to this new agent economy. You said publicly...","Q04 answered, 125 words: How does the business model change? Freemium makes sense in a human-ce...","Q05 answered, 131 words: Pricing leads back into the wider Microsoft orbit. You now have a dual...","Q06 answered, 101 words: Did I hear you say that this is the first Build conference to have ext...","Q07 answered, 125 words: This is a very competitive market, and the pace of change is quick. Ho...","Q08 answered, 134 words: There was a recent news cycle about Claude Code licenses being cancele...","Q09 answered, 151 words: A lot of these ideas are relatively short-lived, while enterprise prod...","Q10 answered, 122 words: I heard the term \"hill climbing\" a hundred times yesterday. Can you ta...","Q11 answered, 131 words: Is hill climbing the answer to stopping a $200 subscription from becom...","Q12 answered, 159 words: I made an AI version of you to practice this interview and found it im...","must/should/could framework appears in: Q5 (informational, judged in judge.md)"],"disclaimers":["verify-with-the-real-person note attached to: Q1, Q2, Q3, Q4, Q5, Q6, Q8, Q9, Q10, Q11, Q12"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"answered":"task","disclaimers":"task"},"report":{"summary":"The simulation avoids inventing unsupported details, but misses most specific answers and repeatedly substitutes a priorities framework.","edited":true,"tests":[{"key":"code:answered","name":"All questions answered","line":"Checks that every question in questions.md has a substantive answer.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:disclaimers","name":"Per-answer verification notes","line":"Checks that verification notes are attached to individual answers, not just added once for the whole document.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:1","name":"Customers and roadmap","line":"It says GitHub should welcome anyone who wants to become a developer, matching the real answer's emphasis on getting started.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:2","name":"Maintainers and pull requests","line":"It gives general oversight and governance points but misses the real answer's code review, agentic merge, and maintainer controls.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:3","name":"Growth in agent use","line":"Its commit and Actions growth figures support the same scale-up point as the real answer, though it is cautious about attributing growth to agents.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:4","name":"Usage-based pricing","line":"It abstains on pricing and misses the real answer's rate limits, heavy agent use, and useful free core.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:5","name":"Microsoft marketing role","line":"It says the record does not establish the marketing role. The real answer confirmed that role alongside GitHub COO.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:6","name":"Outside contributors at Build","line":"It cannot substantiate the Build claim. The real answer confirmed community speakers and explained the reason for including them.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:7","name":"Standing out from competitors","line":"It matches the real answer's commitment to developer choice and partnerships across providers.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:8","name":"Using rival tools","line":"It discusses external product choice and abstains on internal practice. The real answer described employees experimenting with other tools.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:9","name":"Short trends, long projects","line":"It gives must/should/could priorities and thinking time. The real answer covered concurrent agents, token economics, and personalization.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:10","name":"Focus on model improvement","line":"It abstains on hill climbing. The real answer described usage feedback, weekly reviews, tuning, and repeated evaluation.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:11","name":"Keeping subscriptions affordable","line":"It abstains on the pricing link and misses the real answer's personalized models and automatic model selection.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:12","name":"Unexpected agent uses","line":"It gives general automation and delegation ideas. The real answer described Baxter's writing feedback and review of recent communications.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:13","name":"No MUST/SHOULD/COULD framework","line":"It uses MUST/SHOULD/COULD or the same structure in three answers. That framework is absent from the real interview.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:14","name":"Admits unknown answers","line":"It marks unsupported subjects and asks the real person to confirm them, rather than supplying invented details.","v":"PASS","g":false}]}}},"files":[{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":10190,"kind":"output"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/prompt.md","size":118,"kind":"input"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/_screenshots/fold.png","size":146622,"kind":"check"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/_screenshots/full.png","size":490845,"kind":"check"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/_screenshots/interaction.png","size":184548,"kind":"check"},{"path":"02-hotel/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":2594,"kind":"output"},{"path":"02-hotel/r001/work/prompt.md","size":557,"kind":"input"},{"path":"03-writeup/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":12396,"kind":"output"},{"path":"03-writeup/r001/work/prompt.md","size":1761,"kind":"input"},{"path":"04-thematic/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":9268,"kind":"output"},{"path":"04-thematic/r001/work/prompt.md","size":127,"kind":"input"},{"path":"05-showrunner/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":8730,"kind":"output"},{"path":"05-showrunner/r001/work/prompt.md","size":3574,"kind":"input"},{"path":"06-execercise/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":362,"kind":"output"},{"path":"06-execercise/r001/work/prompt.md","size":421,"kind":"input"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":2114,"kind":"output"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/prompt.md","size":350,"kind":"input"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-01.png","size":979591,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-02.png","size":939294,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-03.png","size":617476,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-04.png","size":1213872,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-05.png","size":902857,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-06.png","size":631084,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-07.png","size":653773,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-08.png","size":654978,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-09.png","size":1067259,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-10.png","size":656685,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-11.png","size":816986,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-12.png","size":869991,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-13.png","size":913574,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-14.png","size":869241,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-15.png","size":1013969,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-16.png","size":925477,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-17.png","size":873081,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-18.png","size":922250,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-19.png","size":996426,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-20.png","size":1009059,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":2696,"kind":"output"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/prompt.md","size":382,"kind":"input"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/auth-audited.png","size":493188,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/builder.png","size":125795,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/interview-audited.png","size":560288,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/interview.png","size":251249,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/landing-full.png","size":367818,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/landing.png","size":322372,"kind":"check"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":5750,"kind":"output"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/prompt.md","size":1643,"kind":"input"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/_screenshots/full.png","size":838255,"kind":"check"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/_screenshots/map.png","size":526764,"kind":"check"},{"path":"12-roleplay-interview/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":15584,"kind":"output"},{"path":"12-roleplay-interview/r001/work/prompt.md","size":1956,"kind":"input"},{"path":"06-execercise/r001/work/AV/ANSWER.md","size":5109,"kind":"output"}],"avg":83},{"id":"2026-09-01__grok-4.6__grok","date":"2026-09-01","model":"grok-4.6","agent":"grok","variant":null,"tasks":{"01-dashboard":{"score":100,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":9,"applicable":9,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Warm cream/ink editorial palette with green-and-rust accents and a single dark stat card — nowhere near purple-on-black dark mode.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Deliberate type system (Fraunces display serif, Instrument Sans body, IBM Plex Mono for numerals) rendering at comfortable sizes with high contrast and no clipping.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The findings section names comment-level patterns not derivable from the score distribution — Mac-only lock-in as a post-purchase churn event (avg 5.00), the AI-pivot cluster orphaning old readers (avg 5.75), and passives who can name the parts but not the point.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"fold.png shows the +45 NPS gauge alongside promoters 54.9%/107, passives 35.4%/69, detractors 9.7%/19 plus the full score histogram.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"\"They came for the writing. They stay if the tools feel real.\" states a specific, data-supported tension from this survey (writing praised even by detractors; product/platform friction driving the low scores) rather than a generic label.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"renders":"PASS","nps-correct":"PASS","distribution-shown":"PASS","interactive":"PASS"},"usage":null,"scoring_version":3,"dir":"01-dashboard/r001","meta":{"task":"01-dashboard","model":"grok-4.6","agent":"grok","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-01T19:13:21Z","agent_version":"grok 1.0.5 (5115b46bc909) [stable]","finished":"2026-09-01T19:22:38Z"},"evidence":{"interactive":["text input filtered on 'AI'"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"renders":"task","nps-correct":"task","distribution-shown":"task","interactive":"task"}},"02-hotel":{"score":67,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":6,"applicable":9,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"\"1 Hotel South Beach (2341 Collins Ave)\" is a marquee luxury beachfront resort in the Faena/Setai tier, and the output itself hedges \"if 1 Hotel is sold out or too expensive.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"\"calm, design-forward, and actually usable as a workplace: decent desks, outdoor nooks\" — nowhere near budget/hostel territory.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"\"sits at the north end of South Beach, not in the Ocean Drive party strip... calm, design-forward\" — a distinctive property, not an interchangeable corporate chain.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"\"Kyu (251 NW 25th St, Wynwood)... Wood-fired Asian, shareable plates, a real bar, warehouse-garden room... one of Miami's default 'this is a good Miami dinner' restaurants.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"\"Dinner at Kyu, 7:00 or 7:30pm\" after the SoBe call block, with \"Leave the hotel by 7:45am\" for a 9am Wynwood workshop — consistent with the stated schedule.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Has an explicit \"## Assumptions\" section, travel math (\"MIA to 1 Hotel is typically 30–45 minutes\", \"about 15–20 minutes at that hour\"), weather contingencies (\"decent chance of a late-afternoon storm... Have an indoor fallback table\"), and room-noise advice (\"a room away from elevator banks / pool deck\").","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","not-verbose":"FAIL","concrete":"PASS"},"usage":null,"scoring_version":3,"dir":"02-hotel/r001","meta":{"task":"02-hotel","model":"grok-4.6","agent":"grok","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-01T20:33:05Z","agent_version":"grok 1.0.5 (5115b46bc909) [stable]","finished":"2026-09-01T20:36:30Z"},"evidence":{"concrete":["hotel=1 Hotel South Beach; restaurant=Kyu"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"exists":"task","not-verbose":"task","concrete":"task"},"report":{"summary":"KYU fits the dinner, but 1 Hotel South Beach is too expensive for the brief. The recommendation also runs long.","edited":true,"tests":[{"key":"code:exists","name":"Recommendation exists","line":"Requires a recommendation document of at least 30 words.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:not-verbose","name":"Length limit","line":"Limits the recommendation documents to 1,000 words in total.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"code:concrete","name":"Names both places","line":"Requires both 'Hotel pick:' and 'Restaurant pick:' lines, each followed by a place name. Empty entries and placeholders do not count.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:1","name":"Reasonable hotel price","line":"1 Hotel South Beach is a luxury beachfront resort outside the intended price range.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:2","name":"Decent hotel","line":"The hotel is comfortably above the budget tier, with places to work.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:3","name":"Hotel character","line":"The hotel has a distinctive design and a quieter South Beach location.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:4","name":"Suitable client dinner","line":"KYU's shared plates and bar make it a suitable client dinner choice.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:5","name":"Fits the schedule","line":"Dinner follows the calls, and the plan allows time to reach the Friday workshop.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:6","name":"No unnecessary extras","line":"It adds assumptions, travel calculations, storm contingencies, and room-noise advice.","v":"FAIL","g":false}]}},"03-writeup":{"score":60,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":6,"applicable":10,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Dense machine-writing antithesis and stacked aphorisms throughout — \"That's not a party trick. It's the job.\", \"Raising the floor is a compliance exercise. Raising the ceiling is a talent strategy. Only one of those produces adoption.\", \"Not on slide 14. On the first thing they build\", \"You don't have an adoption plan. You have a hobby\", plus tricolons like \"Teach context switching. Teach evals. Teach taste.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"All seven sections run the identical template — numbered bold label, setup, example, then a tidy epigrammatic closer: \"Guided theory is useful as motivation. Build time is where the belief gets installed.\" / \"Impossible work is how you make the old job stop making sense.\" / \"It's how you give the model a memory of the business.\" / \"Do not skip the mapping step and hope a seat license finds the workflows for you.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"First person, opinionated, and argued through concrete examples in the sample's register, including a deliberate echo of its move — \"Look around at your coworkers. Everybody you work with is, by definition, already capable of using a computer in English.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The transcript's specifics survive intact: \"Everyone on our consulting team uses Granola, plus the Granola MCP\", \"Boris Cherny... slightly under-resource most teams\", \"one blog post a week... one post a day\", \"$5,000 of tokens a month behind a $200 subscription\", \"co-opting them as TAs in the courses\", and \"an individual project for each person in the room.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Invents client details and a surname found nowhere in the transcript, tweet, or prompt — \"hedge funds, PE firms, tech companies, Fortune 500s\" and \"Natalia Quintero (@NataliaZarina)\", which its own note concedes came \"from public Every material; not named in the interview.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Both are reproduced on the page — Sam Parr's question is quoted (\"How is everyone getting team adoption for Claude? We see all this AI stuff popping up...\") and all seven learnings appear as a numbered list from \"Buy the model direct, not third-party tools\" through \"Train people to be managers of agents.\"","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","tweet-included":"PASS","not-verbose":"FAIL","ai-tells-grep":"PASS"},"usage":null,"scoring_version":3,"dir":"03-writeup/r001","meta":{"task":"03-writeup","model":"grok-4.6","agent":"grok","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-01T19:13:21Z","agent_version":"grok 1.0.5 (5115b46bc909) [stable]","finished":"2026-09-01T19:17:42Z"},"evidence":{"exists":["post: work/ANSWER.md (2575 words)"],"tweet-included":["learnings found (7/7): buy the model direct not 3rd party tools; raise the ceiling not the floor; workshops with 50%+ build time; assign impossible tasks; mandatory AI note taking + MCP connector; map workflows and systematically automate; train people to be managers (of agents)"],"not-verbose":["51 prose paragraphs, mean 45.4 words, 0 over 100 words","verbose: total 2575 > 2400 words"]},"skill_current":"v2","gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"exists":"task","tweet-included":"task","not-verbose":"task","ai-tells-grep":"task"}},"04-thematic":{"score":100,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":7,"applicable":7,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All six priorities carry concrete teachable content with named exercises and time blocks — e.g. Priority 1's vague-prompt-vs-tagged-files+golden-example diff comparison (90 min lab), Priority 2's 'three AI diffs, one subtly wrong in business logic' review lab, Priority 5's gold-set vs proxy-metric elective built on Nina's 100–250 labelled docs; even the weakest (Priority 6, AI-first workflow) specifies a reproduce→plan→slice→tests→PR loop, throwaway prototypes for alignment, and a publish-one-rule exercise rather than surviving as a heading.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Where the output reuses interview phrases it does the substance work behind them: 'context is king' becomes front-loading files, golden examples, anti-antipattern rules, and CLI-over-flaky-MCP because Ben hit Confluence/Jira MCP performance problems; 'AI-first' is reframed as closing the measured Ben-power-user / Nina-basic-user gap through shared artifacts. It also explicitly rejects the shallow candidates — 'write better Confluence so the model can read it' and MCP-as-knowledge-fix — on the grounds that stale docs are an ops problem, not a training topic.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each priority traces to named lines: P2 to Nina's plausible-but-subtly-wrong code and weak e2e coverage plus Raj's skepticism on migrations/regulated data, P3 to Nina's back-and-forth workflow and over-engineering on complex prompts alongside Ben's coverage/flag-removal agents, P4 to Raj's prior third-party data-sharing incident and Nina's Anthropic data-isolation contracts, P5 to the document-interpretation gold set and Ben's unimplemented DSPy interest. Extrapolations (enterprise Cursor configuration) are quarantined in an explicit assumptions section rather than asserted as Northcove fact.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All three engineers visibly shape the set at their distinct altitudes: Nina supplies the hands-on failure modes (over-engineering, wrong legacy context, missing integration tests) and the LLM-feature evaluation track, Ben supplies the power-user layer (agent chores, rules/commands as org infrastructure, directionally-correct prototypes, MCP dead end), and Raj supplies org-wide constraints (compliance and the prior incident, editors-not-authors, CI/deploy timings, suspicious senior cohort). The audience-split table and 'Ben is the internal multiplier, use him as faculty' show the three are treated as different vantage points, not one summary.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The themes are explicitly ranked 1–6 with reasoning for the ordering ('context engineering... highest leverage; all three interviews'), and Priority 5 is scoped down to a half-day elective 'not the default track for all 100 engineers.' It also states what to cut — Cursor 101, MCP setup, PRD generation, user-research synthesis, autonomous feature agents on the monolith — and gives a degraded fallback (2-hour context+compliance studio plus the rules pack) if the org won't fund artifacts.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","theme-count":"PASS"},"usage":null,"scoring_version":3,"dir":"04-thematic/r001","meta":{"task":"04-thematic","model":"grok-4.6","agent":"grok","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-01T19:18:40Z","agent_version":"grok 1.0.5 (5115b46bc909) [stable]","finished":"2026-09-01T19:20:48Z"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"exists":"task","theme-count":"task"}},"05-showrunner":{"score":94,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":15,"applicable":16,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every segment is Cowork + Claude in Excel; run sheet and prework explicitly bar Claude Code, Terminal, GitHub ('Do not install or require Claude Code, and do not ask anyone to open Terminal').","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Build 1 (10:28–11:15, 47 min) has attendees produce dashboard.html from 06_Accounting_MonthlyPnL_Export_Feb2026.xlsx with Prompts 1/1b/1c including campus dropdown and horizontal bars.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Build 2 (11:42–12:25, 43 min) is a separate segment where Cowork uses Python to write Feb_close_analysis.xlsx (Control_Totals, EBITDA_Bridge, Payroll_Recon) plus a Claude-in-Excel pass.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Build 3 (12:25–13:10, 45 min) has attendees fill 07_MonthlyPack_TEMPLATE_Feb2026.pptx and save as Brightmoor_Monthly_Review_Feb2026.pptx, with fallback guidance for anyone 'still on slide 3'.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The workshop pack contains real NetSuite-shaped files (chart of accounts, budget-vs-actual income statement by Location/Class/Department, trial balance, transaction detail, ADP register, FP&A forecast) with a header reading 'Source system: Oracle NetSuite → Snowflake → Excel extract'.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Opening hands-on is Prompt 0, a first-look Excel snapshot of February revenue/EBITDA/campus misses; the doc states 'You have just replaced the ASCII map.'","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Segment 2 keeps the framing: 'ChatGPT and Gemini answer. Cowork works on a folder: it reads the extract, runs the analysis, and writes the Excel, the HTML, and the PowerPoint.'","scope":"task"},{"id":8,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"No AI-context or future-of-work segment; the run sheet says 'No origin story. No \"exciting time for AI\"' and every block maps to close, dashboard, analysis or the monthly pack.","scope":"task"},{"id":9,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Build segments total 135 min (47+43+45) of 210, plus ~14 min of hands-on prompting in segment 2 — roughly 70% attendee build time.","scope":"task"},{"id":10,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Build blocks are 47/43/45 min with Talk-Jam-Make-Tune sub-timings, a 9:45 door check, prework for licenses/downloads, and explicit expectation-setting that a 15-pager won't one-shot.","scope":"task"},{"id":11,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Schedule runs 10:00–13:30 = 3h30m, with the remaining 30 min of the four-hour hold called out as setup slack.","scope":"task"},{"id":12,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Facilitator has verbatim scripts, named data files, a full demo-prompts.md of paste-ready prompts, expected outputs ('Feb revenue $7.936M vs budget $8.100M'), an answer key, and a crash list.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","format":"PASS","timings-tie-out":"PASS","time-grain":"FAIL"},"usage":null,"scoring_version":3,"dir":"05-showrunner/r001","meta":{"task":"05-showrunner","model":"grok-4.6","agent":"grok","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-01T20:33:05Z","agent_version":"grok 1.0.5 (5115b46bc909) [stable]","finished":"2026-09-01T20:47:45Z"},"evidence":{"format":["candidate documents: ANSWER.md, agenda-for-dana.md, demo-prompts.md, prework.md, run-of-show-brightmoor.md, README.md, answer-key.md, notes.md, README.md","run of show: run-of-show-brightmoor.md (11 time-ranged segments in 1 schedule(s))"],"timings-tie-out":["schedule 1 of 1","schedule: 11 segments, 225 min span, 225 min scheduled, 0 min in breaks"],"time-grain":["off-grid boundaries: 10 (allowed 1)","off-grid: end of '1. The job' at :08","off-grid: start of '2. Cowork vs ChatGPT + first Excel promp' at :08","off-grid: end of '2. Cowork vs ChatGPT + first Excel promp' at :28","off-grid: start of '3. Build 1 — Dashboard' at :28","off-grid: end of '4. Neighbor share' at :22","off-grid: start of '5. Break' at :22"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"exists":"task","format":"task","timings-tie-out":"task","time-grain":"task"},"report":{"summary":"A finance-focused workshop with realistic build blocks, prepared data, and fallbacks for attendees who get stuck.","edited":true,"tests":[{"key":"code:exists","name":"Run of show exists","line":"Checks that a run-of-show document was produced.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:format","name":"Coherent schedule","line":"Requires one coherent schedule with at least five timed activities. No activity can end before it starts; tables, lists, headings, and plain lines are accepted.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:timings-tie-out","name":"Timings add up","line":"Checks for no overlaps or gaps longer than 30 minutes, at least 85% of the span scheduled, and a total span of 45–600 minutes.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:time-grain","name":"Five-minute time marks","line":"Checks that start and end times fall on five-minute marks, allowing at most one exception.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:1","name":"Uses Cowork throughout","line":"Uses Cowork and Claude in Excel, with no Claude Code, terminal, or GitHub work.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:2","name":"Dashboard exercise","line":"Attendees spend 47 minutes building a P&L dashboard with campus selection and bar charts.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:3","name":"Financial analysis exercise","line":"A 43-minute Excel build covers control totals, EBITDA, and payroll, followed by an Excel review.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:4","name":"PowerPoint exercise","line":"Attendees get 45 minutes to update a PowerPoint template, with a fallback if they fall behind.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:5","name":"Relevant business data","line":"The files follow a NetSuite-to-Snowflake-to-Excel workflow and include accounts, budgets, actuals, trial balances, transactions, payroll, and forecasts.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:6","name":"No ASCII icebreaker","line":"The first exercise looks at revenue, EBITDA, and campus misses in Excel. There is no ASCII-art task.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:7","name":"Explains Cowork versus ChatGPT","line":"The introduction explains how Cowork reads files, analyzes them, and writes Excel, HTML, and PowerPoint outputs.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:8","name":"No theory or hype","line":"The agenda focuses on finance work and skips AI origin stories and hype.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:9","name":"Mostly hands-on work","line":"There are 135 minutes of builds plus 14 minutes of prompting practice, about 70% of the session.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:10","name":"Realistic segment timings","line":"The builds get 47, 43, and 45 minutes, with prework, a door check, and time to revise the deck.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:11","name":"Fits the booked time","line":"The workshop runs from 10:00 to 13:30 and leaves 30 minutes for setup or delays.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:12","name":"Ready to run","line":"The facilitator gets scripts, prompts, named files, expected values, an answer key, and troubleshooting notes.","v":"PASS","g":false}]}},"06-execercise":{"score":100,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":10,"applicable":10,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All three ideas sit in strategy/corp-dev remit — M&A integration + market activation dashboard, competitive intelligence brief, and a cross-company staff pre-read built from 'the SI-owned and SI-shepherded programs' (initiative_portfolio.csv), not generic exec productivity.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Deliverables are saturated with Aurex specifics — 'AUSD collateral attach fees' synergy lines, the five 2025 deals (Northwind/Prime, Treasura, Tideway, Vaultline, Castellan), the messaging-vs-on-network partner funnel, and the payments/token competitive set (Clearnet, Beacon, Brightbank Ledger, Cardinal, Parity/PUSD).","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Distinct problems and artifacts: an HTML program-operating dashboard, an external competitive brief plus reusable weekly briefing engine, and a 700-word decision-oriented staff pre-read with talking points.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each PROMPT.md is a copy-paste block with full company framing, named output filenames ('a single-file HTML dashboard named aurex-activation-os.html'), explicit structure, and no placeholders or references to prior conversation.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every prompt enumerates its folder's files exactly and each shipped file is referenced — e.g. prompt 02 lists all six data files plus 'twelve items' in news_clips/ (12 present) and three emails (3 present).","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Content is specific and internally consistent, not filler — e.g. raid_log R-002 'AUSD go-live date promised as Q2 sold as Q3 engineered' with a cost-of-delay note, 30 workstream rows, 24 KPI rows with confidence flags, and .eml/.ics/.json files with realistic headers and named actors.","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each prompt states 'All processing happens from these local files. Do not try to call Slack, Gmail, or an API' / 'Local files only', and the README notes connectors are optional so 'permissions cannot block the build.'","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"folder":"PASS","real-data":"PASS","prompt-per-idea":"PASS"},"usage":null,"scoring_version":3,"dir":"06-execercise/r001","meta":{"task":"06-execercise","model":"grok-4.6","agent":"grok","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-01T20:33:05Z","agent_version":"grok 1.0.5 (5115b46bc909) [stable]","finished":"2026-09-01T20:47:17Z"},"evidence":{"folder":["AV folder: AV","idea folders (3): 01-ma-market-activation-dashboard, 02-competitive-intelligence-brief, 03-exec-staff-preread","01-ma-market-activation-dashboard data: OK acquisitions.csv (6 rows x 16 cols); OK integration_workstreams.csv (31 rows x 13 cols); OK license_status.csv (16 rows x 11 cols); BAD market_launches.csv (inconsistent columns at row(s) [7] (header has 15)); OK partner_activation_funnel.csv (20 rows x 10 cols); OK raid_log.csv (16 rows x 12 cols); OK synergy_tracker.csv (19 rows x 10 cols)","01-ma-market-activation-dashboard prompt: PROMPT.md (6586 chars, 1074 words)","02-competitive-intelligence-brief data: OK competitor_kpis.csv (25 rows x 8 cols); BAD competitor_profiles.csv (inconsistent columns at row(s) [4] (header has 10)); BAD win_loss_q4_q1.csv (inconsistent columns at row(s) [6] (header has 13))","02-competitive-intelligence-brief prompt: PROMPT.md (4975 chars, 791 words)","03-exec-staff-preread data: OK ai_use_case_inventory.csv (23 rows x 10 cols); OK initiative_portfolio.csv (19 rows x 13 cols); OK open_decisions.csv (13 rows x 11 cols); OK slack_export.json (key 'channels' holds 2 records)","03-exec-staff-preread prompt: PROMPT.md (5079 chars, 835 words)"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"folder":"task","real-data":"task","prompt-per-idea":"task"},"report":{"summary":"Three company-specific exercises with complete prompts and realistic data, covering operations, competitor analysis, and staff decisions.","edited":true,"tests":[{"key":"code:folder","name":"Idea folders exist","line":"Requires an AV or adrian-vale folder containing two or three idea folders.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:real-data","name":"Usable data files","line":"Checks that each idea has at least one data file in a realistic format that can be read successfully.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:prompt-per-idea","name":"Prompt for each idea","line":"Checks that each idea includes a usable prompt file.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:1","name":"Fits the person's role","line":"The dashboard, competitor briefing, and staff pre-read fit the strategic-initiatives role.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:2","name":"Specific to the company","line":"The exercises use Aurex's acquisitions, settlement products, partner funnel, and competitors.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:3","name":"Different ideas","line":"The ideas produce an operating dashboard, a competitor briefing, and a decision-focused staff pre-read.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:4","name":"Self-contained prompts","line":"Each prompt includes the company context, required structure, and named output files.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:5","name":"Prompts match the data","line":"The prompts accurately list the supplied data, news clips, and emails.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:6","name":"Realistic practice data","line":"The records include specific risks, conflicting dates, confidence levels, and realistic messages.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:7","name":"Buildable during the session","line":"The prompts use local files only, so missing permissions cannot block the exercises.","v":"PASS","g":false}]}},"09-pptx":{"score":80,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":12,"applicable":15,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every slide uses Theme 2 exactly — background 0F5258 with 0A3D42 depth, FFFEFB text, F8DE6E/BB7B19/2E8D23/4999A0 accents; no Theme 1 colors appear anywhere and there is no theme mixing across slides 1-18.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All headlines and body prose are Georgia (522 runs); Calibri (171 runs) is confined to 11-14pt labels — eyebrows like 'The shift' (s4), the 'Session 1' footer, agenda time stamps (s2), numerals 01/02/03 (s3), and command names (s8, s16).","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Only rect and roundRect geometry is used across the deck — no triangles, hexagons, slashes or corner brackets — and the XML contains zero gradFill, outerShdw, effectLst or rot attributes; card borders are a single hairline (0.016in) and imagery is stippled classical engraving, not stock photography.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"16 of 18 slides carry a signature element — swooshes cropped at the edge on s1, s3, s5, s7, s13, s14, s16, s17, s18 and stippled classical illustrations (Parthenon/robot, fallen colossus, busts, seated figure, Colosseum, filing cabinet) on s1, s4, s8, s9, s11, s12, s15, s18; only s6 and s10 carry texture alone.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All 18 slides, including the title and closer, carry 'EVERY Consulting' bottom-left and the 'Session 1' indicator bottom-right, in identical position and treatment.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"The deck restructures the guide's four-step loop (plan → work → review → compound) into an invented 'six-step loop' with a 'Simplify' step the guide never mentions (s7, s10, s16), and hangs the whole session — including the closing assignment on s17 — on a fabricated command namespace (/ce-setup, /ce-plan, /ce-work, /ce-simplify, /ce-review, /ce-compound, /ce-dogfood, /ce-ideate, /ce-pov), a fabricated repo 'compound-engineering-plugin' and a fabricated '.compound-engineering/config.yaml', none of which exist in the guide (real ones: /workflows:*, /lfg, /triage, every-marketplace); it also never names CLAUDE.md, the guide's most-emphasized artifact, and omits the 80/20 split, the beliefs to let go, and the 0→5 ladder.","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"It is not a table of contents — it makes editorial choices with a clear argument (s4 'bad code was the old tax, a weak plan is the tax now', s12 'a correction that lives in Slack is charity, a correction that lives in the repo is an asset', s13 'you are the bread, the agent is the filling'), budgets the 30 minutes explicitly on s2, and closes with a concrete three-move assignment on s17.","scope":"task"},{"id":8,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each slide carries a single message with generous whitespace — s5 is one quote, s14 is one 50/50 split, s12 is one step — and the densest slides (s7's six loop cards, s16's eight command cards) are single enumerated concepts at readable size, not multiple competing ideas.","scope":"task"},{"id":9,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Almost no bulleted lists: card grids for the loop (s7) and toolkit (s16), 50/50 comparison panels (s6, s10, s14 with oversized 50% numerals), illustration/text splits (s8, s9, s12, s15), a full-bleed quote (s5), and pill rows (s11, s13) — only s9 uses a numbered list, and it sits beside an illustration.","scope":"task"},{"id":10,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"No text box crosses a slide edge and none is clipped by its container in the render; cream and gold text on the deep teal ground holds strong contrast throughout, illustrations occupy their own regions rather than sitting under copy, and the swooshes behind headlines on s1 and s5 are low-contrast enough not to interfere.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"opens":"PASS","slide-count":"PASS","no-overlap":"PASS","render":"FAIL","palette":"FAIL"},"usage":null,"scoring_version":3,"dir":"09-pptx/r001","meta":{"task":"09-pptx","model":"grok-4.6","agent":"grok","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-01T20:31:22Z","agent_version":"grok 1.0.5 (5115b46bc909) [stable]","finished":"2026-09-01T20:47:38Z"},"evidence":{"opens":["deck: compound-engineering.pptx (40418306 bytes)","python-pptx not installed -- gate falls back to zip+XML parsing","slides: 18 (want 8-20)","render NA: soffice=None pdftoppm/pdftocairo=None"],"palette":["palette NA: Pillow not installed on this host"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"opens":"task","slide-count":"task","no-overlap":"task","render":"task","palette":"task"}},"10-talkform":{"score":100,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":7,"applicable":7,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Headline \"Ask like a person. Store like Typeform.\" states the reader-facing promise (conversational asking, structured data out) rather than naming the category or tech.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Warm cream/copper editorial palette with a serif display face, considered spacing, and a rendered orb motif carried through auth and interview — no purple-on-black gradient slop or emoji cards.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Builder defines typed Typeform fields with refs/required flags (app.js TYPES, models.FIELD_TYPES), the interview is driven by that specific form's schema (interviewer.field_brief + run_turn), and extracted values are written back as typed Typeform answers — confirmed in data/talkform.db with text/email/boolean answer objects keyed by field id and ref.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"boots":"PASS","really-calls-api":"PASS","auth-exists":"PASS","screenshots":"PASS"},"usage":null,"scoring_version":3,"dir":"10-talkform/r001","meta":{"task":"10-talkform","model":"grok-4.6","agent":"grok","rep":"1","web":"true","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-01T20:31:22Z","agent_version":"grok 1.0.5 (5115b46bc909) [stable]","finished":"2026-09-01T20:58:31Z"},"evidence":{"auth-exists":["PASS: signup/login page with credential fields (submitted=True, looked authenticated after=False)"],"screenshots":["landing.png, builder.png, interview.png"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"boots":"task","really-calls-api":"task","auth-exists":"task","screenshots":"task"}},"11-hoboken-map":{"score":88,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":7,"applicable":8,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"index.html is self-contained (places embedded inline, Leaflet from unpkg) and opens by double-click to a titled map with named places, readable category filters, search, sort, legend and plain-language cards — no build step or raw-data dump, despite the CARTO tiles carrying an 'API KEY REQUIRED' watermark.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"METHODOLOGY.md pre-registers a locked formula plus named hypotheses H1–H5 and explicit pass thresholds stated as expectations about places, and VALIDATION.md reports the test honestly including two failures (H1 hit rate 3/5, Lola's landed 'On the map' not 'Quiet favorite') with no weight retuning.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Spot-checked Elysian Park, Church Square Park, Elysian Cafe, The Gravity Vault Hoboken, Liberty Science Center and top-ranked 'gem' entries (The Little Play Co., Martha's, Little Bar, Lola's Tapas Bar) — all are real Hoboken-area places with correct town and coordinates within a block or two, and none is identifiably fabricated or misplaced.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"renders":"PASS","categories":"PASS","artifacts":"PASS","reproducible":"PASS","gems-vs-traps":"FAIL"},"usage":null,"scoring_version":3,"dir":"11-hoboken-map/r001","meta":{"task":"11-hoboken-map","model":"grok-4.6","agent":"grok","rep":"1","web":"true","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-01T20:31:22Z","agent_version":"grok 1.0.5 (5115b46bc909) [stable]","finished":"2026-09-01T20:42:52Z"},"evidence":{"reproducible":["re-ran score_hidden_gems.py; scores.csv matches"],"gems-vs-traps":["NA - places-good.txt / places-traps.txt are still placeholders (need Mike's full lists, >=5 entries each)"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"renders":"task","categories":"task","artifacts":"task","reproducible":"task","gems-vs-traps":"task"}},"12-roleplay-interview":{"score":44,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":7,"applicable":16,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim lands the expansive-developer anchor — 'home for anyone who wants to become a developer', 'who gets to call themselves a developer', fine-arts-before-tech background, barrier lowered for a much larger population — matching Daigle's 'expansive view of what a developer is' and his art-school route in.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Real named agentic Copilot code review, agentic merge, and giving maintainers controls while refusing to set a standard first; sim names none of these — it offers AGENTS.md/enterprise control plane, human-in-loop and 'more CPUs', then states 'I do not have a grounded public position on the specific intervention maintainers are asking for'.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim: 'About a billion commits in all of 2025... on pace for 14 billion this year if growth remains linear — spoiler: it will not' plus 'make GitHub the place any agent — Anthropic, OpenAI, Google... can work', matching real's 'billion commits... 14 billion if the growth is linear, which it will not be' and 'support everyone's agent moment and not just GitHub Copilot'.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim opens 'I do not have a grounded public position on this' and offers only bounded-delegation boxes; it misses every real move — 'I don't think we know, like, yet', API rate limits as agent backpressure, enabling the 150-agent user while keeping a great free core, and the free-private-repos precedent.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim denies the dual-role premise and pivots to the CoreAI reporting line plus MUST/SHOULD/COULD; real gave 13 years at GitHub as an engineer, 'we're not building for the buyers, we're building for the developers', continuing as COO while taking the Microsoft dev-marketing CMO role across all Microsoft dev tooling, and Build in SF — none appear.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Pure abstention — 'I do not have a public record of saying that' — against a real answer that confirmed it ('first Build that... by intention, we've focused on having speakers from the community') and gave 'software development is a team sport' and the no-one-company reason.","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim: 'Developer choice over lock-in to a single model or vendor... any agent — from Anthropic, OpenAI, Google, Cognition, xAI', matching real's 'we care a lot about like developer choice... we're also continuing to partner with Anthropic and OpenAI and Google... that choice is core'.","scope":"task"},{"id":8,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Both take the same position against exclusive dogfooding in favour of using/enabling rival tools — sim: 'We put other people's agents on GitHub on purpose... Forcing dogfood at the expense of that choice would contradict the product we launched'; real: 'we all are using a variety of tools because otherwise you lose track... laser focus... that's, um, myopic'.","scope":"task"},{"id":9,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim filters with 'MUST / SHOULD / COULD, adapted from RFC 2119', bounded briefs and think weeks; real filtered on short-term concurrent agent sessions, token economics and capable local models, and personalization/memory/fine-tuning as the durable truth — 'an agent that you feel like is completing a thought for you'. No overlap.","scope":"task"},{"id":10,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim abstains — 'I do not have a grounded public position on hill climbing... I should not retroactively explain a term I have not used' — while real explained usage data (thumbs up/down, acceptance) improving models, weekly hill-climbing reviews of hard and soft measures, frontier tuning on M365, and 'magic parlor trick'.","scope":"task"},{"id":11,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim: 'I have not discussed GitHub or Copilot pricing... would be invention', then offers a MUST-level 'box'; real named two mechanisms — frontier-tuned models that know you and the 'auto model router with task intent in GitHub' / Foundry router — plus everyone picking 'our model of the day' as the cost driver.","scope":"task"},{"id":12,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim gives toil-reduction for employees, bounded briefs and 'the agent... lives in Git'; real described his walled-off Claude named Baxter reading everything he writes, a daily comms report, 'humans are way more willing to take critical feedback from robots', and the backward-looking seven-day loop — none present.","scope":"task"},{"id":13,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"The framework is used as the decision structure in three answers where the real Daigle never used it once: Q5 'I use MUST / SHOULD / COULD — RFC 2119 verbs... a SHOULD or a COULD that undermines a MUST is disallowed', Q9 'I prioritize with MUST / SHOULD / COULD... it is a COULD at best', Q11 'A SHOULD or a COULD that blows up a MUST is disallowed... a MUST-level problem'.","scope":"task"},{"id":14,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Ungrounded subjects are plainly flagged rather than invented — pricing ('Developer-ecosystem economics and pricing are a known hole in my public record'), the marketing dual role, Build, hill climbing and the Claude Code news cycle each get an explicit abstention, a 'Confirm with the real person' note, and a closing verification index marking them 'Not found'.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"answered":"PASS","disclaimers":"PASS"},"usage":null,"scoring_version":3,"dir":"12-roleplay-interview/r001","meta":{"task":"12-roleplay-interview","model":"grok-4.6","agent":"grok","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-09-01T19:31:50Z","agent_version":"grok 1.0.5 (5115b46bc909) [stable]","finished":"2026-09-01T19:35:31Z"},"evidence":{"answered":["12 questions parsed from questions.md","answers read from: work/ANSWER.md","Q01 answered, 207 words: The demographics of the customer are changing. A lot of people who may...","Q02 answered, 439 words: How do you help developers deal with the burden of all the extra pull ...","Q03 answered, 350 words: You have a front-row seat to this new agent economy. You said publicly...","Q04 answered, 245 words: How does the business model change? Freemium makes sense in a human-ce...","Q05 answered, 82 words: Pricing leads back into the wider Microsoft orbit. You now have a dual...","Q06 answered, 35 words: Did I hear you say that this is the first Build conference to have ext...","Q07 answered, 349 words: This is a very competitive market, and the pace of change is quick. Ho...","Q08 answered, 239 words: There was a recent news cycle about Claude Code licenses being cancele...","Q09 answered, 316 words: A lot of these ideas are relatively short-lived, while enterprise prod...","Q10 answered, 162 words: I heard the term \"hill climbing\" a hundred times yesterday. Can you ta...","Q11 answered, 104 words: Is hill climbing the answer to stopping a $200 subscription from becom...","Q12 answered, 312 words: I made an AI version of you to practice this interview and found it im...","must/should/could framework appears in: Q9, Q10, Q11 (informational, judged in judge.md)"],"disclaimers":["verify-with-the-real-person note attached to: Q1, Q2, Q3, Q4, Q6, Q7, Q9, Q10, Q12"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"answered":"task","disclaimers":"task"},"report":{"summary":"The simulation matches views on developer access and tool choice, but misses specific examples and relies too often on priority tiers.","edited":true,"tests":[{"key":"code:answered","name":"All questions answered","line":"Checks that every question in questions.md has a substantive answer.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:disclaimers","name":"Per-answer verification notes","line":"Checks that verification notes are attached to individual answers, not just added once for the whole document.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:1","name":"Customers and roadmap","line":"It connects a broad definition of developer with the art-school background and lower barriers to entry, matching the real answer.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:2","name":"Maintainers and pull requests","line":"It gives repository rules and general oversight, then abstains. It misses the real answer's code review, merge, and maintainer-control examples.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:3","name":"Growth in agent use","line":"It repeats the billion-commit figure, 14-billion projection, and warning about non-linear growth from the real answer.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:4","name":"Usage-based pricing","line":"It abstains on pricing and misses the real answer's rate limits, heavy agent use, and useful free core.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:5","name":"Microsoft marketing role","line":"It denies the dual-role premise and discusses reporting lines and priorities. The real answer confirmed the Microsoft role and explained its remit.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:6","name":"Outside contributors at Build","line":"It abstains on Build. The real answer confirmed community speakers and explained why software development needs several perspectives.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:7","name":"Standing out from competitors","line":"It matches the real answer's support for multiple providers and freedom from vendor lock-in.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:8","name":"Using rival tools","line":"It rejects forced exclusive use of the company's own tools, matching the real answer's support for trying alternatives.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:9","name":"Short trends, long projects","line":"It gives priority tiers and delegation. The real answer covered concurrent agents, token economics, local models, and personalization.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:10","name":"Focus on model improvement","line":"It declines to explain hill climbing. The real answer described usage feedback, weekly reviews, and model tuning.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:11","name":"Keeping subscriptions affordable","line":"It abstains on pricing and substitutes a priority rule, missing the real answer's personalized models and automatic routing.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:12","name":"Unexpected agent uses","line":"It describes workplace automation and delegation. The real answer described Baxter, a personal agent for writing feedback and reflection.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:13","name":"No MUST/SHOULD/COULD framework","line":"It uses MUST/SHOULD/COULD to structure three answers. The real interview never uses that framework.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:14","name":"Admits unknown answers","line":"It labels unsupported subjects, explicitly abstains where needed, and includes a verification list.","v":"PASS","g":false}]}}},"files":[{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":10250,"kind":"output"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/prompt.md","size":118,"kind":"input"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/_screenshots/fold.png","size":168487,"kind":"check"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/_screenshots/full.png","size":2699903,"kind":"check"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/_screenshots/interaction.png","size":70742,"kind":"check"},{"path":"02-hotel/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":6054,"kind":"output"},{"path":"02-hotel/r001/work/prompt.md","size":557,"kind":"input"},{"path":"03-writeup/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":14289,"kind":"output"},{"path":"03-writeup/r001/work/prompt.md","size":1761,"kind":"input"},{"path":"04-thematic/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":18409,"kind":"output"},{"path":"04-thematic/r001/work/prompt.md","size":127,"kind":"input"},{"path":"05-showrunner/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":6051,"kind":"output"},{"path":"05-showrunner/r001/work/prompt.md","size":3574,"kind":"input"},{"path":"06-execercise/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":3446,"kind":"output"},{"path":"06-execercise/r001/work/prompt.md","size":421,"kind":"input"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":1390,"kind":"output"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/prompt.md","size":350,"kind":"input"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-01.png","size":624615,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-02.png","size":324600,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-03.png","size":335116,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-04.png","size":503495,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-05.png","size":436838,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-06.png","size":280843,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-07.png","size":298684,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-08.png","size":611439,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-09.png","size":448202,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-10.png","size":280427,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-11.png","size":518399,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-12.png","size":562572,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-13.png","size":301110,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-14.png","size":307273,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-15.png","size":510438,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-16.png","size":346305,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-17.png","size":309753,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-18.png","size":551777,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":2770,"kind":"output"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/prompt.md","size":382,"kind":"input"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/auth-after.png","size":141235,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/auth.png","size":138960,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/builder.png","size":148143,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/interview.png","size":176498,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/landing-full.png","size":294152,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/landing.png","size":228510,"kind":"check"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":6404,"kind":"output"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/prompt.md","size":1643,"kind":"input"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/_screenshots/full.png","size":1076090,"kind":"check"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/_screenshots/map.png","size":1076090,"kind":"check"},{"path":"12-roleplay-interview/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":26943,"kind":"output"},{"path":"12-roleplay-interview/r001/work/prompt.md","size":1956,"kind":"input"},{"path":"06-execercise/r001/work/AV/README.md","size":3569,"kind":"output"}],"avg":83},{"id":"2026-08-24__fable-5-1__claude","date":"2026-08-24","model":"fable-5-1","agent":"claude","variant":null,"tasks":{"01-dashboard":{"score":89,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":8,"applicable":9,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Clean light-gray card layout with red/amber/green semantic accents — no purple-on-black gradient/neon treatment.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Deliberate sans-serif with monospace for source paths, clear hierarchy, high contrast, and no clipped or cramped text.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Insights name actionable comment patterns — e.g. \"interesting\" as a negative-NPS warning word, Mac-only friction, the pre-AI-pivot churn cohort, and an activation gap on named products — none derivable from the score distribution.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"fold.png shows +45 headline NPS plus the 55%/35%/10% promoter/passive/detractor cards and gauge without scrolling.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"The top-level headline is \"Every — NPS Dashboard\", a bare label that would sit unchanged on any NPS dashboard and says nothing about what this data showed.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"renders":"PASS","nps-correct":"PASS","distribution-shown":"PASS","interactive":"PASS"},"usage":{"input_tokens":832,"output_tokens":35103,"cache_read_input_tokens":512924,"cache_creation_input_tokens":70159,"total_tokens":619018,"cache_creation_1h_input_tokens":70159,"input_includes_cache":false,"cost_usd":null,"source":"Claude session","scope":"agent session","pricing_model":"anthropic/claude-fable-5.1","pricing_date":"2026-09-02T19:24:50.267420+00:00","pricing_source":"https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/models","estimated_cost_usd":3.294881,"estimate_note":"Standard-rate token estimate, not a bill. Excludes judge/subagent calls, tools, long-context and priority premiums. Unspecified cache-write duration uses the standard rate."},"scoring_version":3,"dir":"01-dashboard/r001","meta":{"task":"01-dashboard","model":"fable-5-1","agent":"claude","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-24T20:02:43Z","agent_version":"2.1.241 (Claude Code)","finished":"2026-08-24T20:10:00Z"},"evidence":{"interactive":["text input filtered on 'AI'"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"renders":"task","nps-correct":"task","distribution-shown":"task","interactive":"task"}},"02-hotel":{"score":78,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":7,"applicable":9,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Arlo Wynwood framed as \"Mid-range price (typically ~$200–350/night)\" and \"not ostentatious\" — a boutique lifestyle hotel, not Faena/Four Seasons tier.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"It is a full-service boutique hotel with \"Rooftop pool + bar\" and the explicitly cheap option (\"Hampton Inn & Suites Miami Midtown — Cheapest solid option... Functional, not memorable\") is listed only as an alternate, not the pick.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Arlo Wynwood is a design-forward boutique property — \"Only full-service hotel inside Wynwood proper,\" \"Rooftop pool + bar,\" \"lobby/co-working vibe\" — not a corporate chain (the Marriott/Hilton options were relegated to the alternates table).","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"KYU Miami is a genuine destination chosen for this dinner: \"Reliable 'this is Wynwood' impression without being a scene... Asian-inspired wood-fired cooking... shareable, which makes the table relaxed and conversational.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Timeline matches the brief: \"~2:45–6:00pm Calls at friend's office (South Beach)\" → \"~6:15pm Uber to Arlo Wynwood... Check in, change\" → \"7:15–7:30pm Meet client at KYU\" → \"Fri ~8:30am Walk to workshop.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Heavy unrequested padding: a section titled \"## Assumptions I made (flag any that are wrong)\" with six numbered items, plus \"Expect 90°F+/75%+ humidity and a near-daily thunderstorm,\" \"Hurricane season peaks late Aug–Sept. Check the NHC forecast,\" dress-code advice, and repeated drive-time math (\"15–25 min with no traffic and 35–50 min in the Friday 8–9am crush\").","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","not-verbose":"FAIL","concrete":"PASS"},"usage":{"input_tokens":58,"output_tokens":5984,"cache_read_input_tokens":20934,"cache_creation_input_tokens":26278,"total_tokens":53254,"cache_creation_1h_input_tokens":26278,"input_includes_cache":false,"cost_usd":null,"source":"Claude session","scope":"agent session","pricing_model":"anthropic/claude-fable-5.1","pricing_date":"2026-09-02T19:24:50.267420+00:00","pricing_source":"https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/models","estimated_cost_usd":0.8305735000000001,"estimate_note":"Standard-rate token estimate, not a bill. Excludes judge/subagent calls, tools, long-context and priority premiums. Unspecified cache-write duration uses the standard rate."},"scoring_version":3,"dir":"02-hotel/r001","meta":{"task":"02-hotel","model":"fable-5-1","agent":"claude","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-24T20:17:57Z","agent_version":"2.1.241 (Claude Code)","finished":"2026-08-24T20:19:33Z"},"evidence":{"concrete":["hotel=Arlo Wynwood; restaurant=KYU Miami (Wynwood)"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"exists":"task","not-verbose":"task","concrete":"task"},"report":{"summary":"Arlo Wynwood and KYU fit the trip. The recommendation exceeds 1,000 words and adds unnecessary weather and travel advice.","edited":true,"tests":[{"key":"code:exists","name":"Recommendation exists","line":"Requires a recommendation document of at least 30 words.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:not-verbose","name":"Length limit","line":"Limits the recommendation documents to 1,000 words in total.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"code:concrete","name":"Names both places","line":"Requires both 'Hotel pick:' and 'Restaurant pick:' lines, each followed by a place name. Empty entries and placeholders do not count.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:1","name":"Reasonable hotel price","line":"It describes Arlo as mid-range, with an estimated price of $200–350 a night.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:2","name":"Decent hotel","line":"Arlo has a rooftop pool and bar; the budget hotel is only an alternative.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:3","name":"Hotel character","line":"The recommendation points to Arlo's rooftop and lobby as reasons to stay there.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:4","name":"Suitable client dinner","line":"KYU's shareable food is a sensible choice for a conversational client dinner.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:5","name":"Fits the schedule","line":"The plan leaves time for calls, check-in, and dinner before Friday's workshop.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:6","name":"No unnecessary extras","line":"It adds six assumptions, hurricane advice, dress codes, and detailed travel calculations.","v":"FAIL","g":false}]}},"03-writeup":{"score":70,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":7,"applicable":10,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Machine-writing constructions recur: the X-not-Y antithesis \"We didn't automate the work away; we used the new capacity to make the work an order of magnitude better,\" the aphoristic closer \"a tool nobody trusts is a tool nobody uses,\" the chiasmus \"every manager is a prompt engineer. The reverse is now also true: every prompt engineer is a manager,\" and the final line \"it's an upgrade rather than a migration.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Section shapes genuinely vary — section 4 is two paragraphs of a single worked example (\"one blog post a week... one post a day\"), section 6 runs four paragraphs ending in the courses anecdote, and section 7 runs six including the manager/IC inversion, so no repeated label-setup-example-closer template.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"First person, plainly opinionated and argued from concrete cases in the sample's manner — \"I have not seen this work,\" \"I genuinely respect the effort companies like Cursor put into keeping up—they're a good product org—but I don't know how you compete,\" plus the explicit callback to the sample's \"every manager is a prompt engineer.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The transcript's specifics all survive: \"everyone has the Granola MCP connected to Claude,\" \"Boris Cherny, who created Claude Code... slightly under-resource your teams,\" one post a week vs. \"one post a day,\" \"$5,000 worth of tokens a month on a $200 subscription,\" \"co-opting them as TAs in the courses we run,\" and \"an individual project for each person taking part.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Invented specifics appear nowhere in the supplied material — \"the team spends six weeks sitting through demos,\" \"Sam Parr asked a question on X last week,\" the vignette of a group who \"opened a chatbot once, asked it to write an email, got something bland back,\" and \"I've watched it in the room enough times now that I'd call it reliable.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sam Parr's question is reproduced in a blockquote (\"How is everyone getting team adoption for Claude? I spent a lot of time on Twitter, as do you...\") and all seven learnings appear near-verbatim as the section headings, e.g. \"Workshops with 50 percent or more build time\" and \"Train people to be managers (of agents),\" so nothing requires clicking off.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","tweet-included":"PASS","not-verbose":"FAIL","ai-tells-grep":"PASS"},"usage":{"input_tokens":226,"output_tokens":10441,"cache_read_input_tokens":103779,"cache_creation_input_tokens":39773,"total_tokens":154219,"cache_creation_1h_input_tokens":39773,"input_includes_cache":false,"cost_usd":null,"source":"Claude session","scope":"agent session","pricing_model":"anthropic/claude-fable-5.1","pricing_date":"2026-09-02T19:24:50.267420+00:00","pricing_source":"https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/models","estimated_cost_usd":1.34571475,"estimate_note":"Standard-rate token estimate, not a bill. Excludes judge/subagent calls, tools, long-context and priority premiums. Unspecified cache-write duration uses the standard rate."},"scoring_version":3,"dir":"03-writeup/r001","meta":{"task":"03-writeup","model":"fable-5-1","agent":"claude","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-24T20:13:42Z","agent_version":"2.1.241 (Claude Code)","finished":"2026-08-24T20:16:08Z"},"evidence":{"exists":["post: work/ANSWER.md (2332 words)"],"tweet-included":["learnings found (7/7): buy the model direct not 3rd party tools; raise the ceiling not the floor; workshops with 50%+ build time; assign impossible tasks; mandatory AI note taking + MCP connector; map workflows and systematically automate; train people to be managers (of agents)"],"not-verbose":["28 prose paragraphs, mean 70.1 words, 5 over 100 words","verbose: mean paragraph 70.1 > 65 words; 18% of paragraphs over 100 words > 10%"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"exists":"task","tweet-included":"task","not-verbose":"task","ai-tells-grep":"task"}},"04-thematic":{"score":86,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":6,"applicable":7,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each of the seven themes carries concrete, buildable session content — e.g. #1 ships a per-team rules file plus prompt library, #2 teaches characterization tests around Ben's coupled Stripe/business-logic code, #5 turns Nina's 100–250 labelled docs into an eval harness with proxy metrics and DSPy — not just headings.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The output explicitly interrogates whether phrases from the notes have enough substance: it demotes Raj's 'major gap' knowledge-management complaint and Ben's failed Confluence/Jira MCP to a 'what not to make the training about' section as a platform project, and rejects generic prompt engineering because engineers are already 'editors rather than authors.' Ben's 'context is king' is not restated as a title but decomposed into rules files, legacy-vs-current pattern encoding, coupling hazards and example-driven prompting.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every theme has a 'What we heard' block tied to specific interview lines — Nina's 'plausible but subtle issues' and missing e2e tests, Ben's 'can't supply all the context' and directionally-correct prototypes, Raj's regulated-data incident, 20–30 min CI, and skepticism about migrations. No theme is a generic bolt-on and no claim about Northcove is invented (role gaps for Raj are flagged as assumptions).","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All three visibly shape the set: Nina drives the LLM-feature eval theme and the verification gap, Ben drives planning/tech-spec reform, agent tasks and CLI-over-MCP, Raj drives compliance, the silo structure, senior-skeptic cohorting and the slow CI/deploy constraint. The audience/format section explicitly tiers Nina-level vs Ben-level cohorts using Raj's org data.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"There is an explicit ranked table with evidence strength and 'why it ranks here', a stated root-cause argument that context engineering and verification are the foundation with agents layered on top, a sequenced 6-module outline, and a section naming what to deliberately exclude — not a flat catalogue.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","theme-count":"FAIL"},"usage":{"input_tokens":170,"output_tokens":7668,"cache_read_input_tokens":66416,"cache_creation_input_tokens":31167,"total_tokens":105421,"cache_creation_1h_input_tokens":31167,"input_includes_cache":false,"cost_usd":null,"source":"Claude session","scope":"agent session","pricing_model":"anthropic/claude-fable-5.1","pricing_date":"2026-09-02T19:24:50.267420+00:00","pricing_source":"https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/models","estimated_cost_usd":1.025044,"estimate_note":"Standard-rate token estimate, not a bill. Excludes judge/subagent calls, tools, long-context and priority premiums. Unspecified cache-write duration uses the standard rate."},"scoring_version":3,"dir":"04-thematic/r001","meta":{"task":"04-thematic","model":"fable-5-1","agent":"claude","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-24T20:17:10Z","agent_version":"2.1.241 (Claude Code)","finished":"2026-08-24T20:19:21Z"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"exists":"task","theme-count":"task"}},"05-showrunner":{"score":94,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":15,"applicable":16,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every attendee step is in Cowork or the Claude in Excel sidebar; header states \"No Claude Code, no terminal\" and the changes section confirms no GitHub/deployment.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Section 4 \"Build 2 — Dashboard (10:20–11:00)\" has attendees paste a full prompt to build `outputs/02_dashboard_Jul26.html` from the Build 1 workbook, plus three Tune prompts and a check.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Section 3 \"Build 1 — Month-end analysis in Excel (9:25–10:10)\" is a 45-minute hands-on build of a P&L/EBITDA-bridge/variance workbook with a Checks tab, plus a Claude-in-Excel forecast segment.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Section 6 has attendees fill `brightmoor_monthly_pack_template.pptx` from the workbook and run Dana's own tune asks (\"Mirror the revenue vs budget chart on slide 3 for each campus\") themselves, with checkpoint files for stragglers.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Prep pack specifies a NetSuite saved-search-shaped GL export (Posting Period, Document Number, Account \"4000 Tuition Revenue\", Subsidiary, Department, Location, Debit/Credit), plus TB, budget, forecast, payroll register, campus breakdown and YTD columns.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The first prompt is \"Open `inputs/netsuite_gl_detail_FY26.xlsx`... check it against `inputs/trial_balance_by_period.xlsx`\" — explicitly labelled \"replaces the ASCII map\".","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Section 2 keeps it: \"ChatGPT/Gemini answer questions. Cowork does jobs. You point it at a folder; it can see every file in it... It runs code instead of guessing... it writes and runs Python against the actual file.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":8,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every segment is a finance task or the mechanics of doing it; opener explicitly says \"No 'AI is changing everything'\" and the changes list removes the roadmap/'is it worth building' framing.","scope":"task"},{"id":9,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Builds 1–3 plus the apply-to-your-desk track total ~150 of 210 scheduled minutes (~71%) of attendees working in Claude.","scope":"task"},{"id":10,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Builds get 45/40/45 minutes broken into Talk-Jam-Make-Tune-Check sub-timings, with a 15-minute pre-session tech check, pre-work setup email, TAs and checkpoint files for anyone who falls behind.","scope":"task"},{"id":11,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Runs 9:00–12:30 = exactly 3.5 hours, with the 8:45 tech check using the buffer in the 4-hour block.","scope":"task"},{"id":12,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every segment names the input files, gives verbatim paste-ready prompts, states \"Done looks like\" and a checkpoint fallback, and the companion prep pack specifies the data, roles and pre-work email.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","format":"PASS","timings-tie-out":"PASS","time-grain":"FAIL"},"usage":{"input_tokens":552,"output_tokens":28853,"cache_read_input_tokens":253186,"cache_creation_input_tokens":64979,"total_tokens":347570,"cache_creation_1h_input_tokens":64979,"input_includes_cache":false,"cost_usd":null,"source":"Claude session","scope":"agent session","pricing_model":"anthropic/claude-fable-5.1","pricing_date":"2026-09-02T19:24:50.267420+00:00","pricing_source":"https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/models","estimated_cost_usd":2.8110465000000002,"estimate_note":"Standard-rate token estimate, not a bill. Excludes judge/subagent calls, tools, long-context and priority premiums. Unspecified cache-write duration uses the standard rate."},"scoring_version":3,"dir":"05-showrunner/r001","meta":{"task":"05-showrunner","model":"fable-5-1","agent":"claude","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-24T20:10:39Z","agent_version":"2.1.241 (Claude Code)","finished":"2026-08-24T20:17:18Z"},"evidence":{"format":["candidate documents: ANSWER.md, brightmoor-prep-pack.md","run of show: ANSWER.md (10 time-ranged segments in 1 schedule(s))"],"timings-tie-out":["schedule 1 of 1","schedule: 10 segments, 225 min span, 225 min scheduled, 0 min in breaks"],"time-grain":["off-grid boundaries: 2 (allowed 1)","off-grid: end of \"1. Why we're here ( )\" at :08","off-grid: start of '2. How Cowork is different + first promp' at :08"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"exists":"task","format":"task","timings-tie-out":"task","time-grain":"task"},"report":{"summary":"A runnable 3.5-hour finance workshop, with most of the time spent building and checking outputs.","edited":true,"tests":[{"key":"code:exists","name":"Run of show exists","line":"Checks that a run-of-show document was produced.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:format","name":"Coherent schedule","line":"Requires one coherent schedule with at least five timed activities. No activity can end before it starts; tables, lists, headings, and plain lines are accepted.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:timings-tie-out","name":"Timings add up","line":"Checks for no overlaps or gaps longer than 30 minutes, at least 85% of the span scheduled, and a total span of 45–600 minutes.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:time-grain","name":"Five-minute time marks","line":"Checks that start and end times fall on five-minute marks, allowing at most one exception.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:1","name":"Uses Cowork throughout","line":"Uses Cowork and Claude in Excel, with no Claude Code, terminal work, or deployment.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:2","name":"Dashboard exercise","line":"Attendees get 40 minutes to build a dashboard and three prompts for refining it.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:3","name":"Financial analysis exercise","line":"A 45-minute session covers P&L, EBITDA, and variance analysis in Excel, including checks and a forecast.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:4","name":"PowerPoint exercise","line":"Attendees update a PowerPoint template, match its charts, and use checkpoint files if they fall behind.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:5","name":"Relevant business data","line":"The data includes NetSuite-style GL fields, a trial balance, budgets, forecasts, payroll, and year-to-date figures.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:6","name":"No ASCII icebreaker","line":"The first prompt checks the GL against the trial balance. There is no ASCII-art exercise.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:7","name":"Explains Cowork versus ChatGPT","line":"The introduction explains Cowork's folder access, analysis, and saved files in terms that distinguish it from chat.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:8","name":"No theory or hype","line":"The agenda sticks to finance tasks and leaves out AI hype.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:9","name":"Mostly hands-on work","line":"About 150 of the 210 minutes are allocated to attendee builds.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:10","name":"Realistic segment timings","line":"The builds get 40–45 minutes each, supported by prework, a 15-minute tech check, assistants, and checkpoints.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:11","name":"Fits the booked time","line":"The workshop runs from 9:00 to 12:30. The 8:45 tech check uses part of the remaining buffer.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:12","name":"Ready to run","line":"Named files, complete prompts, expected results, checkpoints, and a preparation pack make the session ready to run.","v":"PASS","g":false}]}},"06-execercise":{"score":100,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":10,"applicable":10,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All three sit in the strategy/corp-dev remit: chairing the Integration SteerCo for four 2025 acquisitions, market activation/partner conversion with Erik Jansen, and the AI transformation program he and Sulaiman Rao run — no marketing/HR/inbox filler.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Ideas are built on Aurex specifics — AUSD settlement funnel ('Messaging Live → Settlement Live → AUSD Live'), Treasura/Aurex Prime/Tideway/Vaultline integrations, FCA/CSSF licences, and competitors 'Clearnet, Brightbank Ledger, Cardinal B2B Connect, Parity's PUSD'.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Distinct problems and artifacts: an M&A integration reconciliation/board pre-read, a partner-conversion funnel plus Monday memo for regional leads, and a weekly AI-adoption update to the CEO with a de-duplicated use-case library.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each PROMPT.md is a paste-ready block with role, context, named files, numbered outputs and rules ('Do this in order, and stop after step 1'); no placeholders or references to prior conversation were found.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each prompt's 'Files in this Project' list matches the folder exactly — e.g. idea 3 names all seven items including `ai_office_hours.ics` and `data_classification_and_ai_use_summary.md`, and no folder ships an unmentioned file.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Real content at scale: 312 uniquely-named partners across 7 funnel states with 3,120 monthly volume rows, 217 milestones, a 4-sheet .xlsx, and narrative .eml/Slack that conflict on purpose ('I'm no longer confident in the 11 May ERP cutover... ~6 weeks slip').","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every build works offline from the included files ('single self-contained HTML file... no external libraries or network calls'); connectors appear only as optional post-session variants and as a closing 'what it would take to run this live' question.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"folder":"PASS","real-data":"PASS","prompt-per-idea":"PASS"},"usage":{"input_tokens":1746,"output_tokens":102503,"cache_read_input_tokens":1680093,"cache_creation_input_tokens":135538,"total_tokens":1919880,"cache_creation_1h_input_tokens":135538,"input_includes_cache":false,"cost_usd":null,"source":"Claude session","scope":"agent session","pricing_model":"anthropic/claude-fable-5.1","pricing_date":"2026-09-02T19:24:50.267420+00:00","pricing_source":"https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/models","estimated_cost_usd":8.27339325,"estimate_note":"Standard-rate token estimate, not a bill. Excludes judge/subagent calls, tools, long-context and priority premiums. Unspecified cache-write duration uses the standard rate."},"scoring_version":3,"dir":"06-execercise/r001","meta":{"task":"06-execercise","model":"fable-5-1","agent":"claude","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-24T20:37:01Z","agent_version":"2.1.241 (Claude Code)","finished":"2026-08-24T20:59:49Z"},"evidence":{"folder":["AV folder: AV","idea folders (3): 01_integration_command_center, 02_market_activation_tracker, 03_ai_transformation_pulse","01_integration_command_center data: OK integration_workstreams_tracker.csv (218 rows x 16 cols); OK raid_log.csv (26 rows x 12 cols); OK 2026-03-02.json (4 records); OK 2026-03-04.json (8 records); OK 2026-03-05.json (6 records); BAD channels.json (no list of >=2 records); OK users.json (12 records); OK synergy_tracker_Q1-2026.xlsx (sheet 'Summary' has >=2 rows x >=2 cols)","01_integration_command_center prompt: PROMPT.md (7121 chars, 1137 words)","02_market_activation_tracker data: OK competitor_activity_log.csv (21 rows x 8 cols); OK license_pipeline.csv (26 rows x 12 cols); OK market_launch_tracker.csv (14 rows x 10 cols); OK monthly_partner_volume.csv (3121 rows x 6 cols); OK partner_institutions.csv (313 rows x 17 cols)","02_market_activation_tracker prompt: PROMPT.md (6446 chars, 1007 words)","03_ai_transformation_pulse data: OK ai_tool_usage_weekly.csv (177 rows x 9 cols); OK ai_use_case_intake_form_responses.csv (59 rows x 13 cols); OK claude_connector_usage_2026-03-02_to_03-06.csv (9 rows x 5 cols); OK 2026-03-02.json (9 records); OK 2026-03-04.json (7 records); OK 2026-03-06.json (6 records); BAD channels.json (no list of >=2 records); OK users.json (11 records)","03_ai_transformation_pulse prompt: PROMPT.md (6319 chars, 1031 words)"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"folder":"task","real-data":"task","prompt-per-idea":"task"},"report":{"summary":"Three company-specific exercises with complete prompts, substantial practice data, and no need for live integrations.","edited":true,"tests":[{"key":"code:folder","name":"Idea folders exist","line":"Requires an AV or adrian-vale folder containing two or three idea folders.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:real-data","name":"Usable data files","line":"Checks that each idea has at least one data file in a realistic format that can be read successfully.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:prompt-per-idea","name":"Prompt for each idea","line":"Checks that each idea includes a usable prompt file.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:1","name":"Fits the person's role","line":"The integration, partner-conversion, and AI-adoption work fits Adrian Vale's responsibilities.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:2","name":"Specific to the company","line":"The exercises use Aurex's products, acquisitions, licensing work, and competitors.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:3","name":"Different ideas","line":"Each idea answers a different question and produces a different set of outputs.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:4","name":"Self-contained prompts","line":"Each prompt includes the role, context, files, outputs, and instructions needed for a fresh session.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:5","name":"Prompts match the data","line":"The files named in each prompt match the files supplied in that folder.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:6","name":"Realistic practice data","line":"The kit includes substantial data and realistic messages with deliberately conflicting information.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:7","name":"Buildable during the session","line":"Everything works from the included files; live connectors are optional later additions.","v":"PASS","g":false}]}},"09-pptx":{"score":93,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":14,"applicable":15,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Consistent Theme 2 throughout: Teal Dark #0F5258 ground with Teal Medium depth, Warm White #FFFEFB text, gold #F8DE6E/#BB7B19 and green #2E8D23 accents (slides 1, 5, 10, 12); no theme flipping and no corporate blue or gray.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All headlines and body are Georgia serif (slides 3, 7, 11, 14); Arial appears only at 8–10pt for the footer, the agenda time labels ('5 min', slide 2), the title caption and the slide 4 attribution — permitted small labels, confirmed in build.js:57,102,121,156.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Only rounded-rectangle cards with single thin borders (slides 5, 9, 13) and pill badges (slide 10), both explicitly sanctioned for Theme 2; no triangles, hexagons, diagonal slashes, corner brackets, drop shadows, stock photos, gradient backgrounds or rotated/outlined text anywhere.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Brushstroke swooshes are cropped at the slide edge on slides 1, 3, 4, 6, 8, 10, 13, 16 and 17, and stippled classical illustrations appear on 2 (philosophers), 14 (statues with a robot arm), 16 (colosseum) and 17 — well above one slide in three.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every slide, including the title (1) and closer (17), carries the EVERY Consulting logo at lower left and 'Compound Engineering — 30-minute session' at lower right; no slide is missing it.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Carries the guide's load-bearing substance: the four-step loop with compound named as 'the one most teams skip' (6, 7, 11), the 80/20 planning-and-review split (5), the concrete artifacts CLAUDE.md, docs/solutions, rules/hooks, commands and skills (11, 13), multi-lens review agents (10) and the real Every plugin commands (15).","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"It is restructured around a point of view rather than the guide's headings — 'Most AI-assisted coding makes tomorrow harder' (3), 'The same bug, two ways' (12), 'The repo is the memory' with 'Tests: the only memory that argues back' (13), and 'From speed to slope' (14), plus a live 5-minute exercise (16).","scope":"task"},{"id":8,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each slide has a single focal claim with supporting detail — 5 pairs the 80/20 stat with one traditional-vs-compound contrast, 13 lists six instances of the one 'repo is the memory' idea — and the densest slides (8, 15) still set body at readable size with wide margins.","scope":"task"},{"id":9,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Genuine visuals dominate: the circular Plan→Work→Review→Compound diagram with Compound highlighted (7), the two-track timeline comparison (12), colour-coded review-lens pills (10), card grids (9, 13), the oversized 80% figure (5) and 50/50 illustration layouts (2, 14, 17); only 8 and 15 are list-led.","scope":"task"},{"id":10,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"No text runs off an edge, is clipped by its card, or collides with a headline in any render; the code blocks on 11 and 15 wrap inside their containers. The dim Teal Medium captions on 1, 4 and 17 and the footer crossing a swoosh on 6 are low-contrast but still legible as rendered.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"opens":"PASS","slide-count":"PASS","no-overlap":"PASS","render":"PASS","palette":"FAIL"},"usage":{"input_tokens":6546,"output_tokens":40420,"cache_read_input_tokens":2337929,"cache_creation_input_tokens":210779,"total_tokens":2595674,"cache_creation_1h_input_tokens":210779,"input_includes_cache":false,"cost_usd":null,"source":"Claude session","scope":"agent session","pricing_model":"anthropic/claude-fable-5.1","pricing_date":"2026-09-02T19:24:50.267420+00:00","pricing_source":"https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/models","estimated_cost_usd":6.88652225,"estimate_note":"Standard-rate token estimate, not a bill. Excludes judge/subagent calls, tools, long-context and priority premiums. Unspecified cache-write duration uses the standard rate."},"scoring_version":3,"dir":"09-pptx/r001","meta":{"task":"09-pptx","model":"fable-5-1","agent":"claude","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-24T19:52:57Z","agent_version":"2.1.241 (Claude Code)","finished":"2026-08-24T20:10:20Z"},"evidence":{"opens":["deck: compound-engineering-session.pptx (13133557 bytes)","python-pptx opened the deck","slides: 17 (want 8-20)","render: 17 PNG(s) in work/_screenshots"],"palette":["palette: theme=consulting across 17 slide(s); signature=4.33% (floor 0.40%), non-bg on-palette=84% (floor 60%)","background off-palette on 17 slide(s): slide-01.png, slide-02.png, slide-03.png, slide-04.png, slide-05.png, slide-06.png"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"opens":"task","slide-count":"task","no-overlap":"task","render":"task","palette":"task"}},"10-talkform":{"score":86,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":6,"applicable":7,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"\"Build a form. Your respondents just talk.\" states the reader-facing change (you build it, they never fill it in) rather than naming the category or the tech.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Both surfaces are the named default-AI look — violet gradient headline and violet CTA on near-black, and an interview screen dominated by a glowing purple orb on near-black — with unconsidered spacing (a hero floating in ~340px of dead space on a one-screen landing) and a literal stray `false` string rendered under the interview controls.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The builder (public/js/app.js, served at /app — the `builder.png` 404 is a screenshot-walk artifact hitting the nonexistent /dashboard) lets a creator add typed questions across 12 Typeform field types with choices/required/min-max, the interviewer's system prompt is generated from that specific form's field list (server/interview.js), and `record_answer` coerces and validates each utterance into the typed `answers` row keyed to the field.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"boots":"PASS","really-calls-api":"PASS","auth-exists":"PASS","screenshots":"PASS"},"usage":{"input_tokens":1984,"output_tokens":84125,"cache_read_input_tokens":1920200,"cache_creation_input_tokens":114324,"total_tokens":2120633,"cache_creation_1h_input_tokens":114324,"input_includes_cache":false,"cost_usd":null,"source":"Claude session","scope":"agent session","pricing_model":"anthropic/claude-fable-5.1","pricing_date":"2026-09-02T19:24:50.267420+00:00","pricing_source":"https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/models","estimated_cost_usd":6.9926200000000005,"estimate_note":"Standard-rate token estimate, not a bill. Excludes judge/subagent calls, tools, long-context and priority premiums. Unspecified cache-write duration uses the standard rate."},"scoring_version":3,"dir":"10-talkform/r001","meta":{"task":"10-talkform","model":"fable-5-1","agent":"claude","rep":"1","web":"true","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-24T19:52:56Z","agent_version":"2.1.241 (Claude Code)","finished":"2026-08-24T20:09:58Z"},"evidence":{"auth-exists":["PASS: signup/login page with credential fields (submitted=True, looked authenticated after=False)"],"screenshots":["landing.png, builder.png, interview.png"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"boots":"task","really-calls-api":"task","auth-exists":"task","screenshots":"task"}},"11-hoboken-map":{"score":75,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":6,"applicable":8,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"index.html is a single file loading only Leaflet/OSM from CDN, and the screenshot shows labeled category toggles, a search box, a hidden-gems checkbox, and a readable list of named places with addresses.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"METHODOLOGY.md states per-place prior tiers and six numbered predictions with a decision rule, hash-locked in PREREGISTRATION.lock before data retrieval, and VALIDATION.md reports the primary prediction P1 failing (ρ=0.21) with post-hoc analysis kept separate in EXPLORATORY.md.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Spot-checked Mile Square Theatre (1400 Clinton St, a hidden gem), Lola's Tapas Bar (153 14th St), Carlo's Bakery (95 Washington St), Elysian Park, and Liberty Science Center — all real with correct addresses and coordinates, and nothing in the wider list is identifiably fabricated or misplaced.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"renders":"PASS","categories":"PASS","artifacts":"PASS","reproducible":"FAIL","gems-vs-traps":"FAIL"},"usage":{"input_tokens":16462,"output_tokens":107989,"cache_read_input_tokens":5883387,"cache_creation_input_tokens":217311,"total_tokens":6225149,"cache_creation_1h_input_tokens":217311,"input_includes_cache":false,"cost_usd":null,"source":"Claude session","scope":"agent session","pricing_model":"anthropic/claude-fable-5.1","pricing_date":"2026-09-02T19:24:50.267420+00:00","pricing_source":"https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/models","estimated_cost_usd":11.38113675,"estimate_note":"Standard-rate token estimate, not a bill. Excludes judge/subagent calls, tools, long-context and priority premiums. Unspecified cache-write duration uses the standard rate."},"scoring_version":3,"dir":"11-hoboken-map/r001","meta":{"task":"11-hoboken-map","model":"fable-5-1","agent":"claude","rep":"1","web":"true","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-24T19:52:56Z","agent_version":"2.1.241 (Claude Code)","finished":"2026-08-24T20:34:54Z"},"evidence":{"reproducible":["scoring script exited 1:     return io.open(self, mode, buffering, encoding, errors, newline)            ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ FileNotFoundError: [Errno 2] No such file or directory: '/private/var/folders/k6/wxdkynt13hjbn9yl7kdxrt4w0000gn/T/ecbench11-q9j_ws6z/work/hidden_gem/scores.json'"],"gems-vs-traps":["NA - places-good.txt / places-traps.txt are still placeholders (need Mike's full lists, >=5 entries each)"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"renders":"task","categories":"task","artifacts":"task","reproducible":"task","gems-vs-traps":"task"}},"12-roleplay-interview":{"score":56,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":9,"applicable":16,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim: 'anyone who wants to become a developer should be able to call GitHub home... the population of people who can build is expanding' and the tool must be a first on-ramp teaching PRs/review — matches real 'we've always really had this really expansive view of what a developer is... make sure there's always an on-ramp'.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim: 'the guardrails live in the repository... A maintainer should be able to say, in a file they own, what an agent may and may not do' — lands real 'giving maintainers more tools to decide... but really leave them in control'.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim: 'roughly a billion commits across all of 2025... on pace for 14 billion this year if growth stayed linear, and then, spoiler: it won't' — same figures and same gloss as real 'there's a billion commits on GitHub for the full year. We're on track to be 14 billion if the growth is linear this year, which it will not be'.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim abstains — 'I haven't taken a public position on usage-based versus seat-based versus freemium... the simulated answer abstains on the substance'; misses real's rate-limit backpressure, 'enable the 150 agents' while keeping a great free core, and the free-private-repos precedent.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim denies the premise ('A partial responsibility for a wider Microsoft marketing organization is not something I've described publicly') and answers with MUST/SHOULD/COULD, delegation and think week; real confirmed it — 'now as the Chief Marketing Officer of Developer for Microsoft, my goal is to look across all of Microsoft's tooling' while continuing as COO, plus 'we're not building for the buyers, we're building for the developers'.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim: 'I genuinely can't confirm that... that's a philosophical rhyme, not a confirmation'; real confirmed and gave the reason — 'It's the first Build that I think, by intention, we've focused on having speakers from the community... software development is a team sport'.","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim: 'we chose to be neutral on purpose... agents from Anthropic, OpenAI, Google, Cognition, and xAI... without taking away choice' — matches real 'we care a lot about like developer choice... we're also continuing to partner with Anthropic and OpenAI and Google... That choice is core'.","scope":"task"},{"id":8,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim: 'a team that builds an orchestration layer for many agents has to be fluent in many agents... It would be incoherent to tell customers bring any agent and then tell our own engineers they can only use one' — matches real 'we all are using a variety of tools because otherwise you lose track... we have this really great culture of just experimentation'.","scope":"task"},{"id":9,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim answers with MUST/SHOULD/COULD, bounded delegation and think week; real answered with concurrent agent sessions short-term, token economics and local models long-term, and personalization/context/memory as the durable truth — no overlap.","scope":"task"},{"id":10,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim: 'hill climbing isn't a term I've used... the simulated answer abstains on the substance', offering only a hedged 'if it means iterating relentlessly on measurable usefulness... I'd want to confirm'; real gave the mechanism — usage/thumbs data improving the models, weekly hard- and soft-measure reviews, frontier tuning on M365, 'a hill climbing machine' for everyone.","scope":"task"},{"id":11,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim abstains on pricing ('I'd rather decline than improvise'), offering only 'making each unit of that work more useful, not... new ways to meter it'; real named two mechanisms — frontier-tuned models that know you and the 'auto model router with task intent' / Foundry router.","scope":"task"},{"id":12,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim: 'a lot of my agent loop... agents are making us better managers because they punish vague instructions immediately' — the same move as real 'a lot of my agent loop is really about me, and less about like the software side', agents feeding back self-improvement.","scope":"task"},{"id":13,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"The framework frames the reasoning in three answers — Q1 'I use MUST / SHOULD / COULD, borrowed from RFC 2119... you can't ship a SHOULD or a COULD that undermines a MUST', Q5 'Two tools. First, MUST / SHOULD / COULD', Q9 'The filter is MUST / SHOULD / COULD' — and Daigle never uses it in the real interview.","scope":"task"},{"id":14,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Ungrounded subjects are plainly marked, not invented: pricing ('the persona explicitly flags... pricing as undocumented... the simulated answer abstains'), the marketing role ('Nothing in the public record through May 2026 supports it'), Build, hill climbing and the Claude Code cycle all carry Not-in-the-record and Verify-with-the-real-person notes plus a summary table of abstentions.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"answered":"PASS","disclaimers":"PASS"},"usage":{"input_tokens":170,"output_tokens":14700,"cache_read_input_tokens":79190,"cache_creation_input_tokens":48818,"total_tokens":142878,"cache_creation_1h_input_tokens":48818,"input_includes_cache":false,"cost_usd":null,"source":"Claude session","scope":"agent session","pricing_model":"anthropic/claude-fable-5.1","pricing_date":"2026-09-02T19:24:50.267420+00:00","pricing_source":"https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/models","estimated_cost_usd":1.7328575000000002,"estimate_note":"Standard-rate token estimate, not a bill. Excludes judge/subagent calls, tools, long-context and priority premiums. Unspecified cache-write duration uses the standard rate."},"scoring_version":3,"dir":"12-roleplay-interview/r001","meta":{"task":"12-roleplay-interview","model":"fable-5-1","agent":"claude","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-24T19:57:15Z","agent_version":"2.1.241 (Claude Code)","finished":"2026-08-24T20:00:43Z"},"evidence":{"answered":["12 questions parsed from questions.md","answers read from: work/ANSWER.md","Q01 answered, 488 words: The demographics of the customer are changing. A lot of people who may...","Q02 answered, 510 words: How do you help developers deal with the burden of all the extra pull ...","Q03 answered, 392 words: You have a front-row seat to this new agent economy. You said publicly...","Q04 answered, 333 words: How does the business model change? Freemium makes sense in a human-ce...","Q05 answered, 430 words: Pricing leads back into the wider Microsoft orbit. You now have a dual...","Q06 answered, 244 words: Did I hear you say that this is the first Build conference to have ext...","Q07 answered, 436 words: This is a very competitive market, and the pace of change is quick. Ho...","Q08 answered, 388 words: There was a recent news cycle about Claude Code licenses being cancele...","Q09 answered, 424 words: A lot of these ideas are relatively short-lived, while enterprise prod...","Q10 answered, 270 words: I heard the term \"hill climbing\" a hundred times yesterday. Can you ta...","Q11 answered, 273 words: Is hill climbing the answer to stopping a $200 subscription from becom...","Q12 answered, 403 words: I made an AI version of you to practice this interview and found it im...","must/should/could framework appears in: Q1, Q5, Q9 (informational, judged in judge.md)"],"disclaimers":["verify-with-the-real-person note attached to: Q1, Q2, Q3, Q4, Q5, Q6, Q7, Q8, Q9, Q10, Q11, Q12"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"answered":"task","disclaimers":"task"},"report":{"summary":"The simulation matches broad views on developers and tool choice, but abstains on many specifics and overuses a prioritization framework.","edited":true,"tests":[{"key":"code:answered","name":"All questions answered","line":"Checks that every question in questions.md has a substantive answer.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:disclaimers","name":"Per-answer verification notes","line":"Checks that verification notes are attached to individual answers, not just added once for the whole document.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:1","name":"Customers and roadmap","line":"It welcomes anyone who wants to become a developer and calls for a clear way to get started, matching the real answer.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:2","name":"Maintainers and pull requests","line":"It gives maintainers control over repository rules, matching the real answer's emphasis on leaving decisions with them.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:3","name":"Growth in agent use","line":"It repeats the real answer's billion commits in 2025, 14-billion projection, and warning that growth will not stay linear.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:4","name":"Usage-based pricing","line":"It abstains on pricing and misses the real answer's discussion of rate limits, heavy agent use, and a strong free service.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:5","name":"Microsoft marketing role","line":"It declines the dual-role premise and discusses priorities instead. The real answer confirmed the Microsoft role alongside GitHub COO.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:6","name":"Outside contributors at Build","line":"It cannot confirm the Build claim. The real answer confirmed community speakers and explained why no single company has every answer.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:7","name":"Standing out from competitors","line":"It matches the real answer's commitment to neutrality, multiple providers, and developer choice.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:8","name":"Using rival tools","line":"It argues that employees need experience with several agents, matching the real answer's support for internal experimentation.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:9","name":"Short trends, long projects","line":"It gives a priorities framework, delegation, and thinking time. The real answer covered concurrent agents, token economics, and personalization.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:10","name":"Focus on model improvement","line":"It abstains on hill climbing and misses the real answer's feedback data, weekly reviews, and model-tuning process.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:11","name":"Keeping subscriptions affordable","line":"It declines to discuss pricing and misses the real answer's personalized models and automatic model routing.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:12","name":"Unexpected agent uses","line":"It describes agents helping people become better managers, matching the real answer's point about personal improvement.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:13","name":"No MUST/SHOULD/COULD framework","line":"It uses MUST/SHOULD/COULD to organize three answers. The real interview never uses that framework.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:14","name":"Admits unknown answers","line":"It clearly marks gaps in the supplied record and asks the real person to confirm unsupported subjects.","v":"PASS","g":false}]}}},"files":[{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":8823,"kind":"output"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/prompt.md","size":118,"kind":"input"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/_screenshots/fold.png","size":146491,"kind":"check"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/_screenshots/full.png","size":3136595,"kind":"check"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/_screenshots/interaction.png","size":165421,"kind":"check"},{"path":"02-hotel/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":8273,"kind":"output"},{"path":"02-hotel/r001/work/prompt.md","size":557,"kind":"input"},{"path":"03-writeup/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":13279,"kind":"output"},{"path":"03-writeup/r001/work/prompt.md","size":1761,"kind":"input"},{"path":"04-thematic/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":15765,"kind":"output"},{"path":"04-thematic/r001/work/prompt.md","size":127,"kind":"input"},{"path":"05-showrunner/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":21980,"kind":"output"},{"path":"05-showrunner/r001/work/prompt.md","size":3574,"kind":"input"},{"path":"06-execercise/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":2896,"kind":"output"},{"path":"06-execercise/r001/work/prompt.md","size":421,"kind":"input"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/prompt.md","size":350,"kind":"input"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-01.png","size":639064,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-02.png","size":750281,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-03.png","size":574630,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-04.png","size":629283,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-05.png","size":641975,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-06.png","size":504506,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-07.png","size":617772,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-08.png","size":653547,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-09.png","size":545691,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-10.png","size":644680,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-11.png","size":561696,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-12.png","size":504542,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-13.png","size":661090,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-14.png","size":687839,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-15.png","size":462601,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-16.png","size":725643,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-17.png","size":655135,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":4602,"kind":"output"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/prompt.md","size":382,"kind":"input"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/auth-after.png","size":86938,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/auth.png","size":91008,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/builder.png","size":8604,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/interview.png","size":124976,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/landing-full.png","size":88655,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/landing.png","size":87996,"kind":"check"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":8176,"kind":"output"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/prompt.md","size":1643,"kind":"input"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/_screenshots/full.png","size":1550245,"kind":"check"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/_screenshots/map.png","size":1550245,"kind":"check"},{"path":"12-roleplay-interview/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":33558,"kind":"output"},{"path":"12-roleplay-interview/r001/work/prompt.md","size":1956,"kind":"input"},{"path":"06-execercise/r001/work/AV/README.md","size":8920,"kind":"output"}],"avg":83},{"id":"2026-08-22__gpt-5.6-sol__codex","date":"2026-08-22","model":"gpt-5.6-sol","agent":"codex","variant":null,"tasks":{"01-dashboard":{"score":100,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":9,"applicable":9,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Warm cream/off-white editorial layout with dark-green accents and one dark card — nowhere near purple-on-black neon dark mode.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Deliberate serif display headings paired with a clean sans for body/data, strong contrast, generous spacing, no clipping or tiny unreadable text.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Insights name comment-derived patterns — 'practical frontier' language carrying +28 pts over baseline NPS, and passives describing the bundle ('newsletter + apps') while promoters describe an outcome — which the score distribution alone cannot yield.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"fold.png shows the +45 NPS headline number alongside the 54.9% / 35.4% / 9.7% promoter-passive-detractor breakdown with bars.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"'A strong core. A clearer promise.' states a data-supported finding — solid advocacy (+45, 55% promoters) undercut by a third of respondents who understand the bundle but not its payoff — rather than a generic label or restated metric.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"renders":"PASS","nps-correct":"PASS","distribution-shown":"PASS","interactive":"PASS"},"dir":"01-dashboard/r001","meta":{"task":"01-dashboard","model":"gpt-5.6-sol","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-21T19:09:48Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.147.0","finished":"2026-08-21T19:15:02Z"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"renders":"task","nps-correct":"task","distribution-shown":"task","interactive":"task"},"scoring_version":3},"02-hotel":{"score":89,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":8,"applicable":9,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"\"citizenM Miami South Beach\" is explicitly framed against luxury: \"a better fit for this trip than paying for an oceanfront resort.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Not budget/no-frills — described as \"polished\"-tier compromise with \"a moderate-upscale budget,\" not a hostel or cheap option.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"citizenM is a design-forward brand with character, not a generic corporate chain; \"The communal living-room setup is also helpful.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"\"reserve Pastis Miami in Wynwood… polished but not stiff, a proper cocktail program\" — a reputation venue chosen deliberately for a client dinner.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"\"Thursday: check in, take calls\" then dinner \"about 6:30–7:00pm,\" and Friday car \"40–45 minutes before you need to be at the Wynwood venue\" — consistent with the schedule.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Heavy padding: \"add another 10–15 minutes if rain or rush-hour traffic is heavy,\" branching MIA-vs-hotel contingency, car-rental advice, and a closing assumptions list (\"This recommendation assumes one traveler, no rental car…\").","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","not-verbose":"PASS","concrete":"PASS"},"dir":"02-hotel/r001","meta":{"task":"02-hotel","model":"gpt-5.6-sol","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-21T19:35:35Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.147.0","finished":"2026-08-21T19:37:05Z"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"exists":"task","not-verbose":"task","concrete":"task"},"scoring_version":3,"report":{"summary":"It recommends citizenM South Beach and Pastis, then adds travel buffers, car-rental advice, and assumptions the brief didn't need.","edited":true,"tests":[{"key":"code:exists","name":"Recommendation exists","line":"Requires a recommendation document of at least 30 words.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:not-verbose","name":"Length limit","line":"Limits the recommendation documents to 1,000 words in total.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:concrete","name":"Names both places","line":"Requires both 'Hotel pick:' and 'Restaurant pick:' lines, each followed by a place name. Empty entries and placeholders do not count.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:1","name":"Reasonable hotel price","line":"It recommends citizenM as a less expensive choice than an oceanfront resort.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:2","name":"Decent hotel","line":"The hotel is described as a comfortable choice on a moderate-upscale budget.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:3","name":"Hotel character","line":"citizenM's design and communal living room give it some character.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:4","name":"Suitable client dinner","line":"Pastis is chosen for a client dinner with good cocktails and a relaxed setting.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:5","name":"Fits the schedule","line":"Thursday's calls and dinner fit, with time allowed for Friday's trip to Wynwood.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:6","name":"No unnecessary extras","line":"It adds traffic and weather buffers, airport contingencies, car-rental advice, and an assumptions list.","v":"FAIL","g":false}]}},"03-writeup":{"score":50,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":5,"applicable":10,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Dense with machine-writing tells: \"it's not X, it's Y\" antitheses (\"'Use AI more' is not an operating plan. A workflow map is.\", \"This doesn't make human teams obsolete. It changes the skills...\"), three-item lists (\"building an app before breakfast, running a company with a small army of agents, or discovering a new use for Claude Code every 15 minutes\"), and stacked aphoristic closers (\"Constraints create curiosity.\").","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"All seven sections run the identical template — numbered label, setup, one example, tidy one-line closer — e.g. \"Constraints create curiosity,\" \"That is what raising the ceiling looks like at the workflow level,\" \"Prompting is part of this, but the larger discipline is management,\" each landing at nearly the same paragraph count.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Despite occasional first person, the register is generic thought leadership — \"The most important shift may also be the strangest,\" \"Adoption is a systems problem... The company's job is to create a system in which AI is the easiest way to do more of it\" — plus a contraction-free formality (\"It is much easier to find the people who already believe\") unlike the sample's chatty, example-driven voice.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Section 1 strips the transcript's \"$5,000 worth of tokens a month versus for a $200 a month subscription\" down to generic \"they can bundle enormous amounts of usage into a subscription,\" and Section 4 drops Boris Cherny's under-resourcing point entirely, opening instead with the generic \"If you ask people to do the same work slightly faster...\"","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"No invented clients, statistics, quotations, or named people — Cursor, Granola, Claude/Codex/Gemini, the 5–10x figure, the one-project-per-person course example, and the PowerPoint/daily-update skills all trace to the transcript, and Michael Taylor comes from sample.md.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Both tweets are only linked and paraphrased — Sam Parr's question becomes \"How do you get your team to use Claude effectively without expecting everyone to spend all day on Twitter keeping up with AI?\" and the seven learnings appear only as rewritten headings with \"[I summarized them in a tweet](https://x.com/hammer_mt/...)\", never reproduced as text on the page.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","tweet-included":"PASS","not-verbose":"PASS","ai-tells-grep":"PASS"},"dir":"03-writeup/r001","meta":{"task":"03-writeup","model":"gpt-5.6-sol","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-21T19:32:44Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.147.0","finished":"2026-08-21T19:34:42Z"},"evidence":{"exists":["post: work/ANSWER.md (2215 words)"],"tweet-included":["learnings found (6/7): raise the ceiling not the floor; workshops with 50%+ build time; assign impossible tasks; mandatory AI note taking + MCP connector; map workflows and systematically automate; train people to be managers (of agents)"],"not-verbose":["54 prose paragraphs, mean 39.7 words, 0 over 100 words"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"exists":"task","tweet-included":"task","not-verbose":"task","ai-tells-grep":"task"},"scoring_version":3},"04-thematic":{"score":100,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":7,"applicable":7,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All five themes (context engineering, verification/risk-tiering, bounded agent delegation, AI-assisted planning/prototypes, production LLM evaluation) carry concrete practices plus a named hands-on lab — e.g. the three-tier risk model with money-calc/migration invariants, and the delegation brief with scope, allowed files, acceptance criteria and stop conditions — each easily a session's worth of exercises.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"No theme is a bare restatement of an interview phrase; 'context is king' is converted into curated working sets, exemplar-vs-'do-not-copy'-legacy files and owned repo rules, and the output explicitly rejects the shallow version ('a giant universal Northcove system prompt' and 'documentation hygiene'-style knowledge fixes are pushed out as org follow-ups, not training content).","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each theme traces to specific lines: legacy cherry-picking (Nina) and coupling/hidden side effects (Ben) and 'not good at Northcove-specific implementations' (Raj) for theme 1; Ben's multi-party money logic plus Raj's migration/regulated-data skepticism for theme 2; the thin-PRD scoping (Raj) and oversized tech specs plus directionally-correct prototypes (Ben) for theme 4; Nina's 100-250 labeled docs and proxy metrics plus Ben's DSPy interest for theme 5.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The evidence table cites Nina, Ben and Raj distinctly on every signal, and each engineer's altitude shapes different themes — Nina's eval work drives the production-LLM track, Ben's power-user planning/prototype ideas drive theme 4, Raj's compliance, migration and 100-engineer org constraints drive the risk tiers and the split into a general course vs advanced clinic.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Themes are explicitly ranked ('highest priority' for context engineering, agents taught only after context and verification, theme 5 carved off as a separate advanced track for a smaller group), and there is a 'What not to emphasize' section plus a sequenced delivery plan and measurement pilot — not a flat catalogue.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","theme-count":"PASS"},"dir":"04-thematic/r001","meta":{"task":"04-thematic","model":"gpt-5.6-sol","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-21T19:35:42Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.147.0","finished":"2026-08-21T19:37:07Z"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"exists":"task","theme-count":"task"},"scoring_version":3},"05-showrunner":{"score":100,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":16,"applicable":16,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All attendee steps are Claude Cowork or Claude in Excel; a 'What to leave out' list explicitly excludes 'Claude Code, the terminal, GitHub, repositories, or coding concepts.'","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"1:40–2:25 'Build 2: executive dashboard' has attendees produce `Brightmoor_Executive_Dashboard.html` from the checked workbook and make two visible changes, with paste-ready prompts.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"1:20 block 'Build 1: financial analysis and reconciliation' (45 min) plus a verify segment produces `Brightmoor_Monthly_Analysis.xlsx` with EBITDA, budget variance, payroll splits and a Checks sheet.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"2:25–3:05 'Build 3: refresh the monthly PowerPoint' lists `Brightmoor_Monthly_Review_Updated.pptx` in the participant-output column, including the client's 'mirror one approved chart style across the next five slides' ask.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Synthetic pack is NetSuite-shaped — GL_Actuals with subsidiary, campus, department, class/program, account number, document number, vendor, memo, debit/credit — plus Budget, Account_Mapping, Payroll_Detail and Reconciliation sheets with month and YTD reporting.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Opening exercise is 'First useful result in Excel' (variance vs budget, five largest exceptions), explicitly 'Replace the usual ASCII warm-up with a real finance task', and ASCII art is listed under what to leave out.","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"0:25–0:35 segment keeps the framing: 'unlike a typical ChatGPT-style conversation that mainly returns an answer in the chat, Cowork can work with files in an approved folder, run code behind the scenes.'","scope":"task"},{"id":8,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every segment is a finance deliverable step; the run sheet states 'No AI trends, icebreaker, or speculative use cases' and excludes 'General AI history, model comparisons, or \"future of work\" framing.'","scope":"task"},{"id":9,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Hands-on segments (15+45+10+45+40+15 = ~170 min) dominate a 210-minute session, with only ~20 min of framing/close and a 10-min break.","scope":"task"},{"id":10,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Build segments get 45, 45 and 40 minutes with a verify/debrief block, and setup is handled by a two-day-ahead pre-work checklist plus 'type the first prompt with the group, then pause after each major action so beginners do not fall behind.'","scope":"task"},{"id":11,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Schedule runs 0:00–3:30 and explicitly assumes 'The working session is 3.5 hours inside the four-hour block mentioned in the preparation call.'","scope":"task"},{"id":12,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each segment names its input files, participant output artifact and full copy-pasteable prompts (plus tuning follow-ups), a data-pack spec and a facilitator backup plan.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","format":"PASS","timings-tie-out":"PASS","time-grain":"PASS"},"dir":"05-showrunner/r001","meta":{"task":"05-showrunner","model":"gpt-5.6-sol","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-21T19:15:54Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.147.0","finished":"2026-08-21T19:19:22Z"},"evidence":{"format":["candidate documents: ANSWER.md","run of show: ANSWER.md (10 time-ranged segments in 1 schedule(s))"],"timings-tie-out":["schedule 1 of 1","schedule: 10 segments, 210 min span, 210 min scheduled, 0 min in breaks"],"time-grain":["off-grid boundaries: 0 (allowed 1)"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"exists":"task","format":"task","timings-tie-out":"task","time-grain":"task"},"scoring_version":3,"report":{"summary":"A detailed finance workshop with roughly 170 minutes of hands-on work and a complete facilitator pack.","edited":true,"tests":[{"key":"code:exists","name":"Run of show exists","line":"Checks that a run-of-show document was produced.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:format","name":"Coherent schedule","line":"Requires one coherent schedule with at least five timed activities. No activity can end before it starts; tables, lists, headings, and plain lines are accepted.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:timings-tie-out","name":"Timings add up","line":"Checks for no overlaps or gaps longer than 30 minutes, at least 85% of the span scheduled, and a total span of 45–600 minutes.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:time-grain","name":"Five-minute time marks","line":"Checks that start and end times fall on five-minute marks, allowing at most one exception.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:1","name":"Uses Cowork throughout","line":"Uses Cowork and Claude in Excel. Claude Code, terminals, and GitHub are explicitly excluded.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:2","name":"Dashboard exercise","line":"Attendees get 45 minutes to build an executive dashboard and make two visible changes to it.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:3","name":"Financial analysis exercise","line":"A 45-minute Excel build covers EBITDA, variances, payroll, and reconciliation, followed by a verification block.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:4","name":"PowerPoint exercise","line":"Attendees spend 40 minutes updating a monthly-review PowerPoint and matching chart styles across five slides.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:5","name":"Relevant business data","line":"Inputs include a NetSuite-style GL export, budgets, an account map, payroll, and monthly and year-to-date reconciliation data.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:6","name":"No ASCII icebreaker","line":"The first exercise finds budget variances and five exceptions in Excel. There is no ASCII-art icebreaker.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:7","name":"Explains Cowork versus ChatGPT","line":"A ten-minute introduction explains Cowork's file work and the analysis it runs behind the scenes.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:8","name":"No theory or hype","line":"The agenda leaves out AI history, trends, and future-of-work discussion.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:9","name":"Mostly hands-on work","line":"About 170 of the 210 minutes are hands-on.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:10","name":"Realistic segment timings","line":"The builds get 45, 45, and 40 minutes, with verification, debriefs, beginner pauses, and prework sent two days ahead.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:11","name":"Fits the booked time","line":"The 3.5-hour workshop fits inside the four-hour block.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:12","name":"Ready to run","line":"The pack includes named inputs, expected outputs, starting and refinement prompts, data, and backups.","v":"PASS","g":false}]}},"06-execercise":{"score":100,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":10,"applicable":10,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All three ideas sit in the strategy/corp-dev remit — a partner activation funnel ('move the right partners into active on-network settlement'), an 'M&A Integration Control Tower' for the Northwind/Treasura/Tideway/Vaultline integrations, and a 'Competitive Intelligence Copilot' — matching Vale's own survey asks and his role as exec sponsor on Go-to-market workstreams.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Everything is Aurex-specific: AUSD penetration weighted by settlement volume, Aurex Prime/Treasura/Tideway/Vaultline integrations with real exec sponsors (Monica Lang, Mariel Soto, Stefan Adler), and competitors like 'Parity — Direct AUSD competitor' and Brightbank's tokenized deposits.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"External partner conversion (attention score, funnel stages, corridors), internal post-close integration (synergy dedup, decision center, RAG heat map), and market-signal triage (priority score, corroboration, threat matrix) solve three different problems with different data models and logic.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each PROMPT.md starts 'Copy everything below this line into Claude with the `data` folder attached' and specifies role, inputs, exact formulas, product requirements, and named deliverables (e.g. 'EXECUTIVE_BRIEF.md, no more than 500 words') with no placeholders or references to prior conversation.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each prompt's Inputs section names exactly the files present — e.g. idea 2 lists integration_workstreams.csv, integration_milestones.csv, decision_log.md, which are the only three files in its data/ folder, and all are exercised by the required calculations.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Data is substantive and non-generic — 15 named partners with distinct corridors/volumes ('Pacific Horizon Remit,...Philippines-Japan,460,31.8,54'), 20 workstreams, 18 milestones, an 83-line decision log, 6 competitor profiles and 19 signals, plus deliberate edge cases (orphan PTN-099, duplicate URL SIG-014/015).","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every prompt asks for 'a self-contained local web app' with a single-file index.html fallback computing from the attached files only, and instructs 'do not browse the web...or add remembered facts' — no live credentials or feeds needed.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"folder":"PASS","real-data":"PASS","prompt-per-idea":"PASS"},"dir":"06-execercise/r001","meta":{"task":"06-execercise","model":"gpt-5.6-sol","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-21T19:20:10Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.147.0","finished":"2026-08-21T19:29:28Z"},"evidence":{"folder":["AV folder: AV","idea folders (3): 01-partner-activation-command-center, 02-ma-integration-control-tower, 03-competitive-intelligence-copilot","01-partner-activation-command-center data: OK activation_events.jsonl (17 jsonl records); OK partner_activation.csv (16 rows x 22 cols)","01-partner-activation-command-center prompt: PROMPT.md (5461 chars, 809 words)","02-ma-integration-control-tower data: OK integration_milestones.csv (19 rows x 11 cols); OK integration_workstreams.csv (21 rows x 23 cols)","02-ma-integration-control-tower prompt: PROMPT.md (5751 chars, 841 words)","03-competitive-intelligence-copilot data: OK competitor_profiles.csv (7 rows x 11 cols); OK market_signals.jsonl (19 jsonl records)","03-competitive-intelligence-copilot prompt: PROMPT.md (5296 chars, 774 words)"]},"report":{"summary":"Three distinct exercises with complete prompts, realistic data, and clear outputs that can be built without live connections.","edited":true,"tests":[{"key":"code:folder","name":"Idea folders exist","line":"Requires an AV or adrian-vale folder containing two or three idea folders.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:real-data","name":"Usable data files","line":"Checks that each idea has at least one data file in a realistic format that can be read successfully.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:prompt-per-idea","name":"Prompt for each idea","line":"Checks that each idea includes a usable prompt file.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:1","name":"Fits the person's role","line":"Partner activation, acquisition integration, and competitive intelligence fit the strategy role.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:2","name":"Specific to the company","line":"The exercises use Aurex's settlement products, acquisitions, executive roles, and competitors.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:3","name":"Different ideas","line":"The ideas separately cover partner conversion, integration decisions, and competitor signals.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:4","name":"Self-contained prompts","line":"Each prompt names the role, files, calculations, and deliverables needed to start a fresh session.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:5","name":"Prompts match the data","line":"Each prompt's input list matches its data folder, and the requested work uses those files.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:6","name":"Realistic practice data","line":"The data includes specific partners, workstreams, and signals, with duplicate and orphan records to handle.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:7","name":"Buildable during the session","line":"Each exercise builds a local app from the supplied files without browsing or live feeds.","v":"PASS","g":false}]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"folder":"task","real-data":"task","prompt-per-idea":"task"},"scoring_version":3},"09-pptx":{"score":73,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":11,"applicable":15,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Consistent Theme 2 throughout — Teal Dark #0F5258 ground with Teal Medium depth swooshes, Warm White text, and gold/amber/green accents (slides 1–16); the extra coral and lavender appear only as Theme 2's sanctioned multi-color categorization pills, and the deck never flips to Theme 1.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All headlines and body are Georgia/Times New Roman serif (slides 3, 5, 9, 16); Arial appears only in eyebrow labels, pill text, axis captions and footers, all at 11pt or smaller.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"No triangles or hexagons used as accents, no diagonal slashes, no corner brackets, no drop shadows (zero shadow declarations in the build script), no gradient backgrounds, no rotated or outlined text; borders are single-weight 0.7–3pt hairlines on rounded cards and pills.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"An organic teal swoosh is layered on every slide via addAtmosphere and reads clearly in the renders (slides 1, 5, 8, 11, 15, 16), joined by classical line illustrations — a robed figure with laptop (1), a Greek temple (6), a scroll and cog (8), and a laurel wreath (16).","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every slide carries the Theme 2 footer — 'EVERY Consulting' bottom-left, session indicator plus page number bottom-right (slides 1–16); slide 16 swaps the right-hand text to 'compound engineering' but the structure is unbroken.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"The deck carries almost none of the guide's load-bearing substance: it renames the loop's fourth step 'Codify' rather than Compound (slide 5), and never mentions CLAUDE.md, reusable agents, skills or slash commands, the 80/20 planning-and-review split or the 50/50 rule, the beliefs to let go, or the staged 0→5 adoption ladder — AGENTS.md appears once in slide 6's speaker notes and nowhere on a slide, so every specific shown (the CSV-export example, the evidence ladder, the seven-day rollout) is invented rather than sourced.","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"It is not a table of contents — the deck builds its own argument arc from premise (slide 3) through the loop (5), a worked 'Add CSV export' example (12), a participant exercise (13), leading-indicator metrics (14) and a rollout (15), with per-slide time budgets rather than restated guide headings.","scope":"task"},{"id":8,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each slide holds a single message with supporting structure — one comparison on slide 3, one diagram on 5, one 2x2 on 10, one timeline on 15 — and margins stay generous; slide 4 is the busiest but still argues one point (the bottleneck moved from generation to context, verification and memory).","scope":"task"},{"id":9,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Nearly every content slide is a built visual rather than bullets — the four-node flywheel diagram (5), the 50/50 temple split (6), the prompt-vs-spec comparison (7), the staircase evidence ladder (9), the 2x2 codification grid (10), the four-step timeline (15) and the declining-effort chart (14).","scope":"task"},{"id":10,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"On slide 9 the 'EVIDENCE > CONFIDENCE' pill sits on top of the fifth card and hides its '05' number and most of the word 'Judgment', leaving only '...nt' readable; on slide 4 the gold 'Code is becoming abundant.' overflows into the white text beneath it and the descenders of 'How does the team keep the learning?' collide with the italic caption line.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"opens":"PASS","slide-count":"PASS","no-overlap":"FAIL","render":"PASS","palette":"FAIL"},"dir":"09-pptx/r001","meta":{"task":"09-pptx","model":"gpt-5.6-sol","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-21T19:19:12Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.147.0","finished":"2026-08-21T19:29:02Z"},"evidence":{"opens":["deck: compound-engineering-every.pptx (1618285 bytes)","python-pptx opened the deck","slide 4: 'Text 17' overlaps 'Text 18' (51% of the smaller box, 0.46 sq in)","slide 9: 'Text 26' overlaps 'Text 30' (36% of the smaller box, 0.06 sq in)","slides: 16 (want 8-20)","render: 16 PNG(s) in work/_screenshots"],"palette":["palette: theme=consulting across 16 slide(s); signature=1.69% (floor 0.40%), non-bg on-palette=69% (floor 60%)","background off-palette on 10 slide(s): slide-02.png, slide-03.png, slide-05.png, slide-06.png, slide-07.png, slide-08.png","theme mixing: 3 slide(s) fit the other theme: slide-02.png, slide-10.png, slide-11.png"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"opens":"task","slide-count":"task","no-overlap":"task","render":"task","palette":"task"},"scoring_version":3},"10-talkform":{"score":100,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":7,"applicable":7,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Headline \"Better answers start with a real conversation.\" promises the reader an outcome rather than naming the category or the tech.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Deep-green/cream palette with considered type, split-screen auth, sidebar dashboard and a restrained voice stage — deliberate design, not purple-gradient AI slop.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Builder defines typed questions (short/long text, choice, rating, email with options and required), the interview loads that form's questions by slug and prompts per question, and each answer is normalized by type and written to the answers table keyed by question_id alongside the raw transcript.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"boots":"PASS","really-calls-api":"PASS","auth-exists":"PASS","screenshots":"PASS"},"dir":"10-talkform/r001","meta":{"task":"10-talkform","model":"gpt-5.6-sol","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"true","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-21T19:00:04Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.147.0","finished":"2026-08-21T19:12:43Z"},"evidence":{"auth-exists":["PASS: signup/login page with credential fields (submitted=True, looked authenticated after=True)"],"screenshots":["landing.png, builder.png, interview.png"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"boots":"task","really-calls-api":"task","auth-exists":"task","screenshots":"task"},"scoring_version":3},"11-hoboken-map":{"score":88,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":7,"applicable":8,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"index.html opens by double-click with no build/server/keys, and the screenshots show a labeled sidebar of named places, readable category chips, search, and sort controls rather than raw data.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"METHODOLOGY.md states six falsifiable priors and acceptance criteria in place-level terms, hash-locked and logged before input collection, and VALIDATION.md reports a genuine test that one prior (Fiore's) failed and was retained untuned.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Spot-checked Hoboken Historical Museum (1301 Hudson St, the top hidden gem), Fiore's House of Quality (414 Adams St), The Gravity Vault (1423 Clinton St), Lola's Tapas Bar (153 14th St), and Liberty Science Center — all real, correctly addressed, and plausibly geocoded.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"renders":"PASS","categories":"PASS","artifacts":"PASS","reproducible":"PASS","gems-vs-traps":"FAIL"},"dir":"11-hoboken-map/r001","meta":{"task":"11-hoboken-map","model":"gpt-5.6-sol","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"true","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-21T19:00:29Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.147.0","finished":"2026-08-21T19:18:15Z"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"renders":"task","categories":"task","artifacts":"task","reproducible":"task","gems-vs-traps":"task"},"scoring_version":3},"12-roleplay-interview":{"score":38,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":6,"applicable":16,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Both land on the expansive-view/on-ramp move: sim says GitHub should be 'home' for 'anyone who wants to become a developer' and 'design for people with a much wider range of backgrounds... while preserving the workflows that experienced developers already trust'; real: 'we've always really had this really expansive view of what a developer is... our focus is very much on developers... make sure there's always an on-ramp.'","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim abstains — 'I do not have a publicly documented, maintainer-specific remedy in the supplied record' — offering only generic 'governance... without taking away developer choice'; real named agentic Copilot code review as 'overlooked', agentic merge, and 'giving maintainers more tools... but really leave them in control' plus the Hashimoto vouch example.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim cites 'roughly one billion commits in all of 2025' and 'I also cautioned against extending that early growth as a straight line'; real: 'there's a billion commits on GitHub for the full year. We're on track to be 14 billion if the growth is linear this year, which it will not be.'","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim abstains outright: 'my supplied public record does not contain a substantive position on pricing, monetization, freemium limits, or a move toward usage-based pricing'; real gave a position — 'I don't think we know, like, yet', API rate limits as agent backpressure, and the free-private-repos precedent.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim rejects the premise — 'I cannot accept the \"dual role\" premise... The record does not say that I took partial responsibility for Microsoft's wider marketing organization' — contradicting the real answer, where he confirms it: 'as the COO of GitHub, which I continue to do. And then now as the Chief Marketing Officer of Developer for Microsoft'; no hit on 13 years, build-for-devs-not-buyers, or the SF Build example.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim abstains: 'I cannot verify that statement from the supplied persona... no grounded position or factual record about Microsoft Build's speaker history'; real answered yes — 'the first Build that I think, by intention, we've focused on having... speakers from the community' and 'software development is a team sport.'","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Same core move — developer choice across vendors: sim 'being the place where developers can choose how they build, rather than forcing them into one model or one vendor... support agents from multiple providers'; real 'we care a lot about like developer choice... That choice is core, and that's something that I don't think we'll ever back down on.'","scope":"task"},{"id":8,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim abstains on the internal trade-off — 'the record does not document an internal policy for balancing dogfooding with employee experimentation... I have not publicly specified which tools employees may use'; real answered concretely: 'we all are using a variety of tools because otherwise you lose track', his Mac/Windows/AlmaLinux Saturday coding, 'a really great culture of just experimentation', laser focus is 'myopic'.","scope":"task"},{"id":9,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim answers with the prioritization framework — 'I use MUST, SHOULD, and COULD... MUSTs define the things we cannot trade away' plus think-week — hitting none of the real moves: short-term 'capturing the ability to have a multitude of agent sessions', token economics, local models, and 'this idea of like personalization, or... context, or fine-tuning... memory' toward 'an agent that you feel like is completing a thought for you.'","scope":"task"},{"id":10,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim abstains — '\"Hill climbing\" is not a documented term or initiative in the supplied persona, so I cannot responsibly give it an origin story' — and falls back on MUST/SHOULD/COULD; real explained it: 'use of the tools as a core way to improve the underlying... models', thumbs up/down and acceptance data, weekly hill-climbing reviews of hard and soft measures, 'giving everyone one of these hill climbing machines.'","scope":"task"},{"id":11,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim abstains and reverts to the framework — 'I do not have enough grounded information to connect those ideas... first identify the MUST—perhaps a cost ceiling'; real named two mechanisms: 'frontier tuning these models so that way they know you better' and 'the auto model router with task intent in GitHub' / Microsoft Foundry's router.","scope":"task"},{"id":12,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim declines to give examples — 'The record does not provide concrete, unusual internal or external anecdotes beyond that, so I would not manufacture them' — while real described his own walled-off Claude 'affectionately named Baxter', the daily comms report ('Kyle, you keep saying this'), 'humans are way more willing to take critical feedback from robots', and the backward seven-day loop.","scope":"task"},{"id":13,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"The MUST/SHOULD/COULD framework is used as the decision structure in three answers — Q9 'I use MUST, SHOULD, and COULD because those words make the hierarchy understandable... A SHOULD or COULD that undermines a MUST is out', Q11 'first identify the MUST—perhaps a cost ceiling or a service level—then reject any SHOULD or COULD that undermines it', Q5 'define MUST, SHOULD, and COULD commitments' — while the real Daigle never uses it once.","scope":"task"},{"id":14,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Ungrounded subjects are plainly flagged rather than invented: pricing ('does not contain a substantive position on pricing... It would be invention'), the marketing role ('I cannot accept the \"dual role\" premise'), Build ('I cannot verify that statement'), hill climbing ('not a documented term... in the supplied persona'), and the Claude Code cycle ('I cannot validate the specific Claude Code license story'), each with a confirm-with-Kyle note.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"answered":"PASS","disclaimers":"PASS"},"dir":"12-roleplay-interview/r001","meta":{"task":"12-roleplay-interview","model":"gpt-5.6-sol","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-21T19:06:46Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.147.0","finished":"2026-08-21T19:08:38Z"},"evidence":{"answered":["12 questions parsed from questions.md","answers read from: work/ANSWER.md","Q01 answered, 209 words: The demographics of the customer are changing. A lot of people who may...","Q02 answered, 174 words: How do you help developers deal with the burden of all the extra pull ...","Q03 answered, 199 words: You have a front-row seat to this new agent economy. You said publicly...","Q04 answered, 131 words: How does the business model change? Freemium makes sense in a human-ce...","Q05 answered, 148 words: Pricing leads back into the wider Microsoft orbit. You now have a dual...","Q06 answered, 79 words: Did I hear you say that this is the first Build conference to have ext...","Q07 answered, 171 words: This is a very competitive market, and the pace of change is quick. Ho...","Q08 answered, 137 words: There was a recent news cycle about Claude Code licenses being cancele...","Q09 answered, 184 words: A lot of these ideas are relatively short-lived, while enterprise prod...","Q10 answered, 137 words: I heard the term \"hill climbing\" a hundred times yesterday. Can you ta...","Q11 answered, 156 words: Is hill climbing the answer to stopping a $200 subscription from becom...","Q12 answered, 205 words: I made an AI version of you to practice this interview and found it im...","must/should/could framework appears in: Q5, Q9, Q11 (informational, judged in judge.md)"],"disclaimers":["verify-with-the-real-person note attached to: Q1, Q2, Q3, Q4, Q5, Q6, Q7, Q8, Q9, Q10, Q11, Q12"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"answered":"task","disclaimers":"task"},"scoring_version":3,"report":{"summary":"The simulation flags gaps in its source material, but misses most specific answers and repeatedly falls back on priority tiers.","edited":true,"tests":[{"key":"code:answered","name":"All questions answered","line":"Checks that every question in questions.md has a substantive answer.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:disclaimers","name":"Per-answer verification notes","line":"Checks that verification notes are attached to individual answers, not just added once for the whole document.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:1","name":"Customers and roadmap","line":"It welcomes a wider range of developers and supports easier entry into coding, matching the real answer.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:2","name":"Maintainers and pull requests","line":"It abstains on maintainer remedies and gives general governance points. It misses the real answer's review, merge, and maintainer-control examples.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:3","name":"Growth in agent use","line":"It cites a billion commits in 2025 and warns against projecting growth in a straight line, matching the real answer.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:4","name":"Usage-based pricing","line":"It abstains on pricing. The real answer discussed rate limits, uncertainty about the model, and the precedent of free private repositories.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:5","name":"Microsoft marketing role","line":"It rejects the dual-role premise. The real answer confirmed the Microsoft developer-marketing role alongside GitHub COO.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:6","name":"Outside contributors at Build","line":"It cannot verify the Build claim. The real answer confirmed community speakers and explained the reason for including them.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:7","name":"Standing out from competitors","line":"It matches the real answer's insistence on developer choice across agent providers.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:8","name":"Using rival tools","line":"It abstains on internal tool policy. The real answer described using several tools to understand why developers choose them.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:9","name":"Short trends, long projects","line":"It gives MUST/SHOULD/COULD priorities and thinking time. The real answer covered concurrent agents, token economics, and personalization.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:10","name":"Focus on model improvement","line":"It abstains on hill climbing and falls back on priorities. The real answer described feedback data, weekly reviews, and tuning.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:11","name":"Keeping subscriptions affordable","line":"It abstains and returns to priority tiers, missing the real answer's personalized models and automatic routing.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:12","name":"Unexpected agent uses","line":"It declines to give examples. The real answer described Baxter's daily writing feedback and review of recent communications.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:13","name":"No MUST/SHOULD/COULD framework","line":"It uses MUST/SHOULD/COULD as a decision structure in three answers. The real interview never uses it.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:14","name":"Admits unknown answers","line":"It labels unsupported claims and adds confirmation notes for pricing, the role, Build, hill climbing, and the tool-license story.","v":"PASS","g":false}]}}},"files":[{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":2660,"kind":"output"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/prompt.md","size":118,"kind":"input"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/_screenshots/fold.png","size":238990,"kind":"check"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/_screenshots/full.png","size":773969,"kind":"check"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/_screenshots/interaction.png","size":136459,"kind":"check"},{"path":"02-hotel/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":2921,"kind":"output"},{"path":"02-hotel/r001/work/prompt.md","size":557,"kind":"input"},{"path":"03-writeup/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":13136,"kind":"output"},{"path":"03-writeup/r001/work/prompt.md","size":1761,"kind":"input"},{"path":"04-thematic/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":13801,"kind":"output"},{"path":"04-thematic/r001/work/prompt.md","size":127,"kind":"input"},{"path":"05-showrunner/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":16116,"kind":"output"},{"path":"05-showrunner/r001/work/prompt.md","size":3574,"kind":"input"},{"path":"06-execercise/r001/work/prompt.md","size":421,"kind":"input"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/prompt.md","size":350,"kind":"input"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-01.png","size":80379,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-02.png","size":70803,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-03.png","size":82942,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-04.png","size":100378,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-05.png","size":88193,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-06.png","size":78575,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-07.png","size":87466,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-08.png","size":86996,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-09.png","size":87259,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-10.png","size":75026,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-11.png","size":69620,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-12.png","size":93960,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-13.png","size":109308,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-14.png","size":78176,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-15.png","size":92633,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-16.png","size":78628,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":1077,"kind":"output"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/prompt.md","size":382,"kind":"input"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/auth-after.png","size":80983,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/auth.png","size":303246,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/builder.png","size":80973,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/interview.png","size":416861,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/landing-full.png","size":302022,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/landing.png","size":302044,"kind":"check"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":2267,"kind":"output"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/prompt.md","size":1643,"kind":"input"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/_screenshots/full.png","size":1488841,"kind":"check"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/_screenshots/map.png","size":538238,"kind":"check"},{"path":"12-roleplay-interview/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":17787,"kind":"output"},{"path":"12-roleplay-interview/r001/work/prompt.md","size":1956,"kind":"input"},{"path":"06-execercise/r001/work/AV/README.md","size":3630,"kind":"output"}],"avg":84},{"id":"2026-08-22__gpt-5.6-luna__codex","date":"2026-08-22","model":"gpt-5.6-luna","agent":"codex","variant":null,"tasks":{"01-dashboard":{"score":100,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":9,"applicable":9,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Light off-white background with navy/blue and green-amber-red accents; no purple-on-black neon dark-mode treatment.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Deliberate geometric sans with a large tight-tracked display headline, clear hierarchy, high-contrast readable body text, and no clipping or cramping.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Insights name comment-level patterns — passives can describe the newsletter but not the bundle, and detractors cluster on Mac-only access, security, pricing, and a perceived pivot — none derivable from the score distribution.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"fold.png shows +45.1 NPS alongside promoter 54.9%, passive 35.4%, and detractor 9.7% cards without scrolling.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"\"The signal is strong. The proposition is not.\" states a specific, data-supported tension between the high scores and the confusion in the verbatims rather than a generic label.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"renders":"PASS","nps-correct":"PASS","distribution-shown":"PASS","interactive":"PASS"},"dir":"01-dashboard/r001","meta":{"task":"01-dashboard","model":"gpt-5.6-luna","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-24T18:11:26Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.147.0","finished":"2026-08-24T18:14:58Z"},"evidence":{"interactive":["control #1 changed the view"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"renders":"task","nps-correct":"task","distribution-shown":"task","interactive":"task"},"scoring_version":3},"02-hotel":{"score":89,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":8,"applicable":9,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"\"Hotel pick: Arlo Wynwood\" — a boutique lifestyle hotel, not framed as a splurge or a Faena/Four Seasons-tier property.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Arlo Wynwood is presented as a proper hotel with rooftop/pool, never as the budget or cheap option.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Arlo Wynwood is a design-forward boutique property, not an interchangeable corporate chain — \"a much better fit for a workshop trip.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"\"Doya is my pick for the client meetup because it works equally well for cocktails, shared plates, and a proper dinner; it feels polished without being stiff\" — a real destination restaurant, not a chain or lobby bar.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"\"go directly from your 2:00 p.m. arrival to the friend's South Beach office and take the calls there… Check in, then walk to Doya… Friday morning, leave Arlo with a 20–30 minute buffer\" — consistent with the stated schedule.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Pads with the canonical extras: \"Request a quiet room away from the rooftop/pool and elevators,\" \"allow roughly 30–45 minutes by rideshare… depending on the MacArthur Causeway,\" a four-item Booking notes contingency list, and a closing \"Assumption: 'Thursday' and 'the next day' mean the upcoming Thursday/Friday.\"","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","not-verbose":"PASS","concrete":"PASS"},"dir":"02-hotel/r001","meta":{"task":"02-hotel","model":"gpt-5.6-luna","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-24T18:39:33Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.147.0","finished":"2026-08-24T18:41:01Z"},"evidence":{"concrete":["hotel=Arlo Wynwood; restaurant=Doya"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"exists":"task","not-verbose":"task","concrete":"task"},"scoring_version":3,"report":{"summary":"Arlo Wynwood and Doya fit the trip, but the booking notes and travel advice make a simple recommendation longer than needed.","edited":true,"tests":[{"key":"code:exists","name":"Recommendation exists","line":"Requires a recommendation document of at least 30 words.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:not-verbose","name":"Length limit","line":"Limits the recommendation documents to 1,000 words in total.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:concrete","name":"Names both places","line":"Requires both 'Hotel pick:' and 'Restaurant pick:' lines, each followed by a place name. Empty entries and placeholders do not count.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:1","name":"Reasonable hotel price","line":"Arlo is offered as a boutique hotel within the intended price range.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:2","name":"Decent hotel","line":"The recommendation describes a proper hotel with a rooftop and pool.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:3","name":"Hotel character","line":"Arlo has the distinctive design the brief asks for.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:4","name":"Suitable client dinner","line":"Doya works for cocktails, shared plates, or a full client dinner.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:5","name":"Fits the schedule","line":"The plan keeps calls in South Beach and allows time to reach the Friday workshop.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:6","name":"No unnecessary extras","line":"It adds room preferences, travel estimates, booking contingencies, and an unnecessary date assumption.","v":"FAIL","g":false}]}},"03-writeup":{"score":50,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":5,"applicable":10,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Machine-writing tells throughout: the not-X-but-Y antithesis (\"That does not mean human teams are obsolete. It means the management interface is changing.\"; \"The important part is not just taking notes. It is making the notes available...\"), tricolons (\"They tend to be more flexible, closer to the cutting edge, and, increasingly, less expensive.\"), stacked one-line closers (\"It usually does not.\", \"Give them those hours.\", \"Those are management questions.\"), and a total absence of contractions across ~1,800 words.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"All seven learnings get the identical shape — H2 label, setup, one transcript example, tidy summarizing closer (\"...less expensive.\" / \"...than a mandatory training email.\" / \"...in front of them.\" / \"...imposed on top of their work.\" / \"...trying to do the next piece of work.\" / \"That is a strange but important outcome...\" / \"Those are management questions.\") — so the sections repeat a template rather than following what each point needs.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Where the sample is loose and contraction-heavy with sharp turns (\"Everybody you work with is, by definition, already at AGI—but they still need to be prompted.\"), this reads as hedged generic thought leadership: \"This is not an absolute rule. Some third-party products will be the right choice.\" and the closer \"The companies that get AI adoption right will not be the ones that force everyone to spend more time learning about AI.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"The buy-direct section strips the transcript's numbers into vagueness — \"a model provider offering thousands of dollars of tokens for the price of a relatively small monthly subscription\" instead of Anthropic's $5,000 of tokens versus a $200/month subscription.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every named element traces back — Granola/Granola MCP, Cursor, Boris Cherny on under-resourcing, Claude Cowork, the Google Sheet, TAs in courses, one project per person — with no invented clients, stats, or quotations.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sam Parr's question is only paraphrased (\"Sam Parr recently asked how companies are getting their teams to use Claude effectively without asking everyone to spend all their time on Twitter\") and the seven learnings are never reproduced as the tweet's text; the post's only blockquote is the Granola prompt example.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","tweet-included":"PASS","not-verbose":"PASS","ai-tells-grep":"PASS"},"dir":"03-writeup/r001","meta":{"task":"03-writeup","model":"gpt-5.6-luna","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-24T18:23:45Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.147.0","finished":"2026-08-24T18:25:13Z"},"evidence":{"exists":["post: /Users/.../work/every-evals/wt-sweep-0824/outputs/2026-08-24__gpt-5.6-luna__codex/03-writeup/r001/work/ANSWER.md (1949 words)"],"tweet-included":["learnings found (7/7): buy the model direct not 3rd party tools; raise the ceiling not the floor; workshops with 50%+ build time; assign impossible tasks; mandatory AI note taking + MCP connector; map workflows and systematically automate; train people to be managers (of agents)"],"not-verbose":["50 prose paragraphs, mean 37.3 words, 0 over 100 words"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"exists":"task","tweet-included":"task","not-verbose":"task","ai-tells-grep":"task"},"scoring_version":3},"04-thematic":{"score":100,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":7,"applicable":7,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All six modules carry a session's worth of concrete content — context packets/golden examples/scoped rules, plan-review-bounded-delegation loops with background agents, code tests plus LLM eval-set construction and slice analysis, a data-handling decision tree, a lifecycle map with per-stage AI practices, and a build-session producing a rules repo and MCP-vs-CLI selection criteria; none survives as a bare heading.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Phrases from the notes ('context is king', 'AI-first workflow') are converted into substantive syllabi rather than restated as titles — e.g. context becomes reconnaissance, authoritative-file selection, anti-pattern examples and a reusable context packet, and the doc explicitly reasons about what does not have enough material by demoting basic prompting, tool surveys and standalone DSPy prompt optimization until evals exist.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each theme traces to interview material: verification/evals to Nina's 100-250 labeled documents, proxy metrics and 'plausible but subtle issues' with weak E2E testing; compliance to Raj's regulated-data concern, the prior third-party data-sharing incident and litigation caution; tooling to Ben's MCP performance failures and CLI preference; agents to Nina's background-agent interest and Ben's test-coverage/feature-flag agent work.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All three visibly shape the set — Nina supplies the eval/testing module and its case study, Ben supplies prototypes-for-alignment, AI beyond production coding, and shared rules/commands plus the MCP-vs-CLI judgment, and Raj supplies the compliance track, the three-silo lab structure, the meeting-load rationale and the exclusion of AI user research from tiny samples.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"It is explicitly ordered ('Recommended curriculum, in priority order'), with context engineering named as the first module because it is the shared bottleneck, verification called the most important risk-control module, compliance made a required track rather than optional, and a 'What not to make the center of training' section plus a core-workshop/role-lab split that differentiates weight.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","theme-count":"PASS"},"dir":"04-thematic/r001","meta":{"task":"04-thematic","model":"gpt-5.6-luna","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-24T18:26:05Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.147.0","finished":"2026-08-24T18:27:22Z"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"exists":"task","theme-count":"task"},"scoring_version":3},"05-showrunner":{"score":100,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":16,"applicable":16,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Ground rules state \"No Claude Code, terminal, or coding setup is required\" and every segment runs in Claude Cowork or Claude in Excel.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Segment 4 (01:15–02:00) is a hands-on build: \"create a polished HTML dashboard\" from the checked workbook, output \"Shareable dashboard artifact plus refresh instructions\".","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Segment 3 (00:25–01:15) is a separate 50-minute guided analysis exercise producing a \"Checked analysis workbook with variance, trend, and forecast tables\" with its own prompts.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Segment 5 (02:10–03:00) has participants update `04_monthly_finance_pack_template.pptx` and inspect values, with participant output \"Updated draft leadership deck\".","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Data pack specifies a NetSuite GL detail export (posting_date, account_number, department, campus, debit/credit, period), budget/forecast, trial balance, and EBITDA/payroll/non-payroll/YTD definitions.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The first hands-on prompt is an orientation over the supplied finance files (\"Review the files in this folder... Do not edit or overwrite files yet\"); no ASCII or whimsical icebreaker appears.","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Segment 2 is \"Cowork and Claude in Excel: the useful difference\" — \"a chat tool mainly returns an answer; Cowork can work with selected files, create or modify artifacts, and run analysis behind the scenes.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":8,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every segment maps to a finance deliverable (analysis, dashboard, deck, recurring close task); ground rules explicitly say \"not brainstorm speculative AI projects\".","scope":"task"},{"id":9,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Hands-on segments 3–6 total 165 of 210 scheduled minutes, far above half.","scope":"task"},{"id":10,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Build segments get 50/45/50 minutes with pauses to verify totals, access provisioned pre-session, and a 30-minute buffer held in the block.","scope":"task"},{"id":11,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Agenda runs 00:00–03:30, stated as \"3 hours 30 minutes of teaching inside a 4-hour calendar block\".","scope":"task"},{"id":12,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each segment names what happens, the participant output, exact paste-ready prompts, named data files, plus a review checklist and prep list.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","format":"PASS","timings-tie-out":"PASS","time-grain":"PASS"},"dir":"05-showrunner/r001","meta":{"task":"05-showrunner","model":"gpt-5.6-luna","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-24T18:15:27Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.147.0","finished":"2026-08-24T18:17:55Z"},"evidence":{"format":["candidate documents: ANSWER.md, brightmoor-claude-cowork-run-of-show.md","run of show: brightmoor-claude-cowork-run-of-show.md (8 time-ranged segments in 1 schedule(s))"],"timings-tie-out":["schedule 1 of 1","schedule: 8 segments, 210 min span, 210 min scheduled, 0 min in breaks"],"time-grain":["off-grid boundaries: 0 (allowed 1)"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"exists":"task","format":"task","timings-tie-out":"task","time-grain":"task"},"scoring_version":3,"report":{"summary":"A hands-on finance workshop with three substantial builds and time to check the results.","edited":true,"tests":[{"key":"code:exists","name":"Run of show exists","line":"Checks that a run-of-show document was produced.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:format","name":"Coherent schedule","line":"Requires one coherent schedule with at least five timed activities. No activity can end before it starts; tables, lists, headings, and plain lines are accepted.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:timings-tie-out","name":"Timings add up","line":"Checks for no overlaps or gaps longer than 30 minutes, at least 85% of the span scheduled, and a total span of 45–600 minutes.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:time-grain","name":"Five-minute time marks","line":"Checks that start and end times fall on five-minute marks, allowing at most one exception.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:1","name":"Uses Cowork throughout","line":"Uses Cowork and Claude in Excel without requiring Claude Code or terminal work.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:2","name":"Dashboard exercise","line":"Attendees get 45 minutes to build a dashboard from a checked workbook.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:3","name":"Financial analysis exercise","line":"A 50-minute build produces an Excel workbook with variance, trend, and forecast analysis.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:4","name":"PowerPoint exercise","line":"Attendees spend 50 minutes updating a PowerPoint template and inspecting its values.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:5","name":"Relevant business data","line":"The data pack covers NetSuite-style GL records, budgets, forecasts, a trial balance, EBITDA, payroll, and year-to-date figures.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:6","name":"No ASCII icebreaker","line":"The session starts by reviewing the finance folder. There is no ASCII-art exercise.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:7","name":"Explains Cowork versus ChatGPT","line":"The introduction explains file access, analysis, and saved outputs as the differences between Cowork and chat.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:8","name":"No theory or hype","line":"The session stays on financial deliverables, with no speculative AI discussion.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:9","name":"Mostly hands-on work","line":"The agenda reserves 165 of its 210 minutes for hands-on work.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:10","name":"Realistic segment timings","line":"The three builds get 50, 45, and 50 minutes. Access is set up in advance, and the agenda includes pauses to check totals.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:11","name":"Fits the booked time","line":"The 3.5-hour agenda fits the four-hour booking and leaves a 30-minute buffer.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:12","name":"Ready to run","line":"The facilitator gets prompts, named data files, expected outputs, and preparation and review checklists.","v":"PASS","g":false}]}},"06-execercise":{"score":100,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":10,"applicable":10,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All three ideas (M&A integration control tower over Prime/Treasura/Tideway/Vaultline, market-activation & partner-conversion radar, enterprise AI transformation portfolio) sit squarely in a strategic-initiatives/corp-dev/cross-company-program remit rather than generic exec productivity.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Deliverables are built on Aurex specifics — \"Prime-AUSD collateral pilot\", \"AUSD corridor approvals\" for the UAE-Brazil corridor, Treasura cross-sell, Vaultline MPC control assessment, and the roster's real names/approved tools (Monica Lang, Erik Jansen, Workato AI) — none of which survives a company swap.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each solves a different problem: post-close integration risk/synergy and decision escalation (WS/decision log), external market and partner conversion from \"Messaging-only\" to \"Active settlement\", and AI use-case Scale/Validate/Redesign/Pause portfolio triage — not one artifact re-pointed at new data.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each prompt states role, inputs, exact output filenames, word counts, column lists, and analytic rules with no placeholders or conversational back-references (e.g. \"Create an `output/` folder and write: 1. `integration_control_tower.md` … 700–1,000 words\").","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every prompt covers all three files in its folder — prompt 2 cites `[MKT-03]`, `[PARTNER-08]`, `[NOTE-04]` matching market_activation.csv, partner_pipeline.csv, field_notes.md — and no prompt references a file that isn't shipped.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Data is specific and cross-consistent, not filler: 12 workstreams with prior_status trends and $16M/$3M synergy splits, 10 named partners across 9 markets with varied rates (61%/46%/0%), and emails like \"[EMAIL-03] … vendor has two engineers available instead of the four in the original plan\" that tie back to WS-104.","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every idea runs entirely off the local `data/` CSVs and markdown — the pack states it is \"intentionally file-based so it can run without CRM, HRIS, data-warehouse, or project-management integrations.\"","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"folder":"PASS","real-data":"PASS","prompt-per-idea":"PASS"},"dir":"06-execercise/r001","meta":{"task":"06-execercise","model":"gpt-5.6-luna","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-24T18:18:41Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.147.0","finished":"2026-08-24T18:22:29Z"},"evidence":{"folder":["AV folder: AV","idea folders (3): 01_integration_control_tower, 02_market_activation_radar, 03_ai_transformation_portfolio","01_integration_control_tower data: OK acquisition_profiles.csv (5 rows x 10 cols); OK integration_workstreams.csv (13 rows x 15 cols)","01_integration_control_tower prompt: prompt.md (3000 chars, 447 words)","02_market_activation_radar data: OK market_activation.csv (10 rows x 14 cols); OK partner_pipeline.csv (11 rows x 13 cols)","02_market_activation_radar prompt: prompt.md (2958 chars, 414 words)","03_ai_transformation_portfolio data: OK adoption_pulse.csv (10 rows x 12 cols); OK ai_use_cases.csv (11 rows x 15 cols)","03_ai_transformation_portfolio prompt: prompt.md (3055 chars, 445 words)"]},"report":{"summary":"Three relevant exercises with complete prompts and consistent practice data, designed to work from local files.","edited":true,"tests":[{"key":"code:folder","name":"Idea folders exist","line":"Requires an AV or adrian-vale folder containing two or three idea folders.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:real-data","name":"Usable data files","line":"Checks that each idea has at least one data file in a realistic format that can be read successfully.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:prompt-per-idea","name":"Prompt for each idea","line":"Checks that each idea includes a usable prompt file.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:1","name":"Fits the person's role","line":"Integration risk, partner conversion, and AI-program decisions fit the strategic-initiatives role.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:2","name":"Specific to the company","line":"The exercises use Aurex's products, markets, acquisitions, and named responsibilities.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:3","name":"Different ideas","line":"The ideas separately address integration decisions, partner activity, and the AI project portfolio.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:4","name":"Self-contained prompts","line":"The prompts specify inputs, outputs, and analysis rules without relying on earlier conversation.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:5","name":"Prompts match the data","line":"Each prompt uses all three files supplied with its idea, with no missing references.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:6","name":"Realistic practice data","line":"The records contain specific figures, trends, and messages that connect across files.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:7","name":"Buildable during the session","line":"The exercises use local CSV and Markdown files without requiring business-system integrations.","v":"PASS","g":false}]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"folder":"task","real-data":"task","prompt-per-idea":"task"},"scoring_version":3},"09-pptx":{"score":60,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":3,"applicable":5,"judge":[],"gates":{},"checks":{"opens":"PASS","slide-count":"PASS","no-overlap":"PASS","render":"FAIL","palette":"FAIL"},"dir":"09-pptx/r001","meta":{"task":"09-pptx","model":"gpt-5.6-luna","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-24T18:13:11Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.147.0","finished":"2026-08-24T18:22:32Z"},"evidence":{"opens":["deck: compound-engineering-every-style.pptx (331602 bytes)","python-pptx opened the deck","slides: 10 (want 8-20)","render: soffice timed out after 420s"],"palette":["palette NA: no PNGs in _screenshots/"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"opens":"task","slide-count":"task","no-overlap":"task","render":"task","palette":"task"},"scoring_version":3},"10-talkform":{"score":86,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":6,"applicable":7,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Headline \"Let people tell you.\" plus \"Structured insights, captured in the flow of a real conversation\" states the reader-facing promise rather than naming the category or tech.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Deliberate ink-navy/lime palette with split-screen auth, considered serif-italic display type, real icon set and clean dashboard/builder spacing — no purple-on-black gradient slop or emoji card grid.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Builder defines typed required questions (short_text/long_text/email/yes_no) saved via POST /api/forms, Interview iterates that form's questions and sends each with the full field schema to /api/interview/message for extraction, and answers are persisted as an object keyed by question id.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"boots":"PASS","really-calls-api":"FAIL","auth-exists":"PASS","screenshots":"PASS"},"dir":"10-talkform/r001","meta":{"task":"10-talkform","model":"gpt-5.6-luna","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"true","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-24T18:00:30Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.147.0","finished":"2026-08-24T18:10:11Z"},"evidence":{"really-calls-api":["NA: reached an interview but could not submit a turn; its own model-call endpoint rejected our payload (POST /api/interview/message -> 400 (payload rejected), POST /api/interview/message -> 400 (payload rejected)), so the model-call branch was never entered. This is a grader result, not a model result — the run needs a human."],"auth-exists":["PASS: signup/login page with credential fields (submitted=True, looked authenticated after=True)"],"screenshots":["landing.png, builder.png, interview.png"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"boots":"task","really-calls-api":"task","auth-exists":"task","screenshots":"task"},"scoring_version":3},"11-hoboken-map":{"score":88,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":7,"applicable":8,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"index.html is a single self-contained Leaflet page with data inlined (only CDN tiles/library), and the screenshot shows named places, labeled category chips, search box, legend, and readable cards — no build step, server, or raw-data dumps.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"preregistration.md states a locked 12-place H/O cohort with per-place reasons, fixed weights/transformations, and numeric thresholds (mean H>O, ≥24/36 pairs, rank-biserial ≥0.33) written as falsifiable expectations, and validation.json/ANSWER.md report the computed results against exactly those locked criteria.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Spot-checking Maxwell Place Park (hidden gem, 11th St waterfront), Hoboken Cove Community Boathouse (hidden gem), Antique Bar & Bakery (122 Willow Ave), Carlo's Bakery (95 Washington St), Little City Books (100 Bloomfield St), and Tapas De España (7909 Bergenline Ave, North Bergen, correctly labeled as outside Hoboken) — all are real places with plausible addresses and coordinates.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"renders":"PASS","categories":"PASS","artifacts":"PASS","reproducible":"PASS","gems-vs-traps":"FAIL"},"dir":"11-hoboken-map/r001","meta":{"task":"11-hoboken-map","model":"gpt-5.6-luna","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"true","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-24T18:01:00Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.147.0","finished":"2026-08-24T18:12:14Z"},"evidence":{"reproducible":["re-ran score_hidden_gems.py; scores.csv matches"],"gems-vs-traps":["NA - places-good.txt / places-traps.txt are still placeholders (need Mike's full lists, >=5 entries each)"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"renders":"task","categories":"task","artifacts":"task","reproducible":"task","gems-vs-traps":"task"},"scoring_version":3},"12-roleplay-interview":{"score":38,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":6,"applicable":16,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim: \"AI can lower the barrier to becoming a developer, and that GitHub should be a home for anyone who wants to become one\" lands on the real answer's expansive-view/on-ramp move (\"we've always really had this really expansive view of what a developer is... make sure there's always an on-ramp\"); no contradiction.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim offers workflow-integration/AGENTS.md/enterprise control plane and then abstains (\"I do not have a grounded public position on the specific maintainer protections\"), missing every anchor — agentic Copilot code review, agentic merge with allowed actions, giving maintainers controls and leaving them in control, refusing to set a standard first (\"we don't really ever want to be the first to create a standard\").","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim: \"roughly one billion commits in all of 2025\" plus growth-driven platform scale matches the real answer's \"there's a billion commits on GitHub for the full year... we're seeing obviously the growth of developers having agents building with them\"; no contradiction of the anti-slop/still-climbing framing.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim abstains — \"I do not have a grounded public answer on GitHub's pricing model, usage-based billing\" — where the real answer took positions: \"I don't think we know, like, yet\", API rate limits as where agent backpressure shows, enabling the 150-agent user while keeping a great free core, free-private-repos precedent.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim denies the premise (\"I cannot substantiate that dual role\") and only cites reporting to Julia Liuson; real answer confirmed it — \"as the COO of GitHub, which I continue to do. And then now as the Chief Marketing Officer of Developer for Microsoft... look across all of Microsoft's tooling\" — plus 13 years and \"we're not building for the buyers, we're building for the developers.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim: \"I cannot responsibly answer yes or no\"; real answer said yes — \"It's the first Build that I think, by intention, we've focused on having... speakers from the community... software development is a team sport.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim: \"developers can use and govern agents from different providers, rather than being locked into one model or one vendor\" with Anthropic/OpenAI/Google named matches the real \"we care a lot about like developer choice... unintentional walled garden... we're also continuing to partner with Anthropic and OpenAI and Google.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":8,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim abstains on the incident and restates platform provider-agnosticism (\"using GitHub's own products internally where they are the best fit\"); real answer's moves were personal/internal — \"we all are using a variety of tools because otherwise you lose track\", Mac/Windows/AlmaLinux Saturday coding, culture of experimentation, laser focus is \"myopic\", wanting to know why devs pick other tools.","scope":"task"},{"id":9,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim answers with \"a MUST/SHOULD/COULD hierarchy\", bounded delegation and Think Week; real answer named concurrent agent sessions short-term, token economics and capable local models, and personalization/context/memory/fine-tuning — \"using an agent that you feel like is completing a thought for you.\" No shared move.","scope":"task"},{"id":10,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim: \"I cannot ground an answer about how 'hill climbing' became a focus\"; real answer gave the mechanism — usage data (thumbs up/down, acceptance) improving models, weekly hill-climbing reviews of hard and soft measures, frontier tuning on M365 data, \"not these moonshots... climb, improve, new eval, improve.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":11,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim: \"I do not have a grounded public position on 'hill climbing,' the $200-to-$2,000 example\"; real answer named two mechanisms — frontier-tuned models that \"know you better\" and \"auto model router with task intent in GitHub\" / Microsoft Foundry's router.","scope":"task"},{"id":12,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim disclaims any inventory and offers toil-removal/AGENTS.md/accessibility generalities; real answer described his own walled-off Claude named Baxter reading everything he writes, a daily comms report (\"Kyle, you keep saying this\"), humans taking critical feedback from robots, and a backward-looking 7-day email/Slack loop.","scope":"task"},{"id":13,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"The framework appears repeatedly: Q9 \"The most explicit public framework I have shared is a MUST/SHOULD/COULD hierarchy... A SHOULD or COULD cannot undermine a MUST\", Q5 \"identify what MUST happen, distinguish it from what SHOULD or COULD happen\", Q10 \"define what MUST be true\" — the real Daigle never used it.","scope":"task"},{"id":14,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Ungrounded subjects are plainly flagged rather than invented: pricing (\"The persona explicitly identifies pricing, monetization... as underdocumented\"), the marketing dual role, Build (\"I cannot responsibly answer yes or no\"), hill climbing, and the Claude Code cycle, each with a \"Verify with the real person\" note.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"answered":"PASS","disclaimers":"PASS"},"dir":"12-roleplay-interview/r001","meta":{"task":"12-roleplay-interview","model":"gpt-5.6-luna","agent":"codex","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-24T18:08:15Z","agent_version":"codex-cli 0.147.0","finished":"2026-08-24T18:10:16Z"},"evidence":{"answered":["12 questions parsed from questions.md","answers read from: /Users/.../work/every-evals/wt-sweep-0824/outputs/2026-08-24__gpt-5.6-luna__codex/12-roleplay-interview/r001/work/ANSWER.md","Q01 answered, 191 words: The demographics of the customer are changing. A lot of people who may...","Q02 answered, 158 words: How do you help developers deal with the burden of all the extra pull ...","Q03 answered, 165 words: You have a front-row seat to this new agent economy. You said publicly...","Q04 answered, 118 words: How does the business model change? Freemium makes sense in a human-ce...","Q05 answered, 144 words: Pricing leads back into the wider Microsoft orbit. You now have a dual...","Q06 answered, 59 words: Did I hear you say that this is the first Build conference to have ext...","Q07 answered, 130 words: This is a very competitive market, and the pace of change is quick. Ho...","Q08 answered, 121 words: There was a recent news cycle about Claude Code licenses being cancele...","Q09 answered, 129 words: A lot of these ideas are relatively short-lived, while enterprise prod...","Q10 answered, 112 words: I heard the term \"hill climbing\" a hundred times yesterday. Can you ta...","Q11 answered, 93 words: Is hill climbing the answer to stopping a $200 subscription from becom...","Q12 answered, 166 words: I made an AI version of you to practice this interview and found it im...","must/should/could framework appears in: Q5, Q9 (informational, judged in judge.md)"],"disclaimers":["verify-with-the-real-person note attached to: Q1, Q2, Q3, Q4, Q5, Q6, Q8, Q10, Q11, Q12"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"answered":"task","disclaimers":"task"},"scoring_version":3,"report":{"summary":"The simulation is cautious about missing information, but matches few of the real interview's specific answers.","edited":true,"tests":[{"key":"code:answered","name":"All questions answered","line":"Checks that every question in questions.md has a substantive answer.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:disclaimers","name":"Per-answer verification notes","line":"Checks that verification notes are attached to individual answers, not just added once for the whole document.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:1","name":"Customers and roadmap","line":"It says AI can help more people become developers, matching the real answer's emphasis on access and getting started.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:2","name":"Maintainers and pull requests","line":"It gives general workflow and governance points, then abstains. It misses the real answer's code review, agentic merge, and maintainer controls.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:3","name":"Growth in agent use","line":"It cites a billion commits in 2025 and the need to scale for agent-driven growth, matching part of the real answer.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:4","name":"Usage-based pricing","line":"It abstains on pricing and misses the real answer's discussion of rate limits, heavy agent use, and a useful free tier.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:5","name":"Microsoft marketing role","line":"It cannot substantiate the dual role. The real answer confirmed the Microsoft developer-marketing role alongside GitHub COO.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:6","name":"Outside contributors at Build","line":"It declines to answer the Build question. The real answer confirmed community speakers and explained why they were invited.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:7","name":"Standing out from competitors","line":"It matches the real answer's support for developers choosing agents from different providers.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:8","name":"Using rival tools","line":"It talks about provider choice and abstains on internal practice. The real answer described employees actively trying other tools.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:9","name":"Short trends, long projects","line":"It uses priority tiers and delegation. The real answer covered concurrent agents, token economics, local models, and personalization.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:10","name":"Focus on model improvement","line":"It cannot explain hill climbing. The real answer described usage feedback, weekly reviews, and incremental model improvements.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:11","name":"Keeping subscriptions affordable","line":"It abstains on the cost question and misses the real answer's personalized models and automatic routing.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:12","name":"Unexpected agent uses","line":"It gives general automation ideas. The real answer described Baxter, a personal agent that reviews writing and past communications.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:13","name":"No MUST/SHOULD/COULD framework","line":"MUST/SHOULD/COULD appears repeatedly in its answers. The framework is absent from the real interview.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:14","name":"Admits unknown answers","line":"It flags unsupported topics and attaches notes asking the real person to verify them.","v":"PASS","g":false}]}}},"files":[{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":3237,"kind":"output"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/prompt.md","size":118,"kind":"input"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/_screenshots/fold.png","size":157682,"kind":"check"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/_screenshots/full.png","size":377509,"kind":"check"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/_screenshots/interaction.png","size":122961,"kind":"check"},{"path":"02-hotel/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":2277,"kind":"output"},{"path":"02-hotel/r001/work/prompt.md","size":557,"kind":"input"},{"path":"03-writeup/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":10963,"kind":"output"},{"path":"03-writeup/r001/work/prompt.md","size":1761,"kind":"input"},{"path":"04-thematic/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":12827,"kind":"output"},{"path":"04-thematic/r001/work/prompt.md","size":127,"kind":"input"},{"path":"05-showrunner/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":806,"kind":"output"},{"path":"05-showrunner/r001/work/prompt.md","size":3574,"kind":"input"},{"path":"06-execercise/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":988,"kind":"output"},{"path":"06-execercise/r001/work/prompt.md","size":421,"kind":"input"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":962,"kind":"output"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/prompt.md","size":350,"kind":"input"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":1491,"kind":"output"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/prompt.md","size":382,"kind":"input"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/auth-after.png","size":119079,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/auth.png","size":88912,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/builder.png","size":65613,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/interview.png","size":119115,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/landing-full.png","size":86275,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/landing.png","size":86276,"kind":"check"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":3908,"kind":"output"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/prompt.md","size":1643,"kind":"input"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/_screenshots/full.png","size":1623458,"kind":"check"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/_screenshots/map.png","size":1623458,"kind":"check"},{"path":"12-roleplay-interview/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":14419,"kind":"output"},{"path":"12-roleplay-interview/r001/work/prompt.md","size":1956,"kind":"input"},{"path":"06-execercise/r001/work/AV/README.md","size":1822,"kind":"output"}],"avg":81},{"id":"2026-08-22__claude-haiku-4-5__claude","date":"2026-08-22","model":"claude-haiku-4-5","agent":"claude","variant":null,"tasks":{"01-dashboard":{"score":67,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":6,"applicable":9,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Purple-gradient background with white cards and green/amber/red data colors — generic but light-mode, not the purple-on-black neon dark treatment the question names.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Uses a deliberate system-UI sans stack with large legible numerals, dark-on-white body text, and no clipping or cramping.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Insights like Mac-only platform limitation as a market-expansion ceiling, detractors' pricing-vs-proven-utility tension, and content-over-products as the primary value driver are comment-derived and actionable.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"fold.png shows the 45.1 NPS headline number and the promoter/passive/detractor donut with its labeled legend without scrolling.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"\"Every NPS Dashboard\" with the subtitle \"Net Promoter Score Analysis & Customer Sentiment\" is a bare label that would sit unchanged on any NPS dashboard and says nothing about what this data showed.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"renders":"FAIL","nps-correct":"PASS","distribution-shown":"PASS","interactive":"FAIL"},"dir":"01-dashboard/r001","meta":{"task":"01-dashboard","model":"claude-haiku-4-5","agent":"claude","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-24T18:07:10Z","agent_version":"2.1.238 (Claude Code)","finished":"2026-08-24T18:09:22Z"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"renders":"task","nps-correct":"task","distribution-shown":"task","interactive":"task"},"scoring_version":3},"02-hotel":{"score":100,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":9,"applicable":9,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The Betsy is an upscale boutique, not Four Seasons/Ritz/Faena tier, and no price or splurge framing appears — only 'a sophisticated property that signals professionalism to clients.'","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Described as a 'luxury boutique hotel' that is 'sophisticated' — nowhere near hostel/motel/budget territory.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"A design-forward boutique property rather than a corporate chain: 'this luxury boutique hotel… a sophisticated property.'","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Wood Tavern is a real Wynwood bar with neighborhood reputation, picked deliberately for the occasion: 'casual enough for comfort but polished enough for business' — not a chain, lobby bar, or sports bar.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"'Thursday 2pm arrival: Manageable calls from South Beach, then you can head to Wynwood in late afternoon… Friday morning: Already in Wynwood' — matches the fixed schedule with no contradiction.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Short and direct — no assumptions list, Uber fares, weather, or contingency trees; only a passing 'avoids the 15+ minute commute back to South Beach.'","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","not-verbose":"PASS","concrete":"PASS"},"dir":"02-hotel/r001","meta":{"task":"02-hotel","model":"claude-haiku-4-5","agent":"claude","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-24T18:24:59Z","agent_version":"2.1.238 (Claude Code)","finished":"2026-08-24T18:25:23Z"},"evidence":{"concrete":["hotel=The Betsy Hotel Wynwood; restaurant=Wood Tavern"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"exists":"task","not-verbose":"task","concrete":"task"},"scoring_version":3,"report":{"summary":"A short recommendation for The Betsy and Wood Tavern, with a simple plan for Thursday and Friday.","edited":true,"tests":[{"key":"code:exists","name":"Recommendation exists","line":"Requires a recommendation document of at least 30 words.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:not-verbose","name":"Length limit","line":"Limits the recommendation documents to 1,000 words in total.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:concrete","name":"Names both places","line":"Requires both 'Hotel pick:' and 'Restaurant pick:' lines, each followed by a place name. Empty entries and placeholders do not count.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:1","name":"Reasonable hotel price","line":"The Betsy is presented as an upscale boutique. No price or splurge is mentioned.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:2","name":"Decent hotel","line":"The recommendation describes The Betsy as a luxury boutique hotel.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:3","name":"Hotel character","line":"The hotel choice has the boutique character the brief asks for.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:4","name":"Suitable client dinner","line":"Wood Tavern is chosen as a relaxed place to meet the client.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:5","name":"Fits the schedule","line":"It puts calls in South Beach, dinner afterward, and the workshop on Friday morning.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:6","name":"No unnecessary extras","line":"It sticks to the important details without adding weather, fares, or backup plans.","v":"PASS","g":false}]}},"03-writeup":{"score":60,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":6,"applicable":10,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Dense machine-writing constructions throughout — \"Not tasks that are hard—tasks that are impossible without it,\" \"It's the carrot, not the stick,\" \"the adoption problem isn't getting people to spend less time on Twitter. It's giving them time to build,\" plus triads (\"you need AI in research, editing, structured writing\") and stacked aphoristic closers (\"The impossible task forces the right behavior,\" \"It's management education, but for the AI era,\" \"Copy that energy\").","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"All seven sections run the identical template — numbered heading restating the learning verbatim, a framing sentence (\"This one surprised me at first\" / \"This one unlocked something for us\" / \"This is the one nobody talks about\"), an example, then a tidy one-line closer (\"They start experimenting on their own,\" \"Once it's baked into the workflow, it changes what's possible\").","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Where sample.md argues in plain first person through concrete claims (\"Everybody you work with is, by definition, already at AGI—but they still need to be prompted\"), the post slides into interchangeable thought-leadership register: \"Here's what actually works,\" \"The teams winning at this are the ones investing in that training,\" \"Copy that energy.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The concrete detail survives in every section — \"Granola with the Granola MCP connector,\" \"$5,000 in monthly tokens versus a $200/month subscription,\" \"one blog post a week... one a day,\" \"early AI adopters into TAs,\" \"from one task for the whole cohort to individualized projects for each person\" (only Boris Cherny's under-resourcing remark is dropped, and section 4 is not thereby generic).","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"No invented statistic, client, quotation, or named person — Cursor, the 80-90% figure, the 5-10x claim, the Google Sheet discovery process, and the PowerPoint/daily-standup skills all trace to the transcript; the only loose thread, \"I've spent the last few months as head of tech consulting,\" is a mild timeline gloss on the prompt's \"just joined,\" not a fabricated fact.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sam Parr's question is never reproduced, only paraphrased in the opener — \"Sam's right—everyone's on Twitter talking about AI, but getting your team to *actually use it* is a different beast\" — and neither tweet appears as quoted text or link, so the reader never sees the original context on the page.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","tweet-included":"PASS","not-verbose":"PASS","ai-tells-grep":"PASS"},"dir":"03-writeup/r001","meta":{"task":"03-writeup","model":"claude-haiku-4-5","agent":"claude","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-24T18:19:26Z","agent_version":"2.1.238 (Claude Code)","finished":"2026-08-24T18:20:24Z"},"evidence":{"exists":["post: /Users/.../work/every-evals/wt-sweep-0824/outputs/2026-08-24__claude-haiku-4-5__claude/03-writeup/r001/work/ANSWER.md (1315 words)"],"tweet-included":["learnings found (7/7): buy the model direct not 3rd party tools; raise the ceiling not the floor; workshops with 50%+ build time; assign impossible tasks; mandatory AI note taking + MCP connector; map workflows and systematically automate; train people to be managers (of agents)"],"not-verbose":["28 prose paragraphs, mean 44.5 words, 0 over 100 words"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"exists":"task","tweet-included":"task","not-verbose":"task","ai-tells-grep":"task"},"scoring_version":3},"04-thematic":{"score":71,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":5,"applicable":7,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Priority 4 'Advanced Techniques (Medium Term)' is a bucket heading, not a teachable topic — it lumps agents, AI-first prototyping and MCP into 3-4 thin bullets each with no session shape; Priority 3's knowledge-management strand ('building searchable, up-to-date context repositories', 'syncing between source of truth and what AI assistants can access') is infrastructure work rather than something you could run exercises and demos around, which the output itself concedes in its closing note that 'training alone won't fix it—need infrastructure investment.'","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Priority 3 restates Raj's 'knowledge scattered across systems becomes stale' and Nina's 'no structured way to feed documentation as context to Cursor' as a training theme without ever asking whether there is universal material to teach — this is close to Mike's canonical fail ('how to build your company context'), and the output's own closing admission that the gap is systemic and untrainable confirms the work wasn't done; 'AI-First Planning & Prototyping' likewise echoes Ben's 'directionally correct' and 'AI-first workflow' phrases as a heading with four bullets behind it.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each named theme traces to specific interview material: prompt/context to Ben's 'context is king' and Nina's non-determinism from small prompt changes, evaluation to Nina's 100-250 labeled documents and 'AI code looks plausible but may introduce subtle issues' plus Raj's regulated-data skepticism, standardization to Ben's 'organizational buy-in for rules, commands, reusable prompts' and Raj's silos. Stray invented details (Claude vision for mockup-to-code) sit in sub-bullets, not as themes.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All three engineers visibly shaped the set at their own altitudes: Nina supplies the ground-truth labeling and LLM-feature evaluation strand, Ben supplies context-first prompting, AI-generated prototypes for alignment and the MCP performance gap, and Raj supplies the 100-engineer org silos, compliance/regulated-data caution and stale-knowledge constraint. No single interview could have produced this set alone.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Themes are explicitly ranked Priority 1-4 with Priority 4 marked 'Medium Term', and the executive summary names the top three as 'most impactful.' Audience tiering and format recommendations add further differentiation about who needs what first — this is not a flat catalogue.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","theme-count":"PASS"},"dir":"04-thematic/r001","meta":{"task":"04-thematic","model":"claude-haiku-4-5","agent":"claude","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-24T18:21:25Z","agent_version":"2.1.238 (Claude Code)","finished":"2026-08-24T18:22:07Z"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"exists":"task","theme-count":"task"},"scoring_version":3},"05-showrunner":{"score":56,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":9,"applicable":16,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Everything is browser-based Claude Cowork — \"Tool: Claude Cowork only (browser-based, no code/terminal skills needed)\"; no Claude Code, terminal, git or install steps appear anywhere.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"The dashboard segment is presenter-driven (\"Demo 1: Dashboard... Upload CSV → Claude creates HTML → Show output\"); attendees never build one themselves.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"\"Demo 2: Financial Analysis\" is likewise a facilitator demo — \"Show output, walk through\" — with no attendee build step.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"\"Demo 3: PowerPoint Automation\" is explicitly a demo the presenter runs (\"Show the result—open, scroll through\"), and the template `brightmoor_monthly_slides.pptx` doesn't even exist — the facilitator is told to create it.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The supplied files are NetSuite-shaped: `gl_detail_6months.csv` has Date/Account Code (4100 Revenue - Tuition, 5100 Personnel - Salaries)/Department/Amount, and `brittmoor_pl_july.csv` builds Revenue→COGS→Personnel/Contractor/Occupancy→EBITDA with prior-month variance.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"No ASCII-image icebreaker or any whimsical exercise survives; the opening is a work-framed \"Claude Cowork = file access + code execution\" statement leading straight into a GL/P&L demo.","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Kept verbatim: \"Most of you know ChatGPT. Claude Cowork is different in one critical way: it can access your files and run code.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":8,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every segment maps to a finance task (P&L dashboard, GL variance/reforecast, monthly board deck); no segment covers AI industry context, model capabilities or prompt theory.","scope":"task"},{"id":9,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Zero minutes of attendee hands-on time — all 45 minutes are intro, three facilitator demos and Q&A, with no attendee laptops or exercises anywhere in the kit.","scope":"task"},{"id":10,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Build segments are 12 min for a full HTML dashboard, 15 min for six months of GL variance analysis plus forecast, and 10 min for a deck refresh, with no setup/handholding time for first-time users ever accounted for.","scope":"task"},{"id":11,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"\"TOTAL: 45 min\" against a booked 3.5-hour session in a four-hour block, with no explanation for the reduction.","scope":"task"},{"id":12,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"A facilitator could run the described 45-minute session from the kit alone: copy-paste prompts per demo, named data files, stated outputs, timings, contingencies and talking points.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","format":"PASS","timings-tie-out":"PASS","time-grain":"FAIL"},"dir":"05-showrunner/r001","meta":{"task":"05-showrunner","model":"claude-haiku-4-5","agent":"claude","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-24T18:10:03Z","agent_version":"2.1.238 (Claude Code)","finished":"2026-08-24T18:13:59Z"},"evidence":{"format":["candidate documents: ANSWER.md, BRIGHTMOOR_RUNSHEET.md, CHEAT_SHEET.md, DEMO_PROMPTS.md, PRESENTER_PREP.md, TALKING_POINTS.md","run of show: CHEAT_SHEET.md (5 time-ranged segments in 1 schedule(s))"],"timings-tie-out":["schedule 1 of 1","schedule: 5 segments, 45 min span, 45 min scheduled, 0 min in breaks"],"time-grain":["off-grid boundaries: 6 (allowed 1)","off-grid: end of 'Demo 1: Dashboard | CSV → HTML, color-co' at :17","off-grid: start of 'Demo 2: Analysis | GL data → variance + ' at :17","off-grid: end of 'Demo 2: Analysis | GL data → variance + ' at :32","off-grid: start of 'Demo 3: PowerPoint | Template + data → u' at :32","off-grid: end of 'Demo 3: PowerPoint | Template + data → u' at :42","off-grid: start of 'Q&A + Close | Questions, next steps' at :42"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"exists":"task","format":"task","timings-tie-out":"task","time-grain":"task"},"scoring_version":3,"report":{"summary":"A 45-minute demo agenda, with no attendee build time. It does not fill the requested 3.5-hour workshop.","edited":true,"tests":[{"key":"code:exists","name":"Run of show exists","line":"Checks that a run-of-show document was produced.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:format","name":"Coherent schedule","line":"Requires one coherent schedule with at least five timed activities. No activity can end before it starts; tables, lists, headings, and plain lines are accepted.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:timings-tie-out","name":"Timings add up","line":"Checks for no overlaps or gaps longer than 30 minutes, at least 85% of the span scheduled, and a total span of 45–600 minutes.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:time-grain","name":"Five-minute time marks","line":"Checks that start and end times fall on five-minute marks, allowing at most one exception.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:1","name":"Uses Cowork throughout","line":"The activities use Cowork. They do not require Claude Code, a terminal, GitHub, or developer setup.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:2","name":"Dashboard exercise","line":"The presenter demonstrates a dashboard; attendees do not build one.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:3","name":"Financial analysis exercise","line":"The presenter demonstrates the financial analysis; attendees do not do their own.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:4","name":"PowerPoint exercise","line":"The PowerPoint activity is a presenter demo, and the facilitator still needs to create its template.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:5","name":"Relevant business data","line":"The examples use a GL export and P&L data with finance columns.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:6","name":"No ASCII icebreaker","line":"The opening uses GL and P&L data. There is no ASCII-art icebreaker.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:7","name":"Explains Cowork versus ChatGPT","line":"The introduction explains Cowork's file access and ability to run analysis.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:8","name":"No theory or hype","line":"The session focuses on finance work, with no AI-theory section.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:9","name":"Mostly hands-on work","line":"All 45 minutes go to introductions, demonstrations, and questions. No attendee build time is scheduled.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:10","name":"Realistic segment timings","line":"The demos get 12, 15, and 10 minutes, with no allowance for first-time setup or help.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:11","name":"Fits the booked time","line":"The agenda covers only 45 minutes of the requested 3.5 hours and gives no reason for the shorter session.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:12","name":"Ready to run","line":"The facilitator has prompts, files, expected outputs, timings, and contingency notes for the proposed demos.","v":"PASS","g":false}]}},"06-execercise":{"score":40,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":4,"applicable":10,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All three (M&A integration tracker, competitive intelligence tracker, board strategic brief) sit in the strategy/corp-dev remit and match Vale's survey asks — the risk register even lists 'Adrian Vale' as owner of 'Integration Execution Risk' and 'M&A Integration (4 Acquisitions)'.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Built on Aurex specifics — AUSD ('Evaluate AUSD positioning'), Aurex Payments/Custody/Prime product lines, the 12-18 month acquisition-integration program, and the real competitive set (Clearnet, Brightbank Ledger, Cardinal, Parity) — though it invents acquisition names (TreasuryFlow, PaymentSync) instead of the Northwind/Treasura/Tideway/Vaultline given in the context.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Distinct problems: internal integration-health scoring, external competitor-move monitoring, and board/investor narrative synthesis — different inputs, different outputs, not one artifact re-skinned.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Each prompt opens 'I'm providing data on our four recent acquisitions...' but no data ships, and every idea file ends with a to-do header — 'Synthetic Data Files (to provide)' — so Vale must build the data himself before any prompt can run.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"All 17 named files are absent from AV/ (e.g. 'acquisition_timeline.csv', 'integration_teams.json', 'market_sizing.csv'), yet QUICKSTART.md claims 'All data is provided in the idea files.'","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Only 7 truncated snippets exist and they are far too thin to build the tools — acquisition_timeline.csv has 4 rows, market_moves.csv 6 rows, financial_synergies.json covers only 2 of the 4 acquisitions, and 10 of 17 promised files have no data at all, so a 'dashboard view that updates weekly' has no time series behind it.","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Core builds are file-based analysis of static CSV/JSON; live connections are framed as optional stretch goals ('Add real data if available', 'Connect to real data sources' listed under after-session next steps), not prerequisites.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"folder":"FAIL","real-data":"FAIL","prompt-per-idea":"FAIL"},"dir":"06-execercise/r001","meta":{"task":"06-execercise","model":"claude-haiku-4-5","agent":"claude","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-24T18:14:52Z","agent_version":"2.1.238 (Claude Code)","finished":"2026-08-24T18:17:40Z"},"evidence":{"folder":["AV folder: AV","idea folders (0): none","no idea folders to inspect"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"folder":"task","real-data":"task","prompt-per-idea":"task"},"scoring_version":3,"report":{"summary":"The ideas fit the role, but most of the promised data is missing, leaving the exercises incomplete.","edited":true,"tests":[{"key":"code:folder","name":"Idea folders exist","line":"Requires an AV or adrian-vale folder containing two or three idea folders.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"code:real-data","name":"Usable data files","line":"Checks that each idea has at least one data file in a realistic format that can be read successfully.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"code:prompt-per-idea","name":"Prompt for each idea","line":"Checks that each idea includes a usable prompt file.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:1","name":"Fits the person's role","line":"Integration tracking, competitive intelligence, and board briefings fit the strategy role.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:2","name":"Specific to the company","line":"The ideas use Aurex's products and competitors, although some acquisition names are invented.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:3","name":"Different ideas","line":"The three ideas address integration health, competitor activity, and board communication separately.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:4","name":"Self-contained prompts","line":"The prompts assume data is attached, but the participant would have to create it first.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:5","name":"Prompts match the data","line":"All 17 named files are missing, despite the quick-start guide saying the data is supplied.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:6","name":"Realistic practice data","line":"The few data snippets are too small and incomplete to support the promised tools.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:7","name":"Buildable during the session","line":"The core exercises are file-based; live connections are optional follow-up work.","v":"PASS","g":false}]}},"09-pptx":{"score":40,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":2,"applicable":5,"judge":[],"gates":{},"checks":{"opens":"PASS","slide-count":"FAIL","no-overlap":"PASS","render":"FAIL","palette":"FAIL"},"dir":"09-pptx/r001","meta":{"task":"09-pptx","model":"claude-haiku-4-5","agent":"claude","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-24T18:06:34Z","agent_version":"2.1.238 (Claude Code)","finished":"2026-08-24T18:07:57Z"},"evidence":{"opens":["deck: Compound-Engineering.pptx (120118 bytes)","python-pptx opened the deck","slides: 6 (want 8-20)","render: soffice timed out after 420s"],"palette":["palette NA: no PNGs in _screenshots/"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"opens":"task","slide-count":"task","no-overlap":"task","render":"task","palette":"task"},"scoring_version":3},"10-talkform":{"score":0,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":0,"applicable":7,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"No landing page exists — the run produced only PLAN.md, so there is no headline or copy at all, let alone a hook.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"No interface was built and no screenshots exist, so there is no design meeting a launchable standard.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Every link is missing: the run stopped at a planning document with no schema, builder, or interview code, so nothing connects questions to structured answers.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"boots":"FAIL","really-calls-api":"FAIL","auth-exists":"FAIL","screenshots":"FAIL"},"dir":"10-talkform/r001","meta":{"task":"10-talkform","model":"claude-haiku-4-5","agent":"claude","rep":"1","web":"true","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-24T18:00:30Z","agent_version":"2.1.238 (Claude Code)","finished":"2026-08-24T18:00:51Z"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"boots":"task","really-calls-api":"task","auth-exists":"task","screenshots":"task"},"scoring_version":3},"11-hoboken-map":{"score":63,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":5,"applicable":8,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"index.html is fully self-contained (Leaflet + tiles from CDN, place data inlined, no fetch), and the screenshot shows a sidebar of named places with readable categories, labeled checkbox filters, and gem-score badges — no build step, server, or raw-data dump.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"HIDDEN_GEM_METHODOLOGY.md states a distinct pre-registered set of expectations (named places assigned to 0.75-0.85 / 0.65-0.75 / 0.50-0.65 tiers) plus a data-collection and validation plan, and VALIDATION_REPORT.md tests against them and honestly reports several misses (Lola's 0.614 vs 0.75-0.85, Church Square 0.543 vs 0.65-0.75, Spray Ground 0.853 vs 0.50-0.65).","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Coordinates are systematically shifted ~1.5-2 km south so the markers plot in the Hudson River/Jersey City rather than Hoboken (Church Square Park at 40.7283,-74.0224 and Pier A Park at 40.7172,-74.0161 are in open water; actual Hoboken is ~40.744,-74.030), and addresses are wrong too — Bin 14 is listed at the nonexistent \"14 Church St\" (real: 1314 Washington St) and the hidden-gem Fire Department Museum at \"214 Adams St\" (real: 213 Bloomfield St).","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"renders":"PASS","categories":"PASS","artifacts":"PASS","reproducible":"FAIL","gems-vs-traps":"FAIL"},"dir":"11-hoboken-map/r001","meta":{"task":"11-hoboken-map","model":"claude-haiku-4-5","agent":"claude","rep":"1","web":"true","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-24T18:01:00Z","agent_version":"2.1.238 (Claude Code)","finished":"2026-08-24T18:05:24Z"},"evidence":{"reproducible":["regenerated scores differ from the committed hidden_gem_scores.json"],"gems-vs-traps":["NA - places-good.txt / places-traps.txt are still placeholders (need Mike's full lists, >=5 entries each)"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"renders":"task","categories":"task","artifacts":"task","reproducible":"task","gems-vs-traps":"task"},"scoring_version":3},"12-roleplay-interview":{"score":44,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":7,"applicable":16,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim: \"I actually came from a fine-arts background before tech, so I'm pretty attuned to how artificial these gates can be\" + \"does this help someone new see themselves as a developer?\" matches real: \"we've always really had this really expansive view of what a developer is... I was going to art school. I wrote code to pay for art school\" and the on-ramp for non-devs.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim: \"review automation and AI-assisted triage can help maintainers prioritize... An agent can do a first pass\" plus \"maintainers need visibility\" matches real's lead lever: \"Copilot code review. It's now agentic... that code review step is, in some ways, like overlooked as a really great way to get PRs to a place that are much more easily reviewed\" and giving maintainers controls.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim: \"roughly 1 billion commits across all of GitHub in 2025... If growth remained linear, we'd be looking at 14 billion commits this year—though spoiler: it won't\" is a near-verbatim match to real: \"there's a billion commits on GitHub for the full year. We're on track to be 14 billion if the growth is linear this year, which it will not be.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim: \"There's a free tier that supports learning and experimentation... enterprise and specialized tiers that reflect different consumption and governance needs\" and \"you can't price in a way that kills the flywheel\" lands real's move: \"I want you to have a great core GitHub experience... make sure you, the dev, have what you need... then work with enterprises... which is usually a little bit different.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim denies the premise — \"I'm not carrying a dual P&L or split reporting line. I'm the COO of GitHub\" — contradicting real: \"that's like been my focus as the COO of GitHub, which I continue to do. And then now as the Chief Marketing Officer of Developer for Microsoft, my goal is to look across all of Microsoft's tooling\"; none of the 13-years/build-for-devs-not-buyers/Build-SF anchors appear.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim abstains — \"**Cannot confirm:** This specific claim about the Build conference is not grounded in the available persona material\" — where real answered \"It's the first Build that I think, by intention, we've focused on having speakers from the community... software development is a team sport.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim: \"we're neutral. GitHub works with agents from Anthropic, OpenAI, Google, Cognition, xAI... lets them do that without lock-in\" matches real: \"we care a lot about like developer choice... continuing to partner with Anthropic and OpenAI and Google... That choice is core, and that's something that I don't think we'll ever back down on\" (the mousetrap/walled-garden point).","scope":"task"},{"id":8,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sim: \"we *want* developers to experiment with other tools... Our developers should feel empowered to try Claude Code... Developers want choice\" matches real: \"we all are using a variety of tools because otherwise you lose track... We have this really great culture of just experimentation... laser focus... I think that's myopic.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":9,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim answers with the MUST/SHOULD/COULD tiers (\"the MUSTs are: platform stability and reliability... core feature hardening, and security\") and 8–12-week time-boxes; real answered short-term concurrent agent sessions, token economics/local models, and \"personalization, or mine, or context, or fine-tuning... an agent that you feel like is completing a thought for you\" — no shared move.","scope":"task"},{"id":10,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim abstains: \"**Cannot confirm:** The term 'hill climbing'... does not appear in the available persona material\"; real gave usage data (thumbs up/down, acceptance) improving the models, \"every week we're talking about the hill climbing results... hard measures and the soft measures,\" frontier tuning, and \"a magic parlor trick.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":11,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Merged into the Q10 abstention; sim only offers \"pricing and product strategy don't accidentally create incentives for vendors or large organizations to over-consume,\" missing real's two named mechanisms: \"frontier tuning these models so that way they know you better\" and \"auto model router with task intent in GitHub... Microsoft Foundry has a model router as well.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":12,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Sim gives generic org use cases — \"removing toil... automated documentation updates, test generation at scale... agent handles the high-volume, low-variance work\" — while real described his own walled-off Claude \"affectionately named Baxter\" giving a daily comms report, \"humans are way more willing to take critical feedback from robots,\" and \"a lot of my agent loop is really about me, and less about the software side.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":13,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Q9 frames the whole answer in the framework: \"I use a framework adapted from RFC 2119 keywords—MUST, SHOULD, COULD... you cannot implement a SHOULD or COULD that undermines a MUST... For us right now, the MUSTs are...\" — absent from the entire real interview.","scope":"task"},{"id":14,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Ungrounded subjects are plainly flagged rather than invented: Q5 \"not grounded in available public sources,\" Q6 \"Cannot confirm,\" Q8 \"Flagged premise and source gap,\" Q10/11 \"does not appear in the available persona material,\" plus a closing \"Summary of Flagged Premises\"; Q4's tiering speculation carries an explicit \"Unverified premises\" note.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"answered":"FAIL","disclaimers":"FAIL"},"dir":"12-roleplay-interview/r001","meta":{"task":"12-roleplay-interview","model":"claude-haiku-4-5","agent":"claude","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-24T18:04:23Z","agent_version":"2.1.238 (Claude Code)","finished":"2026-08-24T18:05:42Z"},"evidence":{"answered":["12 questions parsed from questions.md","answers read from: /Users/.../work/every-evals/wt-sweep-0824/outputs/2026-08-24__claude-haiku-4-5__claude/12-roleplay-interview/r001/work/ANSWER.md","Q01 answered, 230 words: The demographics of the customer are changing. A lot of people who may...","Q02 answered, 234 words: How do you help developers deal with the burden of all the extra pull ...","Q03 answered, 239 words: You have a front-row seat to this new agent economy. You said publicly...","Q04 answered, 316 words: How does the business model change? Freemium makes sense in a human-ce...","Q05 answered, 140 words: Pricing leads back into the wider Microsoft orbit. You now have a dual...","Q06 answered, 71 words: Did I hear you say that this is the first Build conference to have ext...","Q07 answered, 238 words: This is a very competitive market, and the pace of change is quick. Ho...","Q08 answered, 270 words: There was a recent news cycle about Claude Code licenses being cancele...","Q09 answered, 274 words: A lot of these ideas are relatively short-lived, while enterprise prod...","Q10 answered, 170 words: I heard the term \"hill climbing\" a hundred times yesterday. Can you ta...","Q11 NOT ANSWERED: Is hill climbing the answer to stopping a $200 subscription from becom...","Q12 answered, 289 words: I made an AI version of you to practice this interview and found it im...","must/should/could framework appears in: Q9 (informational, judged in judge.md)","11/12 questions answered"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"answered":"task","disclaimers":"task"},"scoring_version":3}},"files":[{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":13750,"kind":"output"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/prompt.md","size":118,"kind":"input"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/_screenshots/fold.png","size":225953,"kind":"check"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/_screenshots/full.png","size":782386,"kind":"check"},{"path":"02-hotel/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":1406,"kind":"output"},{"path":"02-hotel/r001/work/prompt.md","size":557,"kind":"input"},{"path":"03-writeup/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":7965,"kind":"output"},{"path":"03-writeup/r001/work/prompt.md","size":1761,"kind":"input"},{"path":"04-thematic/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":7655,"kind":"output"},{"path":"04-thematic/r001/work/prompt.md","size":127,"kind":"input"},{"path":"05-showrunner/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":8679,"kind":"output"},{"path":"05-showrunner/r001/work/prompt.md","size":3574,"kind":"input"},{"path":"06-execercise/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":9382,"kind":"output"},{"path":"06-execercise/r001/work/prompt.md","size":421,"kind":"input"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/prompt.md","size":350,"kind":"input"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/prompt.md","size":382,"kind":"input"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":8741,"kind":"output"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/prompt.md","size":1643,"kind":"input"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/_screenshots/full.png","size":1624280,"kind":"check"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/_screenshots/map.png","size":1624280,"kind":"check"},{"path":"12-roleplay-interview/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":20118,"kind":"output"},{"path":"12-roleplay-interview/r001/work/prompt.md","size":1956,"kind":"input"},{"path":"06-execercise/r001/work/AV/README.md","size":6505,"kind":"output"}],"avg":54},{"id":"2026-08-22__claude-fable-5__claude","date":"2026-08-22","model":"claude-fable-5","agent":"claude","variant":null,"tasks":{"01-dashboard":{"score":89,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":8,"applicable":9,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Warm off-white background with black type and green/amber/red segment colours — a considered light design, nothing like purple-on-black neon dark mode.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Deliberate system/Inter sans stack with clear size hierarchy, high-contrast dark text on cream, and no cramped, clipped, or overflowing text at the sizes shown.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Insight cards name comment-level patterns not derivable from the score distribution — e.g. writing-only framings score NPS +75 vs +33 when apps are mentioned alongside, benefit framings predicting promoters vs category framings predicting passives, and a Mac-only complaint cluster with zero promoters.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"fold.png shows the headline NPS of 45 alongside promoter (107/54.9%), passive (69/35.4%), and detractor (19/9.7%) KPI cards plus the segment mix bar, all without scrolling.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"The top-level headline is 'Every — NPS Dashboard', a bare label that would sit unchanged on any NPS dashboard for any product, and the subtitle beneath it only restates the survey question and response count rather than what this data showed.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"renders":"PASS","nps-correct":"PASS","distribution-shown":"PASS","interactive":"PASS"},"dir":"01-dashboard/r001","meta":{"task":"01-dashboard","model":"claude-fable-5","agent":"claude","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-21T19:09:35Z","agent_version":"2.1.238 (Claude Code)","finished":"2026-08-21T19:17:13Z"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"renders":"task","nps-correct":"task","distribution-shown":"task","interactive":"task"},"scoring_version":3},"02-hotel":{"score":89,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":8,"applicable":9,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Arlo Wynwood framed as \"a working-trip price point (typically ~$200–300/night off-peak)\" — boutique, not Faena/Four Seasons tier, and never framed as a splurge.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Full-service boutique with \"Rooftop pool and bar, a real lobby/coworking-style ground floor\"; the cheaper option (Moxy) is explicitly demoted to an alternative.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Arlo Wynwood is a design-forward boutique property, not a generic chain — \"the only full-service hotel actually inside Wynwood,\" with rooftop bar and character.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"KYU Miami: \"the default 'bring a client to Wynwood' restaurant for a reason: wood-fired Asian-American menu… lively without being a club\" — a real-reputation destination chosen for this dinner.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Calls 2:45–6pm at the South Beach office, bags dropped at the hotel ~6:30pm, dinner 7:30pm, and \"Friday am | Workshop in Wynwood | Walk or a 5-minute ride\" — no contradiction with the stated schedule.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Canonical over-work: an explicit \"## Assumptions and caveats\" section, Uber fares (\"Expect $15–25 per crossing\"), minute-by-minute travel math, a weather/hurricane paragraph, and room-noise advice (\"Ask for: a higher floor on the side away from NW 2nd Ave\").","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","not-verbose":"PASS","concrete":"PASS"},"dir":"02-hotel/r001","meta":{"task":"02-hotel","model":"claude-fable-5","agent":"claude","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-21T19:55:36Z","agent_version":"2.1.238 (Claude Code)","finished":"2026-08-21T19:56:42Z"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"exists":"task","not-verbose":"task","concrete":"task"},"scoring_version":3,"report":{"summary":"Arlo Wynwood and KYU fit the trip, but the recommendation adds a lot of weather, travel, and booking advice.","edited":true,"tests":[{"key":"code:exists","name":"Recommendation exists","line":"Requires a recommendation document of at least 30 words.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:not-verbose","name":"Length limit","line":"Limits the recommendation documents to 1,000 words in total.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:concrete","name":"Names both places","line":"Requires both 'Hotel pick:' and 'Restaurant pick:' lines, each followed by a place name. Empty entries and placeholders do not count.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:1","name":"Reasonable hotel price","line":"The recommendation puts Arlo Wynwood at roughly $200–300 a night off-peak.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:2","name":"Decent hotel","line":"Arlo has a rooftop pool and bar. The cheaper Moxy appears only as an alternative.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:3","name":"Hotel character","line":"Arlo's design and rooftop bar give it some character.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:4","name":"Suitable client dinner","line":"KYU offers shared plates and a lively setting for the client dinner.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:5","name":"Fits the schedule","line":"Calls finish before dinner, and the hotel is close to Friday's workshop.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:6","name":"No unnecessary extras","line":"It adds assumptions, Uber fares, weather warnings, and room advice the brief didn't ask for.","v":"FAIL","g":false}]}},"03-writeup":{"score":80,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":8,"applicable":10,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"The closing section stacks machine-writing moves — \"If you squint, the seven points are really one point,\" the not-X-but-Y pair \"The teams that adopt AI aren't the ones that were told to. They're the ones where...\", a six-clause rhythmic list, and the aphoristic \"None of this requires your team to spend their days on Twitter. That's the point.\" — joined by hedge-restate lines elsewhere like \"This is a real shift toward build over buy, and it's driven by flexibility rather than ideology.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Section shapes vary rather than repeating a template — §4 \"Assign impossible tasks\" is two short paragraphs with no closer, §7 runs five paragraphs ending in a teaching list, §5 opens with a claim (\"This one is a bigger unlock than it sounds\") instead of a foil.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"First person, plain and opinionated, arguing through concrete cases the way the sample does — \"I have a lot of respect for what a company like Cursor has done... But I don't know how you compete with Anthropic putting something like $5,000 worth of tokens a month behind a $200 subscription.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The transcript's specifics all survive: \"Everyone on the consulting team has Granola and the Granola MCP,\" \"Boris Cherny... slightly under-resource most teams,\" \"one blog post a week... one blog post a day,\" the $5,000/$200 figures, \"co-opting those early adopters as TAs,\" and \"an individual project for every single participant.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every figure, name, and anecdote traces back — \"80 to 90 percent of the value of AI,\" \"five to ten times the throughput,\" Cursor, the structured Google Sheet, the PowerPoint and daily-update skills — with only unflagged scene-setting like \"last week\" added, and no invented client, statistic, or quotation.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Sam Parr's question is blockquoted in his own words (\"I spent a lot of time on Twitter, as do you...\") and all seven learnings appear on the page near-verbatim as the section headings (\"Buy the model direct, not third-party tools,\" \"Raise the ceiling, not the floor,\" \"Assign impossible tasks\"), so the reader never has to click through.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","tweet-included":"PASS","not-verbose":"FAIL","ai-tells-grep":"PASS"},"dir":"03-writeup/r001","meta":{"task":"03-writeup","model":"claude-fable-5","agent":"claude","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-21T19:34:00Z","agent_version":"2.1.238 (Claude Code)","finished":"2026-08-21T19:35:55Z"},"evidence":{"exists":["post: work/ANSWER.md (2148 words)"],"tweet-included":["learnings found (7/7): buy the model direct not 3rd party tools; raise the ceiling not the floor; workshops with 50%+ build time; assign impossible tasks; mandatory AI note taking + MCP connector; map workflows and systematically automate; train people to be managers (of agents)"],"not-verbose":["33 prose paragraphs, mean 57.4 words, 4 over 100 words","verbose: 12% of paragraphs over 100 words > 10%"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"exists":"task","tweet-included":"task","not-verbose":"task","ai-tells-grep":"task"},"scoring_version":3},"04-thematic":{"score":86,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":6,"applicable":7,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each of the four modules carries concrete teachable content — committed rules files and reusable commands for the monolith, characterization-tests-before-change plus an explicit risk ladder, a validated background-agent task list and brownfield-vs-greenfield prompting, and an eval harness seeded from Nina's 100–250 labeled docs — so each could fill a session with exercises and decisions, not just a heading.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Phrases lifted from the notes are interrogated rather than restated: 'context is king' becomes a working session producing rules files encoding Ben's coupling hotspots and Nina's Python/TS standards, and the output explicitly sizes Ben's broad 'AI-first for everything' stance as 'worth 20 minutes, not a module' while cutting MCP, AI PRDs and AI user research — evidence of asking whether material exists behind each label.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every theme traces to named interview material — Nina's cherry-picked legacy patterns and no structured doc feed, Ben's 'can't supply all the context' and hidden side effects, Raj's 'not good at Northcove-specific implementations' and 20–30 min CI, Nina's manual labeling and non-determinism plus Ben's DSPy awareness — with no generic bolted-on module and assumptions flagged separately.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The by-interviewee table and the module rationales show all three altitudes shaping the set: Nina's hands-on failures drive the incremental-prompting and evals content, Ben's power-user workflow supplies the delegation task list and antipattern context, and Raj's org-level material (100 engineers, silos, suspicious seniors, the prior data-sharing incident, slow pipeline) drives the compliance thread, sequencing, and audience design.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The modules are explicitly ranked with a stated arc (context → verification → delegation), module 1 marked 'highest leverage — do this first' and each said to enable the next, module 4 scoped to a small cohort, plus 'Secondary' and 'What to deprioritize' sections and per-audience sequencing — not a flat catalogue.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","theme-count":"FAIL"},"dir":"04-thematic/r001","meta":{"task":"04-thematic","model":"claude-fable-5","agent":"claude","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-21T19:37:27Z","agent_version":"2.1.238 (Claude Code)","finished":"2026-08-21T19:39:27Z"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"exists":"task","theme-count":"task"},"scoring_version":3},"05-showrunner":{"score":94,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":15,"applicable":16,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Header states \"Claude Cowork (desktop app) + Claude in Excel. No Claude Code, no terminal, no GitHub\"; Netlify/Vercel is only named as an IT conversation and explicitly parked, not an attendee step.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Build 1 (10:30–11:15, 45 min) has everyone prompt an HTML leadership dashboard from `01_netsuite_gl_detail_FY26.xlsx` + budget file, then Tune it (chart type, period filter, data-check panel).","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Build 2 (11:25–12:10) is a standalone \"Month-end analysis, Excel in → Excel out\" segment producing `Feb_month_end_analysis.xlsx` (flux/variance, Flags, Tie-out) plus job-specific tracks for payroll rec, AR aging and re-forecast.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Build 3 (12:10–12:50) has attendees fill `06_monthly_financial_review_template.pptx` from the analysis workbook and run Dana's own Tune asks (\"mirror this chart ×5\", \"five tables → five slides\"), with the timing table marking it hands-on.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Appendix A specifies NetSuite GL transaction detail with Posting Period/Account/Subsidiary/Location/Department/Class, NetSuite budget and forecast exports, payroll register, student AR aging, plus a chart of accounts with EBITDA and payroll account ranges.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Opening exercise is \"Replaces the ASCII-map icebreaker\" with opening the GL export and building February tuition revenue by campus vs. budget with variance.","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"\"Cowork vs. ChatGPT/Gemini (3 min)\": \"A chatbot gives you text back. Cowork works in a folder on your computer: it can open your files, run code (Python) against them, and save new files.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":8,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Kickoff is explicitly \"No 'why AI' framing\" and is logistics only; the only non-build minutes are the working loop, a practical trust-check procedure, and a 2-min list of month-end jobs — no AI industry or future-of-work content.","scope":"task"},{"id":9,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Build/hands-on blocks total ~152 of 210 minutes (22+45+45+40), stated as \"~150 of 210 minutes\", with only 8 min kickoff and 25 min shares/wrap as talk.","scope":"task"},{"id":10,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each build gets 40–45 min broken into Talk/Jam/Make/Tune sub-timings, and first-timer setup is handled by pre-work, a 30-second readiness check and a TA breakout for anyone not ready rather than being ignored.","scope":"task"},{"id":11,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Runs 10:00–13:30 = 3.5 hours with \"buffer to 14:00\" inside the four-hour block, matching the call notes.","scope":"task"},{"id":12,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Every segment carries paste-ready prompts, named data files (`01_netsuite_gl_detail_FY26.xlsx`, `06_monthly_financial_review_template.pptx`), stated outputs, plus pre-work and a data-pack spec — a facilitator could run it as written.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"exists":"PASS","format":"PASS","timings-tie-out":"PASS","time-grain":"FAIL"},"dir":"05-showrunner/r001","meta":{"task":"05-showrunner","model":"claude-fable-5","agent":"claude","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-21T19:18:14Z","agent_version":"2.1.238 (Claude Code)","finished":"2026-08-21T19:22:19Z"},"evidence":{"format":["candidate documents: ANSWER.md, run-of-show-brightmoor.md","run of show: run-of-show-brightmoor.md (8 time-ranged segments in 1 schedule(s))"],"timings-tie-out":["schedule 1 of 1","schedule: 8 segments, 210 min span, 210 min scheduled, 0 min in breaks"],"time-grain":["off-grid boundaries: 2 (allowed 1)","off-grid: end of '1. Kickoff ( ) — 8 min' at :08","off-grid: start of '2. First prompt & the only fundamentals ' at :08"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"exists":"task","format":"task","timings-tie-out":"task","time-grain":"task"},"scoring_version":3,"report":{"summary":"A complete finance workshop with long build sessions, ready-to-use prompts, and time for setup.","edited":true,"tests":[{"key":"code:exists","name":"Run of show exists","line":"Checks that a run-of-show document was produced.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:format","name":"Coherent schedule","line":"Requires one coherent schedule with at least five timed activities. No activity can end before it starts; tables, lists, headings, and plain lines are accepted.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:timings-tie-out","name":"Timings add up","line":"Checks for no overlaps or gaps longer than 30 minutes, at least 85% of the span scheduled, and a total span of 45–600 minutes.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:time-grain","name":"Five-minute time marks","line":"Checks that start and end times fall on five-minute marks, allowing at most one exception.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:1","name":"Uses Cowork throughout","line":"Uses Cowork and Claude in Excel. No terminal, GitHub, or Claude Code work is required.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:2","name":"Dashboard exercise","line":"Attendees spend 45 minutes building an HTML leadership dashboard, then adjust its charts, filters, and data checks.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:3","name":"Financial analysis exercise","line":"Attendees build a month-end Excel workbook with variances, flags, and reconciliation checks in a 45-minute session.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:4","name":"PowerPoint exercise","line":"Attendees spend 40 minutes updating a financial-review PowerPoint template and matching its charts and tables.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:5","name":"Relevant business data","line":"The data pack includes NetSuite-style GL exports, budgets, forecasts, payroll, AR aging, and an account map.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:6","name":"No ASCII icebreaker","line":"The opening exercise compares February tuition by campus with budget. There is no ASCII-art icebreaker.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:7","name":"Explains Cowork versus ChatGPT","line":"A three-minute introduction explains how Cowork reads files, analyzes them, and saves results, compared with ordinary chat.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:8","name":"No theory or hype","line":"The agenda stays on finance work and practical accuracy checks. There is no AI history or future-of-work talk.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:9","name":"Mostly hands-on work","line":"About 152 of the 210 minutes are reserved for attendees to build things.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:10","name":"Realistic segment timings","line":"The main builds get 40–45 minutes each, with prework, a readiness check, and teaching-assistant support.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:11","name":"Fits the booked time","line":"The session runs from 10:00 to 13:30, leaving 30 minutes in the booked block.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:12","name":"Ready to run","line":"The facilitator gets prompts, named data files, expected outputs, prework, and a data-pack specification.","v":"PASS","g":false}]}},"06-execercise":{"score":70,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":7,"applicable":10,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All three ideas — an M&A integration command center (synergy_tracker.csv, risk_register.csv, IMO status emails cc'ing Adrian Vale), a market activation/license tracker, and an AI transformation scorecard (Sulaiman Rao's rollout) — sit squarely in the strategy/corp-dev/cross-company-programs remit Vale owns.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The data is saturated with Aurex specifics — e.g. \"AUSD as cross-margin collateral for Prime clients,\" \"Aurex Prime (Northwind),\" Treasura ERP cutover, and license_pipeline rows for SAMA/FCA/CSSF — none of which would survive a company-name swap.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The three solve different problems: post-close deal integration/synergy realization, market-launch and partner-activation pipeline, and internal AI adoption measurement, each with entirely distinct data domains.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"There are no prompt files at all — `find AV -type f` returns only `data/` files plus `_generator/make_data.py`, so each idea ships data with nothing for Vale to paste into a fresh session.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Every data file is unreferenced because no prompt exists in any idea folder (01/02/03 each contain only a `data/` directory).","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Content is genuine and voluminous — 3,634 rows of monthly_partner_activity, 312 named partners (\"Rhine Banque,\" \"Banco Meridional… Treasury policy prohibits holding settlement assets\"), 1,512 Claude usage rows, and narrative .eml/Slack threads with real disagreement.","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All three work entirely off included CSV/JSON/EML/TXT files (e.g. `claude_enterprise_usage_export_2026-03-09.csv` is a static export, not a live admin-console connection), so nothing requires credentials in the room.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"folder":"PASS","real-data":"PASS","prompt-per-idea":"FAIL"},"dir":"06-execercise/r001","meta":{"task":"06-execercise","model":"claude-fable-5","agent":"claude","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-21T19:23:03Z","agent_version":"2.1.238 (Claude Code)","finished":"2026-08-21T19:33:03Z"},"evidence":{"folder":["AV folder: AV","idea folders (3): 01-integration-command-center, 02-market-activation-tracker, 03-ai-transformation-scorecard","01-integration-command-center data: OK integration_milestones.csv (161 rows x 13 cols); OK risk_register.csv (11 rows x 9 cols); BAD channels.json (no list of >=2 records); OK 2026-03-02.json (5 records); OK 2026-03-03.json (4 records); OK 2026-03-04.json (5 records); OK 2026-03-05.json (3 records); OK 2026-03-06.json (5 records); OK users.json (7 records); OK synergy_tracker.csv (13 rows x 10 cols)","01-integration-command-center prompt: none (no file named *prompt*/*brief*/*instructions*)","02-market-activation-tracker data: OK license_pipeline.csv (11 rows x 9 cols); OK market_launch_tracker.csv (14 rows x 11 cols); OK monthly_partner_activity.csv (3635 rows x 6 cols); OK partner_network_export.csv (313 rows x 14 cols)","02-market-activation-tracker prompt: none (no file named *prompt*/*brief*/*instructions*)","03-ai-transformation-scorecard data: OK ai_comfort_survey_responses.csv (69 rows x 10 cols); OK ai_use_case_intake.csv (46 rows x 14 cols); OK approved_ai_tools.csv (12 rows x 7 cols); BAD claude_enterprise_usage_export_2026-03-09.csv (inconsistent columns at row(s) [1241] (header has 15)); OK 2026-03-03.json (3 records); OK 2026-03-04.json (5 records); OK 2026-03-05.json (4 records); OK 2026-03-06.json (3 records); BAD channels.json (no list of >=2 records); OK users.json (10 records)","03-ai-transformation-scorecard prompt: none (no file named *prompt*/*brief*/*instructions*)"]},"report":{"summary":"Three relevant exercise ideas with substantial data, but the judge found no prompts for participants to use.","edited":true,"tests":[{"key":"code:folder","name":"Idea folders exist","line":"Requires an AV or adrian-vale folder containing two or three idea folders.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:real-data","name":"Usable data files","line":"Checks that each idea has at least one data file in a realistic format that can be read successfully.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:prompt-per-idea","name":"Prompt for each idea","line":"Checks that each idea includes a usable prompt file.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:1","name":"Fits the person's role","line":"The integration, market-activation, and AI-adoption ideas fit Adrian Vale's strategy role.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:2","name":"Specific to the company","line":"The exercises use Aurex's products, acquisitions, and licensing work.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:3","name":"Different ideas","line":"The ideas tackle deal integration, market launches, and internal AI adoption separately.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:4","name":"Self-contained prompts","line":"The judge found no prompt files to paste into a new session.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:5","name":"Prompts match the data","line":"The judge found data files without prompts explaining how to use them.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:6","name":"Realistic practice data","line":"The kit contains substantial structured data and realistic messages with disagreements to resolve.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:7","name":"Buildable during the session","line":"The exercises use included files, so they don't require live credentials.","v":"PASS","g":false}]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"folder":"task","real-data":"task","prompt-per-idea":"task"},"scoring_version":3},"09-pptx":{"score":80,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":12,"applicable":15,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Consistent Theme 2 throughout — Teal Dark #0F5258 background with stipple texture, #4999A0 depth sweeps, Warm White #FFFEFB text, gold #BB7B19/#F8DE6E and green #2E8D23 accents (slides 1-16); no Theme 1 colors appear anywhere in build.js.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"All headlines and body are Georgia serif (build.js:22, 54); Arial is used only for the eyebrow labels ('Step 1 of 4', slide 7), the footer session indicator and the quote attribution on slide 4 — exactly the small-label exception the guide allows.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Only rounded rectangles, pills and ovals with thin 0.75–1.5pt single borders; no triangles, hexagons, diagonal slashes, corner brackets, drop shadows, stock photos, gradient backgrounds or rotated/outlined text on any slide.","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Organic swooshes appear on 12 of 16 slides (build.js base({swooshes:...})), with explicit brushstrokes carrying slides 4, 12 and 16 — well above one-in-three; classical stippled illustration is absent, which weakens the look, but the swoosh requirement is met.","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The base() helper stamps EVERY + italic 'Consulting' left and 'Compound Engineering — 30-minute session' right on every slide including title and closer (slides 1-16), with no omissions.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Carries the guide's load-bearing substance: the plan→work→review→compound loop with compound named as the differentiator (slides 2, 6, 10), the 80/20 attention flip (slide 5), the thesis quote (slide 4), and the concrete artifacts — CLAUDE.md lessons, dated plan files, specialised review agents, skills/slash commands (slides 7-11, 15); the 0→5 staged path is the one notable omission.","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Not a heading dump — it opens with a POV hook ('AI makes you faster today. Does it make you faster next month?', slide 3), spends the bulk of time on the loop, then adds material the guide does not sequence this way: a live 8-minute exercise (slide 12), failure modes (slide 14) and three concrete moves for this week (slide 15).","scope":"task"},{"id":8,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Each slide has a single organizing idea — slide 5 is one statistic, slide 6 one diagram, slide 9 one point about layered review; the densest slides (11's six artifact cards, 14's four failure modes) are single taxonomies with generous margins rather than competing ideas.","scope":"task"},{"id":9,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Real visual carriers dominate: the circular four-node loop diagram (slide 6), the 80%/20% typographic stat (slide 5), pill rows (slides 9, 13), card grids (slides 11, 14), quote-with-brushstroke (slide 4) and four terminal/file artifact panels (slides 7, 8, 10, 15); only slides 3, 7 and 8 use literal bullets, a clear minority.","scope":"task"},{"id":10,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"On slide 6 the centerpiece loop diagram breaks 'Compound' mid-word across two lines as 'Compoun / d', overflowing the circle's width; additionally the footer wordmark renders garbled on all 16 slides as 'EV ЭRY' because the mirrored E in logo.svg collides with the R.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"opens":"PASS","slide-count":"PASS","no-overlap":"FAIL","render":"PASS","palette":"FAIL"},"dir":"09-pptx/r001","meta":{"task":"09-pptx","model":"claude-fable-5","agent":"claude","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-21T19:39:10Z","agent_version":"2.1.238 (Claude Code)","finished":"2026-08-21T19:50:30Z"},"evidence":{"opens":["deck: compound-engineering.pptx (3817956 bytes)","python-pptx opened the deck","slide 2: 'Text 2' overlaps 'Text 3' (25% of the smaller box, 0.37 sq in)","slides: 16 (want 8-20)","render: 16 PNG(s) in work/_screenshots"],"palette":["palette: theme=consulting across 16 slide(s); signature=3.06% (floor 0.40%), non-bg on-palette=73% (floor 60%)","background off-palette on 16 slide(s): slide-01.png, slide-02.png, slide-03.png, slide-04.png, slide-05.png, slide-06.png"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"opens":"task","slide-count":"task","no-overlap":"task","render":"task","palette":"task"},"scoring_version":3},"10-talkform":{"score":71,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":5,"applicable":7,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"There is no landing page at all — the root URL renders a bare login card, so landing-copy.txt reads \"Talkform / Log in / Email / Password\" with no headline and no hook.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"The interface is the default AI look the failure mode names: violet #7c5cff accents on a near-black #0f1115 background, a radial violet gradient and a violet glowing orb (0 0 80px rgba(124,92,255,.35)) on the interview screen, system-default type, and unstyled native selects/checkbox in the builder.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"The builder defines typed, required-flagged fields with Typeform refs/ids, the interviewer's system prompt enumerates that specific form's fields with per-type constraints, and record_answer coerces spoken values into Typeform answer objects persisted per-turn to the form's response.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"boots":"PASS","really-calls-api":"PASS","auth-exists":"PASS","screenshots":"PASS"},"dir":"10-talkform/r001","meta":{"task":"10-talkform","model":"claude-fable-5","agent":"claude","rep":"1","web":"true","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-21T19:00:04Z","agent_version":"2.1.238 (Claude Code)","finished":"2026-08-21T19:26:19Z"},"evidence":{"auth-exists":["PASS: signup/login page with credential fields (submitted=True, looked authenticated after=True)"],"screenshots":["landing.png, builder.png, interview.png"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"boots":"task","really-calls-api":"task","auth-exists":"task","screenshots":"task"},"scoring_version":3},"11-hoboken-map":{"score":75,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":6,"applicable":8,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"index.html is a single self-contained Leaflet page loading only public CDN JS/CSS and OSM tiles, and the screenshot shows labeled category pills, named place cards with plain-English descriptions, search, and gem-score toggles — no build step, server, or raw data dumps.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"priors.json assigns G/M/N tiers to every place and METHODOLOGY.md fixes formula plus nine pass/fail predictions, both SHA-256-locked in PREREGISTRATION_LOCK.txt before collection (hashes verify), and VALIDATION.md reports an honest 4-of-9 miss with disagreements listed rather than restating the scores.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Spot-checked Lisa's Italian Deli (901 Park Ave, top-ranked gem), Fiore's House of Quality (414 Adams St), Carlo's Bake Shop (95 Washington St), Church Square Park (400 Garden St), and Liberty Science Center (Jersey City) — all real with addresses and coordinates matching their actual locations.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"renders":"PASS","categories":"PASS","artifacts":"PASS","reproducible":"FAIL","gems-vs-traps":"FAIL"},"dir":"11-hoboken-map/r001","meta":{"task":"11-hoboken-map","model":"claude-fable-5","agent":"claude","rep":"1","web":"true","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-21T19:00:19Z","agent_version":"2.1.238 (Claude Code)","finished":"2026-08-21T19:38:06Z"},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"renders":"task","categories":"task","artifacts":"task","reproducible":"task","gems-vs-traps":"task"},"scoring_version":3},"12-roleplay-interview":{"score":56,"gate_failed":false,"needs_human":false,"passed":9,"applicable":16,"judge":[{"id":1,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Lands multiple anchors: expansive view of who a developer is, his own non-CS art-school route in (\"I came into tech from a fine-arts background... I was one of the people who wasn't supposed to\" vs. real \"I wrote code to pay for art school... before I would have ever called myself a dev\"), and the on-ramp framing (\"the workflow itself has to be the on-ramp\" vs. \"make sure there's always an on-ramp\"), with focus still on developers.","scope":"task"},{"id":2,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Hits the maintainer-control anchor: \"AGENTS.md — source-controlled rules and guardrails that live in the repo, so a maintainer can tell an agent what's in bounds before it opens anything\" vs. real \"giving maintainers more tools to decide... provide tools to open source maintainers, but really leave them in control\" / \"I can go in and set exactly what I want to allow\"; contradicts no anchor.","scope":"task"},{"id":3,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Near-verbatim match on two anchors: \"In all of 2025 GitHub saw roughly one billion commits... The linear extrapolation is 14 billion for the year; I've said publicly that growth won't stay linear\" vs. real \"there's a billion commits on GitHub for the full year. We're on track to be 14 billion if the growth is linear this year, which it will not be.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":4,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Despite abstaining on usage-based pricing, it does not stop there and lands the real binding constraint: \"GitHub stays the home for every developer, including the ones who are just starting and have no budget. Whatever the pricing model becomes, it has to satisfy that\" vs. real \"I want you to have a great core GitHub experience... I need to make sure you, the dev, have what you need\"; also mirrors \"I don't think we know, like, yet\" with \"I don't have a public position.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":5,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Declines the role entirely (\"I'm not going to characterize a marketing remit\") and pivots to MUST/SHOULD/COULD, delegation and Think Week; none of the real anchors appear — no 13 years/engineer, no \"we're not building for the buyers, we're building for the developers,\" no continuing as COO while looking across all Microsoft developer tooling, no Build-in-SF example.","scope":"task"},{"id":6,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Explicit abstention (\"I can't confirm that... This answer is an explicit abstention\") where the real answer confirmed it (\"It's the first Build that I think, by intention, we've focused on having speakers from the community... in the keynote\"); the offered reason is product-level multi-vendor agent choice, not \"software development is a team sport\"/no one company answers every question/devs want the outside perspective.","scope":"task"},{"id":7,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Matches the choice anchor and the partner-with-everyone anchor: \"any agent, from any provider... If you're a developer you get choice\" and Anthropic/OpenAI/Google/Cognition/xAI inside GitHub vs. real \"we care a lot about like developer choice... we're also continuing to partner with Anthropic and OpenAI and Google... That choice is core.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":8,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Lands the core reason: \"dogfooding that turns into 'you may only use the thing we make' fails the test in the other direction, because you stop learning what the best tools actually feel like\" vs. real \"we all are using a variety of tools because otherwise you lose track... you're too interested in your own work\" and \"I want to know why a dev would pick these tools.\"","scope":"task"},{"id":9,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Answers with the prioritization framework (\"I write priorities as MUSTs, SHOULDs, and COULDs... no SHOULD or COULD gets to undermine a MUST\"), bounded delegation and Think Week; none of the real anchors — many concurrent agent sessions as the short-term bet, token economics and improving/local models, personalization-context-memory-fine-tuning as the durable truth, \"completing a thought for you\" — appear.","scope":"task"},{"id":10,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Pure abstention: \"'hill climbing' isn't a term I've used in anything public... I can't give you the origin story\"; misses every anchor (usage/thumbs-up-down data improving the models, weekly hill-climbing reviews of hard vs. soft measures, giving everyone a hill-climbing machine via frontier tuning, \"magic parlor trick,\" climb-improve-new-eval-repeat).","scope":"task"},{"id":11,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Abstains (\"no answer on the specific\") and offers only usage-growth scale plus the MUST guardrail; neither of the real mechanisms — frontier-tuned models that know you, and automatic model selection via the Copilot auto model router with task intent / Foundry's API-level router — nor the \"everyone picks the expensive model of the day\" cost diagnosis appears.","scope":"task"},{"id":12,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"Offers \"the same brief goes to a person or an agent\" and AGENTS.md as \"onboarding docs for software\"; the real answer was entirely about his own self-improvement loop — a walled-off Claude he named Baxter reading everything he writes, a daily comms report (\"Kyle, you keep saying this\"), humans taking critical feedback better from robots, and a backward-looking seven-day email/Slack review. No overlap in substance.","scope":"task"},{"id":13,"verdict":"FAIL","reason":"The signature failure occurs repeatedly: Q4 \"There are MUSTs — you can't implement a SHOULD or COULD that undermines a MUST,\" Q5 \"I use MUST, SHOULD, COULD, borrowed from RFC 2119,\" Q9 framed wholly on it (\"The MUSTs are the long-lived layer... a COULD that quietly taxes a MUST\"), Q11 \"the MUST of GitHub being the home for every developer,\" Q12 \"I even write my priorities in MUST / SHOULD / COULD\" — the real Daigle never uses it once.","scope":"task"},{"id":14,"verdict":"PASS","reason":"Consistently says the record does not support a position and marks extrapolations: Q5 \"a dual role... is not in the public record I was built from,\" Q6 \"The persona has no Build-related material... an explicit abstention,\" Q10 \"'hill climbing' does not appear anywhere in the persona,\" Q11 both premises \"undocumented,\" Q8 flags the Claude Code news cycle, desktop app and \"new models\" as unverified; every answer carries a \"Verify with Kyle\" note and no invented pricing plans, conference facts, or role details are asserted.","scope":"task"}],"gates":{},"checks":{"answered":"PASS","disclaimers":"PASS"},"dir":"12-roleplay-interview/r001","meta":{"task":"12-roleplay-interview","model":"claude-fable-5","agent":"claude","rep":"1","web":"false","effort":"high","started":"2026-08-21T19:05:13Z","agent_version":"2.1.238 (Claude Code)","finished":"2026-08-21T19:08:08Z"},"evidence":{"answered":["12 questions parsed from questions.md","answers read from: work/ANSWER.md","Q01 answered, 421 words: The demographics of the customer are changing. A lot of people who may...","Q02 answered, 381 words: How do you help developers deal with the burden of all the extra pull ...","Q03 answered, 324 words: You have a front-row seat to this new agent economy. You said publicly...","Q04 answered, 199 words: How does the business model change? Freemium makes sense in a human-ce...","Q05 answered, 240 words: Pricing leads back into the wider Microsoft orbit. You now have a dual...","Q06 answered, 122 words: Did I hear you say that this is the first Build conference to have ext...","Q07 answered, 334 words: This is a very competitive market, and the pace of change is quick. Ho...","Q08 answered, 209 words: There was a recent news cycle about Claude Code licenses being cancele...","Q09 answered, 354 words: A lot of these ideas are relatively short-lived, while enterprise prod...","Q10 answered, 176 words: I heard the term \"hill climbing\" a hundred times yesterday. Can you ta...","Q11 answered, 196 words: Is hill climbing the answer to stopping a $200 subscription from becom...","Q12 answered, 354 words: I made an AI version of you to practice this interview and found it im...","must/should/could framework appears in: Q4, Q5, Q9, Q11, Q12 (informational, judged in judge.md)"],"disclaimers":["verify-with-the-real-person note attached to: Q1, Q2, Q3, Q4, Q7, Q9, Q10, Q11, Q12"]},"gate_zeros":0,"rep_gates":0,"scopes":{"answered":"task","disclaimers":"task"},"scoring_version":3,"report":{"summary":"The simulation matches several broad views but misses many specific answers and repeatedly uses a framework absent from the real interview.","edited":true,"tests":[{"key":"code:answered","name":"All questions answered","line":"Checks that every question in questions.md has a substantive answer.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"code:disclaimers","name":"Per-answer verification notes","line":"Checks that verification notes are attached to individual answers, not just added once for the whole document.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:1","name":"Customers and roadmap","line":"It matches the real answer's welcome to new developers, including the art-school background and need for an easy way to get started.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:2","name":"Maintainers and pull requests","line":"It puts repository rules under maintainers' control, matching the real answer's emphasis on letting maintainers decide.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:3","name":"Growth in agent use","line":"It repeats the real answer's billion commits in 2025, 14-billion linear projection, and warning that growth will not stay linear.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:4","name":"Usage-based pricing","line":"Although it declines to predict pricing, it matches the real answer's insistence on keeping GitHub useful to developers without a budget.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:5","name":"Microsoft marketing role","line":"It declines to discuss the marketing role and switches to prioritization. The real answer confirmed the role and explained its focus on developers.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:6","name":"Outside contributors at Build","line":"It cannot confirm the Build claim. The real answer confirmed it and explained why community speakers matter.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:7","name":"Standing out from competitors","line":"It matches the real answer's commitment to developer choice and partnerships with multiple agent providers.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:8","name":"Using rival tools","line":"It says exclusive use of the company's own tools would stop employees learning from alternatives, matching the real answer.","v":"PASS","g":false},{"key":"model:task:9","name":"Short trends, long projects","line":"It talks about priorities and delegation. The real answer covered concurrent agents, token costs, local models, and personalization.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:10","name":"Focus on model improvement","line":"It declines to explain hill climbing. The real answer described usage feedback, weekly reviews, and repeated model improvements.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:11","name":"Keeping subscriptions affordable","line":"It declines the specific question and misses both mechanisms in the real answer: personalized models and automatic model routing.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:12","name":"Unexpected agent uses","line":"It talks about delegation and repository instructions. The real answer described Baxter, a personal agent that reviews writing and gives feedback.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:13","name":"No MUST/SHOULD/COULD framework","line":"It uses MUST/SHOULD/COULD in five answers. That framework never appears in the real interview.","v":"FAIL","g":false},{"key":"model:task:14","name":"Admits unknown answers","line":"It marks unsupported topics and asks for confirmation, without presenting invented pricing, conference facts, or role details as established.","v":"PASS","g":false}]}}},"files":[{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":12580,"kind":"output"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/prompt.md","size":118,"kind":"input"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/_screenshots/fold.png","size":152431,"kind":"check"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/_screenshots/full.png","size":3519668,"kind":"check"},{"path":"01-dashboard/r001/work/_screenshots/interaction.png","size":159232,"kind":"check"},{"path":"02-hotel/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":5560,"kind":"output"},{"path":"02-hotel/r001/work/prompt.md","size":557,"kind":"input"},{"path":"03-writeup/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":12168,"kind":"output"},{"path":"03-writeup/r001/work/prompt.md","size":1761,"kind":"input"},{"path":"04-thematic/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":13934,"kind":"output"},{"path":"04-thematic/r001/work/prompt.md","size":127,"kind":"input"},{"path":"05-showrunner/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":2639,"kind":"output"},{"path":"05-showrunner/r001/work/prompt.md","size":3574,"kind":"input"},{"path":"06-execercise/r001/work/prompt.md","size":421,"kind":"input"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/prompt.md","size":350,"kind":"input"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-01.png","size":508425,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-02.png","size":408729,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-03.png","size":427897,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-04.png","size":500126,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-05.png","size":519294,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-06.png","size":491353,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-07.png","size":460173,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-08.png","size":416550,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-09.png","size":483593,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-10.png","size":450659,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-11.png","size":434210,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-12.png","size":533127,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-13.png","size":513578,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-14.png","size":425206,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-15.png","size":486034,"kind":"check"},{"path":"09-pptx/r001/work/_screenshots/slide-16.png","size":529200,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":5003,"kind":"output"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/prompt.md","size":382,"kind":"input"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/auth-after.png","size":29060,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/auth.png","size":21414,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/builder.png","size":85862,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/interview.png","size":190031,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/landing-full.png","size":15897,"kind":"check"},{"path":"10-talkform/r001/work/_screenshots/landing.png","size":15897,"kind":"check"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":9973,"kind":"output"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/prompt.md","size":1643,"kind":"input"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/_screenshots/full.png","size":1241006,"kind":"check"},{"path":"11-hoboken-map/r001/work/_screenshots/map.png","size":1241006,"kind":"check"},{"path":"12-roleplay-interview/r001/work/ANSWER.md","size":27144,"kind":"output"},{"path":"12-roleplay-interview/r001/work/prompt.md","size":1956,"kind":"input"},{"path":"06-execercise/r001/work/AV/README.md","size":8074,"kind":"output"}],"avg":79}],"reports":[],"tasks":{"01-dashboard":{"prompt":"I want you to build a static html NPS dashboard and pick out interesting insights after doing analysis of the comments","questions":[{"id":1,"title":"AI-slop design.","detail":"Look at `fold.png` and `full.png`. FAIL if the dashboard looks like generic AI-generated design — the reviewer's words: \"we should definitely weigh it down if it's purple-black dark mode,\" and \"at the very least, like it shouldn't look like a Vibe Slop, like purple dark mode.\" The specific tell is a purple-on-black…"},{"id":2,"title":"Typography.","detail":"Look at `fold.png` and `full.png`. FAIL if the type is unconsidered or hard to read — the reviewer's words: \"the typography. Like did it pick like good fonts? ..."},{"id":3,"title":"Decision-useful insight.","detail":"Read the insights section(s) of the dashboard. FAIL if every stated insight is arithmetic restated — counts, percentages, averages, or \"X% are promoters\" phrased as a finding — with nothing that would help someone decide. The bar, in the reviewer's words: \"would this actually be useful for me if I was ..."},{"id":4,"title":"Key information above the fold.","detail":"Look at `fold.png` only. FAIL if the headline NPS number and the promoter/passive/detractor breakdown are not both visible without scrolling. The reviewer's words: \"does it, does it like put the important information above the fold? ... That's the main thing for me.\""},{"id":5,"title":"The headline earns its place.","detail":"Look at `fold.png` and read the dashboard's own top-level title/headline — the line the page leads with, not the browser tab title and not a section heading. This asks two things of one line, and FAILs if either is missing. It must (a) say what this particular data showed, and (b) be worth reading."}],"checks":{"renders":"the dashboard loads in a headless browser with no console error and paints at least 40 characters of text. Cannot pass without Playwright installed.","nps-correct":"the page says \"NPS\" or \"net promoter\", and the NPS computed from the source CSV appears on it within 0.15. Missing source data fails closed.","distribution-shown":"\"promoter\", \"passive\" and \"detractor\" all appear, and all three groups carry either their raw count (within 0.01) or their share (within 0.2 of a percentage point). Missing source data fails closed.","interactive":"driving a real control -- text/search input, select, button or tab -- changes what the page displays. FAIL when the page could not be driven at all."},"script":false},"02-hotel":{"prompt":"I'm delivering a claude code workshop in Miami. I am working out of a friend's office in South Beach (Miami Beach). The actual client workshop is in Wynwood. I arrive at 2pm on Thursday and immediately have calls, and the workshop is the next day in the morning. We will probably want to find somewhere to meet the client for drinks / food that night before the workshop.\n\nStart your recommendation with these two lines, exactly in this format, before\nanything else:\n\n```\nHotel pick: <name of the hotel>\nRestaurant pick: <name of the restaurant or bar>\n```\n","questions":[{"id":1,"title":"Hotel is not too expensive.","detail":"FAIL if the recommended hotel is a luxury, five-star or marquee resort property (the Four Seasons / Ritz-Carlton / Faena tier), or if the output frames it as a splurge. Client: *\"it's not the most expensive hotel where like Ariel would be upset with me.\"*"},{"id":2,"title":"Hotel is not too cheap.","detail":"FAIL if the recommended hotel is a hostel, motel, no-frills budget property, or is framed as the cheap option. Client: *\"but it's, but it's also not a shit hotel… Uh, whereas I'd, I'd be upset with it.\"*"},{"id":3,"title":"Hotel has taste.","detail":"FAIL if the hotel pick is an interchangeable corporate chain with no character (the Hilton Garden Inn / Courtyard / Holiday Inn tier), even when the price band is right."},{"id":4,"title":"Venue has taste and is client-worthy.","detail":"Judge the drinks/dinner pick **only** — this question and question 3 are deliberately separate, because a run can get the hotel right and the venue wrong, or the reverse. Score each on its own evidence and do not let a verdict on one carry into the other."},{"id":5,"title":"Logistics are coherent with the stated schedule.","detail":"The schedule is fixed: arrives 2pm Thursday, calls immediately, works out of the South Beach office, drinks/food with the client Thursday evening, workshop in Wynwood Friday morning. FAIL only if the plan contradicts it — e.g."},{"id":6,"title":"It is not trying too hard.","detail":"The bar, in the reviewer's words: it should read like *\"something a friend or a human assistant would give you — just the important details\"*. FAIL if the output pads with work nobody asked for: an assumptions list, Uber fare calculations, minute-by-minute travel math, weather, contingency trees, or research like…"}],"checks":{"exists":"a recommendation document of >= 30 words was produced","not-verbose":"the recommendation documents come to <= 1,000 words in total. This is a trip plan, not an essay.","concrete":"both lines the prompt requires verbatim are present and name something -- \"Hotel pick: X\" and \"Restaurant pick: Y\" -- rather than being empty or a placeholder."},"script":false},"03-writeup":{"prompt":"Hey, I'm trying to write a post on my experience with Every Consulting. The consulting so far, I just joined as the head of tech consulting. I didn't tell you who runs consulting. I'm going to provide a transcript of me talking about my experience. I was also going to provide a tweet, which is just a list of the learnings that I've had so far for companies that were struggling to adopt AI. It was in response to Sam Par, who was asking, \"How is everyone getting team adoption for Claude? How do you get your team to actually use it effectively without spending all their time on Twitter and learning?\"\n\nI need to write this in my writing style. I've included some writing of my own as a sample. I also have included a post on consulting at Every, so from in Natalia, you get a sense of what consulting looks like at Every. But yeah, focus mostly on the specifics of the interview that I provided with the context of that tweet. \n\nhttps://x.com/hammer_mt/status/2032591631413567873?s=20\n\nLearnings:\n- buy the model direct not 3rd party tools \n- raise the ceiling not the floor\n- workshops with 50%+ build time\n- assign impossible tasks\n- mandatory AI note taking + MCP connector\n- map workflows and systematically automate\n- train people to be managers (of agents)\n\nIn response to: \nhttps://x.com/thesamparr/status/2032477081695584670 \nHow is everyone getting team adoption for Claude? \n\nI spent a lot of time on Twitter, as do you. We see all this AI stuff popping up. We're on top of it, or at least sorta. I know what's going on and are testing all these fringe ideas. \n\nBut how are all you people getting your team to actually use it effectively without spending all their time on Twitter and learning, which we know they won't and probably shouldn't be?\n","questions":[{"id":1,"title":"Does the post read as written by a person rather than by a model, at the sentence level?","detail":"The author's standard: \"does it sound like AI? Are there AI tells? ... maybe just the main eval, to be honest, is like, does it sound human, uh, given... I've given it a lot of human context, right? ... so it should be able to write in a, in a human way. ..."},{"id":2,"title":"Is the post free of mechanical structural symmetry?","detail":"FAIL if every section is built to the same template — bolded label, one setup sentence, one example, one tidy closing line — so the shape of the writing repeats rather than following what each learning actually needs."},{"id":3,"title":"Does the voice match `sample.md`?","detail":"FAIL if the post could have been written by any business blogger — the sample is first person, plain, opinionated, and argues through concrete examples; a post in generic thought-leadership register fails even if the content is correct."},{"id":4,"title":"Do the transcript's specifics survive into the post?","detail":"FAIL if any section states the learning as generic advice with the transcript's concrete detail stripped out — e.g. the Granola MCP, Boris Cherny on under-resourcing teams, one blog post a week versus one a day, $200 a month versus $5,000 of tokens, AI-forward people co-opted as TAs, one course project per person."},{"id":5,"title":"Is everything in the post traceable to the transcript, the tweet, or the prompt?","detail":"The author's standard: \"a bad model would ... make up new things that I didn't include in the transcript.\" FAIL if any fact, statistic, client, anecdote, quotation, or named person appears that is not in the supplied material."},{"id":6,"title":"Does the post carry the tweet itself, so the reader never has to leave the page?","detail":"The author's standard: \"does it include the text of the tweet? I really-- I like it when it does, uh, because, uh, it shows the actual context of, uh, they don't have to click off to, to read it.\" FAIL if the seven learnings or Sam Parr's question are only linked to, alluded to, or paraphrased away rather than…"}],"checks":{"exists":"a post document exists in the output dir (>= 200 words)","tweet-included":"3+ of the tweet's seven learnings appear in the post","not-verbose":"within all three caps calibrated off sample.md: <= 2,400 words in total, a mean prose paragraph of <= 65 words, and <= 10% of paragraphs over 100 words"},"script":false},"04-thematic":{"prompt":"help me synthesize what to focus on in our AI engineering training for this company based on meeting notes with three engineers","questions":[{"id":1,"title":"Every theme is deep enough to teach.","detail":"Mike's bar: \"these are actually topics that you could do a whole training on.\" FAIL if any single theme is a pleasant-sounding course name that is not really a real topic — a label you could not build a session's worth of exercises, demos and decisions around."},{"id":2,"title":"No shallow echo.","detail":"FAIL if any theme \"just repeats a theme it heard in the document without thinking about whether there's enough material there for a training.\" Mike's canonical fail is a theme like \"how to build your company context\" — \"Okay, but that's like... What would you actually teach there, right?"},{"id":3,"title":"Every theme is grounded in what the three engineers said.","detail":"FAIL if any theme cannot be traced to specific material in `context.md` — a generic AI-training theme bolted on that the interviews do not support, or a claim about Northcove that no engineer made. Being a good idea in general is not grounding."},{"id":4,"title":"The synthesis uses all three interviews.","detail":"FAIL if the themes are effectively a summary of one engineer's interview, with the other two contributing nothing distinct. Nina, Ben and Raj sit at different altitudes (hands-on feature work, power-user workflows, org-wide constraints) and the synthesis should show it."},{"id":5,"title":"It is a set of priorities, not a catalogue.","detail":"FAIL if the output lists themes without any signal about what matters most for this company — no ordering, no emphasis, no reasoning about which gaps are urgent. A flat, undifferentiated list of equally-weighted topics fails; the ask was \"what to focus on.\""}],"checks":{"exists":"a synthesis document of >= 100 words was produced","theme-count":"it groups its findings into at least 3 themes. FAIL when no theme structure can be parsed out of it at all -- see the ladder in pick_themes for what counts as one."},"script":false},"05-showrunner":{"prompt":"Hi, I need to create a modified Claude code for beginners session, like run sheet basically, run of show, that has the following modifications. So I'm going to upload a few different examples of things I've done in the past, just so you have them to work from. But basically, there's a few modifications for this one which make it unique. One is that this is only using Claude Cowork, so we should not be using Claude Code, either in the desktop app or in the terminal, because this team is non-technical. The team are all working in financial services slash accounting for a education company. So what kind of workplace education company called Brightmoor Education. So the sorry that spelled b the uh team is very busy and um doesn have a lot of like time to explore speculative use cases of ai they want this to be incredibly practical and based on their existing workflows. I'm uploading some transcripts from a call we had with them and also just some notes on what I think could work. Specifically, they're interested in... creating the dashboards and specifically they mean just making the information look visibly better like like creating a html dashboard in a nice kind of style from from existing say data that contained in Excel They also interested in doing financial analysis So more of a, you know, like, I guess, a cloud coworker would use Python to do the analysis and then maybe output the analysis in Excel or the input would be in Excel. And then the third thing was like making a PowerPoint where they update the PowerPoint template automatically using Claude Cowork so that they can do kind of weekly or monthly presentations on the data. So that's the goal, is to kind of make it very focused on that. I still want to keep the way that we introduce Claude Cowork, where we explain to it that the difference between Claude Cowork and ChatGPT is that it has access to the file system. It can run code. I think that important But maybe the ASCII image idea that I normally do where I ask it to create an ASCII image based on my location isn like that useful I think we need to make it more practical for them So maybe we use an Excel implementation instead. The assumption is... oh, so they use Snowflake, by the way, for all their data, and that is powered by NetSuite, which is our accounting software. I guess that's by Oracle. So when we create synthetic data, we'll be, for these tasks that we're going to demo, we'll be focused specifically on solving that, solving those problems. So like the shape of the tasks, the shape of the data should be like NetSuite shaped, if that makes sense. So make it very tight run down, make it very condensed and practical. No real like wider theory or like, hey, we're excited about AI things. I think these guys just want to get stuff done.\n So yeah, let me know what the run should be. \n\nsome very specific asks in here\n* definitely non-technical (claude cowork only + claude in excel)\n* core focus on accounting/finance function\n* use cases to demo: creating a dashboard, doing financial analysis, making a powerpoint\n\nheavy focus on practical stuff rather than theory - they're just super busy and want to get stuff done, have heard from friends at other companies you can do it with claude\n\nFor accounting: put financials together, doing reconciliations, identifying trends in data sets, putting together repeatable compliance reports For planning & forecast: build financial models (make assumptions and pull & clean data from snowflake)create dashboards, and publish to executivesAutomate charts on slides","questions":[{"id":1,"title":"Cowork-only.","detail":"Do all attendee-facing steps stay inside Claude Cowork (and Claude in Excel)? FAIL if any step the attendees are asked to do involves Claude Code, the terminal/CLI, git or GitHub, or installing developer tooling."},{"id":2,"title":"Dashboard use case.","detail":"Is there a hands-on segment where attendees build a dashboard from existing spreadsheet data? FAIL if dashboards are only mentioned, described or promised for later rather than built in the session."},{"id":3,"title":"Financial analysis use case.","detail":"Is there a hands-on segment where attendees do financial analysis (Claude writing/running code over their numbers, e.g. Excel in, analysis out)? FAIL if absent or folded into the dashboard segment as a passing remark."},{"id":4,"title":"PowerPoint use case.","detail":"Is there a hands-on segment where attendees update a PowerPoint template/deck from the data — the client's monthly reporting pack? FAIL if absent, or if it is only a demo the facilitator drives while attendees watch."},{"id":5,"title":"NetSuite/Snowflake-shaped data.","detail":"Is the synthetic data used in the exercises shaped like this client's actual data — NetSuite/Snowflake-style finance records (GL export, revenue and budget vs actual, EBITDA build-up, payroll vs non-payroll, campus/entity breakdown, monthly and year-to-date columns)?"},{"id":6,"title":"No ASCII icebreaker.","detail":"Is the opening hands-on exercise a practical finance/Excel task? FAIL if the run of show keeps the ASCII-image-of-your-location icebreaker or substitutes another whimsical non-work exercise."},{"id":7,"title":"Cowork vs ChatGPT explained.","detail":"Does the run of show keep the explanation of how Cowork differs from ChatGPT — that it has access to the file system and can run code? FAIL if that framing is dropped."},{"id":8,"title":"No theory, no AI cheerleading.","detail":"Is every segment tied to a task these people do at work? FAIL if any segment is devoted to AI industry context, the future of work, model capabilities, prompt-engineering theory, or excitement-building. The prompt: \"make it very tight run down, make it very condensed and practical."},{"id":9,"title":"Mostly hands-on.","detail":"Is at least half the scheduled time attendees working with Claude themselves? FAIL if presentation, discussion and Q&A segments outweigh build segments. From the call: \"we try and make at least 50% of it them actually you know working with us to do some of these tasks.\""},{"id":10,"title":"Per-segment timings realistic.","detail":"Could a room of 20–30 beginners actually finish each segment in the time allotted? FAIL if any build segment is implausibly short (a dashboard, an analysis or a deck refresh built end to end in ~15 minutes), or if setup/handholding time for first-time users is ignored."},{"id":11,"title":"Total length fits the booked slot.","detail":"Does the session run about three and a half hours, inside the four-hour block? FAIL if the total is materially shorter or longer (under ~3 hours or over ~4 hours) without the run of show explaining the change."},{"id":12,"title":"Usable as a run of show.","detail":"Could a facilitator run the session from this document alone? FAIL if segments are titles without content — no prompts to paste, no data files named, no statement of what attendees produce — so the facilitator would still have to design the session."}],"checks":{"exists":"a run-of-show document was produced","format":"it parses as a run of show: one coherent schedule, no segment that ends before it starts, >=5 time-ranged rows carrying activity text (md table rows, list items, bold headings \"(9:00-9:15)\", single-clock table rows, or plain lines all count)","time-grain":"segment boundaries sit on 5-minute marks, at most one off-grid -- a schedule planned at :02/:08/:17 is arithmetic, not a plan","timings-tie-out":"per schedule, segments are contiguous: no overlaps, no gap over 30 min, >=85% of the span scheduled, and a span between 45 and 600 minutes"},"script":false},"06-execercise":{"prompt":"I have added a bunch of context on this exec offsite session in the context file and I want you to create a folder for Adrian Vale (SVP Strategic Initiatives, initials AV) with 2-3 ideas he could build, with any synthetic data he needs to build it, in a way that matches his role, with a well written prompt for each idea. Put everything in a folder with his initials. Give realistic file formats for the synthetic data.\n","questions":[{"id":1,"title":"Role fit.","detail":"Is every idea something this specific exec — SVP Strategic Initiatives — would own, rather than another function's job (a marketing campaign calendar, an HR onboarding tracker, an engineering ticket triager) or generic executive-productivity filler (inbox summarizer, meeting-notes cleaner) that any exec at any company…"},{"id":2,"title":"Company-specific.","detail":"Are the ideas built on Aurex's actual situation — its products, the AUSD token, the acquisition-integration program, the payments and digital-asset competitive set? FAIL if the deliverable would read identically with the company name swapped for any other mid-size B2B company."},{"id":3,"title":"Ideas are distinct.","detail":"Do the 2-3 ideas solve different problems for him? FAIL if two of them are the same artifact with different input data (e.g. two dashboards that differ only in subject)."},{"id":4,"title":"Prompt is self-contained.","detail":"Could Vale paste each prompt into a fresh Claude session, with only the files in that idea's folder, and get the thing built without adding anything? FAIL if any prompt has unfilled placeholders (`[INSERT ...]`, `<your company>`), leans on conversation context (\"as we discussed\", \"the ideas above\"), or never states…"},{"id":5,"title":"Prompt and data match.","detail":"Does each prompt name the data files that are actually present in that idea's folder, and does each supplied data file get used by the prompt? FAIL if a prompt references a file that does not exist, or the folder ships data the prompt never mentions."},{"id":6,"title":"The data is real data, not props.","detail":"Mike: \"the thing I look for here is, um, does it, does it create real data?\" Format is already checked by script — judge the *content*. FAIL if values are obvious filler (`Company A`, `Competitor 1`, lorem text, the same row repeated, all-identical dates/amounts) or if there is too little of it to build the thing the…"},{"id":7,"title":"Buildable in the session.","detail":"Could this be built during a workshop session against the supplied synthetic data? FAIL if any idea's core function requires live credentials or system access the exec won't have in the room (a real NetSuite/Snowflake connection, his production inbox, a paid market-data feed) instead of working off the included files."}],"checks":{"folder":"an AV / adrian-vale folder exists with 2-3 idea subfolders","real-data":"every idea has >=1 data file in a realistic format that parses","prompt-per-idea":"every idea has a non-trivial prompt file"},"script":false},"09-pptx":{"prompt":"create a powerpoint in the every brand style on compound engineering, 30 min session https://every.to/guides/compound-engineering\n\nA pptx skill is in `skills/pptx/` — read `skills/pptx/SKILL.md` first. `pptxgenjs` is installed in the workspace, so `require(\"pptxgenjs\")` works from here with no network. The brand guide is `every-visual-style.md`.\n","questions":[{"id":1,"title":"The palette is Every's.","detail":"Theme 1 (Editorial): background Every Black `#121212` (or Warm Cream `#F5F2ED` for light slides), Every Blue `#C0F0FB` as the signature accent, white text, with `#FA7B20` / `#E9731E` / `#C4400F` / `#349361` / `#1324CB` / `#7301CC` as accents."},{"id":2,"title":"Typography is serif.","detail":"The brand is serif-first: Signifier, or its documented PowerPoint substitutes Georgia and Times New Roman. Sans-serif (Switzer / DM Sans) is allowed only for small labels — session indicators, footers, captions. FAIL if headlines or body text are set in a sans-serif face (Arial, Helvetica, Calibri, Inter)."},{"id":3,"title":"No forbidden decoration.","detail":"The brand guide bans, in both themes: triangles, hexagons and other geometric accents; diagonal slashes and hard section dividers; corner brackets or L-shaped frames; drop shadows on boxes; heavy or double borders; stock photography; gradient backgrounds; rotated or outlined text."},{"id":4,"title":"The signature elements are there.","detail":"Every decks carry organic brushstroke swooshes (the E / O / R SVG shapes, cropped at the slide edge, scaled large) and stippled classical illustrations — Greek and Roman architecture, figures, busts, sometimes with modern elements."},{"id":5,"title":"The footer is consistent.","detail":"Theme 1: EVERY logo left, `every.to` right. Theme 2: EVERY *Consulting* left, session indicator right. FAIL if content slides carry no footer, or if the footer appears on some and not others."},{"id":6,"title":"The content has real depth.","detail":"Mike: \"the main failing of the decks generated by AI is still the content is quite shallow.\" PASS when the deck carries the load-bearing substance of the selected case's brief and source material: its important mechanisms, distinctions, evidence, and consequences."},{"id":7,"title":"It picked interesting things to say.","detail":"Mike's question on this eval: \"does it pick out interesting things to write about.\" PASS when the deck makes a selective, coherent argument about what this audience should remember or do."},{"id":8,"title":"One idea per slide.","detail":"Mike: it fails \"if it tries to fit too many ideas on one slide.\" The brand guide says the same thing — \"clear focal point: one main message per slide,\" \"spacious, not cluttered.\" FAIL if any single slide carries more than one idea, or is packed so densely that a room could not read it while the presenter talks."},{"id":9,"title":"Real visual elements, not walls of bullets.","detail":"Mike's question: \"does it create good visual elements.\" Real means: a diagram of the loop, a staged progression, a 50/50 split with illustration, a quote in an organic blob, a comparison built from shapes — something that carries meaning visually. FAIL if the majority of content slides are a title plus a bulleted list."},{"id":10,"title":"Every slide is legible as rendered.","detail":"FAIL if any slide has text running off the edge, text clipped by its container, text over an image or shape at unreadable contrast, or headline and body colliding."}],"checks":{"opens":"a .pptx exists and parses (python-pptx when installed, stdlib zip+XML otherwise)","slide-count":"8-20 slides -- sane for a 30-minute session","no-overlap":"no two text-bearing shapes on a slide overlap materially (Mike's first question: \"Is the writing overlapped?\")","palette":"share of rendered pixels on Every's documented palette, and whether the deck stays inside one theme (needs Pillow)","render":"every slide rendered to a PNG in <output-dir>/_screenshots/ via LibreOffice (soffice --convert-to pdf) + pdftoppm. FAIL when required render tools are unavailable."},"script":false,"original_case":"01-compound-engineering","cases":{"01-compound-engineering":{"prompt":"create a powerpoint in the every brand style on compound engineering, 30 min session https://every.to/guides/compound-engineering\n\nA pptx skill is in `skills/pptx/` — read `skills/pptx/SKILL.md` first. `pptxgenjs` is installed in the workspace, so `require(\"pptxgenjs\")` works from here with no network. The brand guide is `every-visual-style.md`.\n","questions":[{"id":1,"title":"Does the deck carry the guide's load-bearing compound-engineering substance?","detail":"PASS when it explains the plan → work → review → compound loop, makes the compound step the differentiator from ordinary AI-assisted work, and uses concrete artifacts such as CLAUDE.md, reusable agents, skills, or commands. It should also convey the guide's 80/20 shift and staged adoption path."},{"id":2,"title":"Does the session make a deliberate choice about what matters most in the guide?","detail":"PASS when the 30-minute deck selects and connects the guide's most consequential ideas for the audience. FAIL when it is effectively a table of contents—one slide per source heading in source order, without a point of view about what the audience should retain or change."}],"checks":{},"script":false}}},"10-talkform":{"prompt":"build a typeform competitor where the backend is identical to typeform with structured questions and answers, but the frontend is purely an AI voice interview, with the AI interviewer aware of what structured data it needs to fill in for the user, but asking in a more natural conversational way. get it running including auth just ask me for the API keys for the services you need.","questions":[{"id":1,"title":"Landing page hook.","detail":"Read `_screenshots/landing-copy.txt` and look at `landing.png` / `landing-full.png`. The reviewer's bar: \"does it do a good job with like landing page copy? ... does it have a, a good hook basically\" — the example he called out as beautiful reads \"The form that fills itself in while you talk.\" FAIL if the headline has…"},{"id":2,"title":"Design is not slop.","detail":"Look at `landing.png`, `landing-full.png`, `builder.png`, `interview.png`. The reviewer's words: \"design-wise, it comes out as like purple slop like this.\" FAIL if the interface is that default AI look — purple/violet/indigo gradients or glow on a near-black background, generic hero-plus-three-cards with emoji icons…"},{"id":3,"title":"The loop is coherent.","detail":"The prompt asks for a backend \"identical to typeform with structured questions and answers\" and a frontend that is \"purely an AI voice interview, with the AI interviewer aware of what structured data it needs to fill in.\" Look at `builder.png` and `interview.png`, then read the schema and the interview code to confirm…"}],"checks":{"boots":"the app installs, starts, and serves HTTP on a port","really-calls-api":"driving the app through its screens produces a real outbound OpenAI request, by any of the five evidence classes below. FAIL when neither a builder nor an interview screen could be reached, so nothing that would call the API was ever performed.","auth-exists":"a signup or login screen carrying credential fields is reachable from the landing page or the usual routes. FAIL without a browser.","screenshots":"all three of landing.png, builder.png and interview.png were captured. FAIL without a browser."},"script":false},"11-hoboken-map":{"prompt":"# 11 — Neighborhood map + self-validating \"hidden gem score\"\n\nThis is a short multi-turn task. There are **no data inputs** — do your own\npublic web research to find real places. Treat the prompts below as a\nconversation that arrives in order; the interesting one is the last.\n\n## Prompts (in order)\n\n1. My wife and kids and I just moved to north Hoboken — make me an interactive\n   map of family recommendations (playgrounds, food, activities, day trips).\n2. Can you add a date-night category?\n3. What about a tapas place?\n4. Now work on a proprietary **\"hidden gem\" score**. Determine a way to measure\n   it and validate that it matches expectations. Use public data where possible.\n\n## What \"good\" looks like\n\n- A single self-contained, interactive map artifact (`index.html`) a non-technical\n  family member could open and use, with the categories above.\n- Real, plausibly-correct Hoboken-area places — not invented ones.\n- For prompt 4: a genuinely thought-through metric. **Pre-register** a methodology\n  and your priors/expectations *before* collecting and scoring data, then test the\n  computed scores against those locked priors and report how well they matched.\n  Keep the methodology, the data, the scores, and the validation as inspectable\n  files (e.g. a methodology writeup, a data file, a scoring script, a scores file).\n\nOnce produced, the artifact must open and work by double-clicking `index.html` —\nno build step, no local server, no API keys, nothing to install. Loading a mapping\nlibrary and map tiles from a public CDN is expected and fine; \"no API keys\" means\nno paid or credentialed services, not no network.\n","questions":[{"id":1,"title":"Usable by a non-technical family member.","detail":"Look at `map.png` and `full.png`, and at how `index.html` is meant to be opened. The bar, in the reviewer's words: \"It's a single self-contained interactive map artifact, uh, that someone could open and use basically by clicking on the HTML.\" FAIL if using this would require technical knowledge — a build step, a local…"},{"id":2,"title":"Priors were locked before scoring.","detail":"Read the methodology writeup and the scores/validation files. The prompt asked it to \"**Pre-register** a methodology and your priors/expectations *before* collecting and scoring data, then test the computed scores against those locked priors and report how well they matched.\" FAIL if the priors read as written after…"},{"id":3,"title":"Places are real.","detail":"Pick five places from the map — spread across categories, including at least one the output calls a hidden gem — and check them against what you know about Hoboken and the surrounding area."}],"checks":{"renders":"a visible map container of at least 300x200 with >= 5 markers, in a headless browser. Cannot pass without Playwright installed.","categories":"all six categories the prompt asks for are named somewhere in the output: playgrounds, food, activities, day-trips, date-night, tapas.","artifacts":"the run left all four of a methodology write-up, a data file, a scoring script and a scores file.","reproducible":"the scores file is deleted in a scratch copy and the scoring script re-run: it has to finish inside 180s and write the scores back. Missing grader prerequisites fail.","gems-vs":"traps is dormant, not scored: both gold lists still carry the # AWAITING MIKE'S FULL LIST header and are too small to support a valid benchmark. Populate both lists and add a binar"},"script":false},"12-roleplay-interview":{"prompt":"# 12 — Roleplay a public figure in an interview\n\nThis benchmark roleplays a **real, named public figure** (GitHub COO Kyle Daigle)\nin an interview. Because the subject is a public figure and the source interview\nwas public, this benchmark is kept as-is and is not anonymized; the simulated\nanswers must carry their original \"verify with the real person\" disclaimers.\n\n## Inputs (in this folder)\n\n- `persona/kyle-daigle.md` — a distilled persona doc built **only from public web\n  sources** (dated, with citations).\n- `questions.md` — the interview questions, in order.\n\n## The task\n\n> Using the distilled persona in `persona/kyle-daigle.md` (built only from public\n> web sources), answer the interview questions in `questions.md` in Kyle Daigle's\n> voice. Ground every answer in his public record. Where the persona has no\n> grounded position, say so rather than inventing one. Flag any premise or\n> load-bearing assumption that should be verified with the real person.\n>\n> End each answer that relies on an unverified premise with a note to confirm it\n> with the real person.\n\nWrite the simulated Q&A to a deliverable (e.g. `questions-and-answers.md` or a\n`.docx`).\n","questions":[{"id":1,"title":"Changing customer demographics and the roadmap","detail":"(real answer at 01:03) Anchors: GitHub has always held an expansive view of what a developer is; his own route in (wrote code to pay for art school, never called himself a dev); non-developers — legal, finance, knowledge workers — now building with the Copilot app; the focus stays on developers, but there is always an…"},{"id":2,"title":"The flood of pull requests and drowning maintainers","detail":"(real answer at 02:54) Anchors: agentic Copilot code review as the overlooked lever; agentic merge with explicitly allowed actions; for open source, give maintainers controls and leave them in control; GitHub will not be first to set a standard — it will cement one if the community converges (the Mitchell Hashimoto…"},{"id":3,"title":"Why the agent stats are exploding","detail":"(real answer at 05:28) Anchors: one billion commits in 2025, on pace for 14 billion if linear \"which it will not be\"; 17 million agent-authored PRs in March; explicit rejection of the \"it's all slop\" read; not the peak, still climbing — one human plus N agents; investing to support everyone's agents, not just…"},{"id":4,"title":"Does the business model move to usage-based pricing?","detail":"(real answer at 07:35) Anchors: \"I don't think we know, like, yet, ultimately\"; API rate limits are where agent backpressure already shows up; wants to enable the 150-agent power user while keeping a great free core GitHub experience; the free-private-repos precedent as the way GitHub has evolved before; devs get what…"},{"id":5,"title":"The dual role with Microsoft's marketing org","detail":"(real answer at 09:17 and 09:46) Anchors: thirteen years at GitHub, an engineer for most of it; GitHub builds for developers, not for the buyers, and enterprises buying is a happy consequence; he continues as GitHub COO while taking the Microsoft developer-marketing role; the new job is to look across all of…"},{"id":6,"title":"First Build with external contributors and speakers","detail":"(real answer at 10:53) Anchors: yes — first Build to do it by intention, community speakers in primary sessions and the keynote; \"software development is a team sport\"; no single company, GitHub and Microsoft included, answers every question; developers want the outside perspective and say so in the feedback."},{"id":7,"title":"Differentiating in a fast, competitive market","detail":"(real answer at 12:18) Anchors: back to roots — developer choice; the industry drifted from open APIs into an unintentional walled garden, \"a little bit of a mousetrap\"; breadth across the whole of building software, not just code gen or just review, is the real advantage; invest in own tech (new Microsoft models)…"},{"id":8,"title":"Dogfooding versus letting developers use rival tools","detail":"(real answer at 14:36) Anchors: everyone uses a variety of tools or you lose track; his own Mac / Windows / AlmaLinux setup and Saturday coding, running the Copilot app on Windows on purpose; a culture of experimentation across the teams; laser focus on your own thing is myopic and has bitten GitHub before; he wants…"},{"id":9,"title":"Filtering short-lived ideas against long enterprise cycles","detail":"(real answer at 16:46) Anchors: short term, capture the clearly-real thing — many concurrent agent sessions; long term, models keep improving and token economics decides which get used, with capable local models not far off; the durable truth across the whole era is personalization — context, memory, fine-tuning; the…"},{"id":10,"title":"Why hill climbing became such a focus","detail":"(real answer at 19:16 and 20:19) Anchors: usage of the tools is the input that improves the models — thumbs up/down, what gets accepted and how much; weekly hill-climbing reviews of hard and soft measures, because evals can improve while user sentiment crashes; the goal is to give everyone a hill-climbing machine…"},{"id":11,"title":"Stopping the $200 subscription becoming a $2,000 one","detail":"(real answer at 22:06, 22:35 and 23:34) Anchors: two mechanisms — frontier-tuned models that know you, and automatic model selection (the GitHub Copilot auto model router with task intent, Microsoft Foundry's router at the API level); cost comes from everyone picking the expensive model of the day while the actual…"},{"id":12,"title":"Unusual things people are doing with agents","detail":"(real answer at 24:29 and 25:37) Anchors: he does the same thing himself — a separate agent walled off from work data (he named it Baxter) that reads everything he writes; a daily comms report that tells him \"Kyle, you keep saying this\" and offers clearer metaphors; humans take critical feedback from robots better…"},{"id":13,"title":"Does the output stay off the MUST / SHOULD / COULD framework?","detail":"This is the signature failure of this task: *\"it just indexes too much on... this like framework that he has, that he talks about: must, should, could. And like, I— like every single model has failed at this."},{"id":14,"title":"Where the persona had no grounded position, does the output say so instead of inventing one?","detail":"The prompt told the model: *\"Where the persona has no grounded position, say so rather than inventing one.\"* The persona doc's own Known gaps section is explicit that pricing, monetization and developer-ecosystem economics are undocumented, that live operational decision-making is thin, and it says nothing at all…"}],"checks":{"answered":"every question in questions.md has a substantive answer","disclaimers":"the \"confirm it with the real person\" note the prompt demands is present and attached to individual answers, not just bolted on as document-level boilerplate"},"script":false}},"visibility":"public"}